MacsLady
CSI Level Two
Welcome to the thread, Ghawazee! Glad you came out of lurkdom to join us in MacLand!
MacsLady, you brought up some intriguing ideas in your post about the possibility of Mac having a tough upbringing, and I agree with you there. He did mention several times throughout all the seasons about his childhood, but only in veiled references - wanting desperately to belong to something special (perhaps because he never felt a true sense of "belonging" with his family?) And yes, he did say that he "couldn't wait" to join the Marines - not just wanting to belong somewhere, but also wanting to get away from his family as quickly as possible, maybe? And of course he not only joins the Marines at a very young age, but willingly lets them take him away to another country, far far away from his own family. Even the sense of wistfulness, sadness he obviously feels when little Sam rejoins his family in Necrophilia Americana, perhaps not only because he and Claire never took the opportunity to have children, but possibly because Sam had with his own parents something Mac never had with his?
I don't know if I'd say Mac came from an abusive background, not physically, anyway. But certainly I would posit that he didn't come from a very openly loving or nurturing background, possibly with extremely strict, demanding parents who always expected more from Mac than he felt he was able to deliver. I can easily see it... Mac is a solid B student, but his parents want him to get only A's. Mac is an average, capable athlete, but his dad wants him to be the All-Star. Mac is shy with girls but finds one or two who he likes enough to date, but his mom thinks he needs to find someone from a "better family", or this one isn't pretty or polished enough, that one is from the wrong side of the tracks, etc. No matter how hard he tries, his parents think he's not doing quite good enough.
Of course I'm only theorizing on everything above, but it would certainly explain his constant demand - near obsession, actually - for perfection as an adult. He really hasn't talked at all about his actual family, we don't even know if his parents are still alive, do we? Has he ever mentioned any siblings?
I agree that Mac probably wasn't physically abused as a child - he just doesn't have the 'feel' of someone who has, like Adam. But I think what you described - demanding parents who wanted more from Mac than he could deliver, and everything he did wasn't good enough etc, and his parents were strict/not openly nurturing or loving towards him, I think that is very strongly suggested by the way he looked at little Sam in NA - Sam's parents, and his coldness and hostility towards the Astor woman who wanted Sam just because he's a male heir to her family's fortune. Also, in 'Manhattan Manhunt' Mac seemed to sympathize with that young girl who came from the rich family and was 'second best' to her sister who was killed. Also, his words to Henry Darius at the end of the ep, when Henry blames what he did on Mr Endecott his biological father never having loved him -'You want me to feel sorry for you because your daddy didn't kiss you when you were a baby...You're where you belong.' suugests perhaps that Mac had cold/distant parents too - and he didn't start killing people because of it, so he feels no pity for Darius.
Also, in SuperMen, Mac mentions dressing up as a Marine when he was a kid. Kids are usually young - say under 10 years old when they play dress up, which suggests even as far back as then, Mac wanted to be a Marine, and get out. I also agree totally with you about Mac letting the Marines send him to Beirut - that's dangerous, but also far from America. Though he may not have had any choice where they sent him, the fact is if he joined the Marines say around 1980, he must have known it was possible he'd be sent there.
I've also noticed that most of the photos in Mac's office are to do with the Marines, and there's even one of Reagan, I think (the President, and therefore Mac's Commander in Chief when he joined/served in the Marines, right?) - but no family pics that we've seen.
Finally, in The Thing About Heroes, he seemed none too happy to be back in Chicago, and it was more I think than just the stress of the case/stalker issue. And in those flashbacks, it looked like he and his friends were out on that job late at night, and a 14 year old boy from a loving secure family wouldn't be out in a city like Chicago that late, surely? I know my parents wouldn't have let me or my sis out when we were that age and we live in York!
And as you say, as an adult, Mac has a near obsession with perfection (especially when it comes to himself). Re his family - he said in Mrs Azrael that his father died of small cell lung cancer and asked Mac to end it for him and he couldn't do it. But he's never mentioned his mother or any siblings. In a sense, he has even less of a family than Stella does - she has a foster sister at least. Mac's family problems might also explain why he's so close to Stella, if he grew up feeling unloved and like he could never be what his parents wanted him to be, like he lacked a loving family emotionally if not physically, he would identify with Stella who physically lacked a loving family for most of her childhood. It might also explain why Mac picked Danny for his team, and is both hard on him, but defends/protects him. Danny's lovely, but he's a total f*ck up, and in On the Job Mac tells Danny that people (Mac's superiors, I guess) warned him not to hire Danny. Mac's hiring of Danny could be Mac trying to be different from his parents and recognize people's talents over their failures - yes, Danny's a f*ck up, but he's an excellent CSI.
Like you said, this is all speculation, but speculation is fun. And there is evidence to suggest all of it.
And now for a pic, inspired by the mentions of Mac and Sam...
awwwwwwwwwwwwww! Daddy Mac, so cute.
Pics from CSI Caps.
Last edited: