I love that picture Casper. Thanks!
I think there are two reasons why we discuss the fics a bit here:
1) Some of us, who are pretty busy with work/school, don't always have the time to check out all the Forums we would like to. Therefore, posting reminders to fic installments here can be very helpful.
2) We're not really discussing what might have been, we're discussing what we would possibly like to see happen. Those type of scenarios get discussed in most threads in 'Shipper Central'.
I think this thread is a combination of what has happened over the two and a half seasons, plus our hopes for the future.
Rest assured, H and Y will never think we're leaving them.
These fanfics have really been created as a result of Yelina leaving the show. It's a kind of therapy for us.
I do take your point though. We'll try to limit our comments about the fics in this thread. No offense taken, btw.