Harper's Island
- Thread starter Half
- Start date
Trish (the bride) is the one Madison told that Charlie didn't take her.
Nikki is the blonde girl that Sully (the spikey blonde haired guy) kissed (after he saw Chloe and Cal kissing lol) and it was her car that Sully and Cal took to go find the boat Cal rented. Nikki has only made a couple of appearances in the series. So, the character has been missing an awful lot which is suspicious to me. She's the one who found the girl hanging (the girl who had red dye put in her eyes- the one that liked the groom's brother).
Half
CSI Level Two
Ah, okay. There were too many dark-haired women in one small building. I was getting them all mixed up.
I have to admit that, having not seen the show in a while, the first thing I thought when I saw Danny Brooks was "Oh, so the SPD Red Ranger is still alive". I'm such a nerd. :lol:
I have to admit that, having not seen the show in a while, the first thing I thought when I saw Danny Brooks was "Oh, so the SPD Red Ranger is still alive". I'm such a nerd. :lol:
mjszud
Captain
I had completely forgotten about that part! Hmm, that is really suspicious. I guess we can also go back to the scenes in that tiny tunnel -- Nikki would have fit in there, & it had to have been someone smaller than Wakefield 'cause the other girl's dead body was in there too.
If she is killer #2, then that's truly creepy, 'cause that means they've locked themselves up with the real killer, & no one seems to be suspicious of her at all. Sneaky little chick.
He was a power ranger? :lol: I only know him from commericals on that show on "the N channel"... I think the show was called "The Best Years" or something like that. :lol:
Exactly! It should be someone they least expect. They've all suspected Abby's dad, JD, Richard, Shane, etc. But none of them ever suspected Nikki. Actually, none of them expected a woman period. And she let the boys take her car. She volunteered it. It's almost as if she knew Wakefield was out there and would shoot at them. It's gotta be either Nikki or that psychic woman who hasn't been seen since the bachelorette party. :lol: I still say those hands they showed when the two cops were shot looked feminine and do not match Wakefield's or Jimmy's... and definitely didnt' match Charlie's. The only guy who might have hands that tone and that thin is Cal and he was otherwise engaged at that moment. :lol: So, it can't be him. Jimmy's skin tone isn't that pale, so it can't be him either. Not to mention Jimmy's hands are bigger and rougher looking. :lol: Nikki works in a bar and short of getting bar rot (which she probably protects herself from), what she does isn't really rough on the hands. :lol: So, she could very easily be a match. And the psychic flips cards and tells fortunes for a living, so... :lol:
Last edited:
SciFiChick
Witness
So Wakefield's alive and Nikki(totally forgot she even existed) could possibly be working with Wakefield. Blows every theory I had to heck. :wtf: I had forgotten also that Nikki found Kelly's body. She had time to plant that stuff at the scene. With three more eps left, there has got to be a major twist somewhere else.
Also something is still up with Jimmy, he was real insistent that Shane get that gas into the boat. Makes me wonder now, if Nikki, Jimmy and Wakefield are in it together. If Nikki could be Wakefield's daughter and not Abby, and Nikki and Jimmy were friends and 'upset' with Abby for their own reasons, then I could see them working together. Just as JD said, it's all about Abby(and her family). Wakefield certainly got his revenge on the sheriff and Abby by hanging the sheriff much like Abby's mom.
Also something is still up with Jimmy, he was real insistent that Shane get that gas into the boat. Makes me wonder now, if Nikki, Jimmy and Wakefield are in it together. If Nikki could be Wakefield's daughter and not Abby, and Nikki and Jimmy were friends and 'upset' with Abby for their own reasons, then I could see them working together. Just as JD said, it's all about Abby(and her family). Wakefield certainly got his revenge on the sheriff and Abby by hanging the sheriff much like Abby's mom.
Last edited:
mjszud
Captain
That scene made me gasp & put my hand over my mouth! For some reason I thought he had explosives tied to him so I was expecting him to blow up in front of her, then he was yanked through the window & it totally freaked me out. :lol:
I'm still not so sure about Jimmy. I think it's just cause I really do like his character & I don't want him to be on it -- Abby deserves to have at least one person live through all this & be there in the end. All she has left aside from Henry is Jimmy!
So, here's what we have so far with surviving characters (I think, correct me if Im missing someone)
Abby & Jimmy
Henry & Trish
Madison & Shae
Chloe & Cal
Spiky-haired dude, Danny, Shane, & Nikki.
I don't want any of the top 4 "duos" from above to be killed.
Totally random queston -- did anyone else think that Shane looked a little suicidal in that scene with Henry (when he was fiddling around with the bullets talking about his home)? My money's on him being next to croak.
Yeah, I just don't think it's Jimmy. He's the one that stopped Wakefield from going after Abby all those years ago. And the two guys didn't seem to know each other then. I think Wakefield has something planned for Jimmy though to get back at him for that. Whether its killing him or killing Abby in front of him, I don't yet know. But hopefully his plan won't succeed. I don't want Jimmy to be one of the killers. That would just suck. Not to mention it would be very copycat from the first Scream movie when Ghostface (aka Stu) "kills" Billy in front of Sidney only for her to later discover Billy isn't really dead and he's one of the killers.
Though I sometimes get the feeling that they may kill off Trish and Jimmy or kill off Trish and have Jimmy be one of the killers so Henry and Abby can get together. :lol: But being that there are only three more shows left and no second season planned, I very much doubt that. :lol:
Spikey haired dude is named Sully.
Why are there so many people with S names on this show? :lol: Wasn't the blonde girl with the dog named Shelly? :lol: And why are there so many names with a "y" in the end or a "y" sound? I mean: Kelly, (possibly Shelly), Danny, Nikki, Henry, Abby, Jimmy, Charlie, Maggie, etc. And Maddy is short for Madison though I don't believe anyone's called her Maddy. :lol:Oh, I wonder what happened to that couple who found Cal's ring. Maybe that man is Wakefield's partner. :lol: And he's looking for some revenge against Cal and Chloe. :lol:
Me either. Well, I wouldn't mind for Chloe getting killed except for the fact that it would hurt poor Cal. :lol: Sully was a little better in last night's ep, but he's been a jerk way too much.
Shane needs to be history like two weeks ago. :lol: Or he needs to be the other killer. I mean, who is gonna suspect a guy who was locked up during most of the murders? And just when he gets out of jail his rival (for Kelly) and longtime nemesis (for lack of a better word) JD gets killed. Coincidence or clue?
What if there are/were more than two killers and what if Richard was one of them (or was in on helping in some small way cause he wanted Wellington dead)? Now that would be a twist no one would expect!
Last edited:
SciFiChick
Witness
Oh now that would be a really good twist. The sheriff did say that when the trinity candle would be lit someone had to know that Wellington would be standing in that very spot. That would be really interesting. He could use the other murders to cover up what he did. Plus I think he did try to scare Trish by activating the cover on the pool when she was swimming the night of her bridal shower.
mjszud
Captain
Richard?? What motive does he have though? If it's all about Abby then I don't see how he'd make any sense being involved. Plus, he was axed & tied to the tree, so why would he have been killed if he was part of it. Listen to me sounding like an investigator :lol: I watch too much CSI, & I probably have no idea what Im talking about but I don't care.
I just think this whole "child" thing from Wakefield must be part of the story, & if it isn't Abby, then surely it's one of the castmembers who is closely linked to her. Nikki seems to make the most sense to me.
I just think this whole "child" thing from Wakefield must be part of the story, & if it isn't Abby, then surely it's one of the castmembers who is closely linked to her. Nikki seems to make the most sense to me.
Wasn't Nikki in the wedding party? If so, then she would've known Wellington would be standing in that spot, unlike Jimmy who would likely to have just been invited but not actually in the wedding party.
Maybe he cut a deal with Wakefield that if Wakefield left his wife and daughter alone, he'd keep his secret and let him kill whomever else he wished as long as Richard himself got to be the one to kill Wellington. I don't think Richard killed anyone else though. Just Wellington... and he had motive for that. But then somehow Wakefield broke his end of the deal and killed Richard because Wakefield doesn't like being told what to do. :lol:
I too think Richard set up that whole thing with Trish and the pool so that he could be the one to save her... thinking it would make her indebted to him and therefore make her stay quiet about his affair with Katherine. :lol:
Half
CSI Level Two
It would be really funny if we're concentrating on Wakefield's child and said child has absolutely nothing to do with the plot past being Abby's half-sibling. XD
I really don't want it to be Jimmy. Even if that's, like, too "happily ever after" or whatever, I just don't want it to be him. Besides, the promo implied that Jimmy was the other killer. Therefore, it cannot be him because this is a show on CBS, and CBS promos always lie. :lol:
I really don't want it to be Jimmy. Even if that's, like, too "happily ever after" or whatever, I just don't want it to be him. Besides, the promo implied that Jimmy was the other killer. Therefore, it cannot be him because this is a show on CBS, and CBS promos always lie. :lol:
Whoh. OK, so definitely don't read my next stuff unless you want to be seriously spoiled for the episode...
Alright, I feel totally vindicated about Jimmy- I knew he was involved! Unless... it's just a big ruse to make us think he's involved and it will turn out he's not... :lol:
And holy crap- Wakefield killed Cal! I was sure they'd keep him alive. And Chloe surprised me with her suicide over letting Wakefield get her. The music in that whole scene worked really well too.
Also, she may have the creepy eyes, but that's all she's got- that little actress playing Madison sucks, and she just keeps getting worse. Pfffft.
I'm still in shock. Not CAL!
And holy crap- Wakefield killed Cal! I was sure they'd keep him alive. And Chloe surprised me with her suicide over letting Wakefield get her. The music in that whole scene worked really well too.
Also, she may have the creepy eyes, but that's all she's got- that little actress playing Madison sucks, and she just keeps getting worse. Pfffft.
I'm still in shock. Not CAL!
Last edited: