Bring Back Louie!

CSINYMIA000 said:
1. Yes, he may be alive - but the guy is half vegittable
Click to expand...
We know he was in a coma at the end of "Run Silent, Run Deep", but there's nothing to suggest that he didn't come out of it (and this is the show with Super!Flack, remember). That's not to say he couldn't be brain damaged, etc--but even so, it's a storyline that never got resolved, and it's been left up in the air for two years now. Even if it's Danny going to see him at the hospital, Louie needs to make a re-appearance for continuity's sake.

If he comes back - he's gonna drag Danny into trouble -yet again.
Click to expand...
That's assuming that Louie would be hanging out with the same sort of crowd. Maybe he's leaving the city to start over, maybe he's starting over and wants to have a closer relationship with Danny in the city. If he didn't change after what happened to him, he'll probably never change, but as with the first point--it's still something that needs to be dealt with.
 
I want Louie to come back.

As a half-dead zombie.

Who eats humans. And is Danny's sidekick.

Wouldn't that be awesome?!
 
It was a tough choice for me. Of course I want to see Louie, but the musical theatre option intrigued me greatly. My love for musical theatre won in the end.
 
CSINYMIA000 said:
I just would like to make 2 points against this idea.

1. Yes, he may be alive - but the guy is half vegittable ;
most people know that if a person stays in come for too long the loose brain tissue - making them hadicapped (to say the least). Bsides the fact that he got beat up to an inch of his life.
Click to expand...

You're assuming that Louie would definitely be disabled in some way; but him being disabled is only one possible outcome. And from the assumption, your arguement for him not returning is basically that a person with a disability isn't worth the screen time. That's extremely offensive.

2. If he comes back - he's gonna drag Danny into trouble -yet again. I think we've learned that - that hangng out with Tanglewood boys is bad bussiness. Especially with Danny's history.You know what they say - better safe than sorry.
Click to expand...

Again, you're making an assumption. They could just as easily have the RSRD incident be the catalyst for Louie changing and bringing him and Danny back together. Either way though, I think it'd be a good story line for the show. Plus, if they weren't going to continue the story down the road they should have given a clear indication of Louie's fate - Dead? or Alive? - at the end of RSRD.
 
^Plus, Louie kind of saved Danny's ass the last time. I think he's turned over a new leaf, or at least wants to protect his little brother.

PerfectAnomaly said:
I think it's a good idea if someone artistic (aka: not me) would make up a "Where's Louie?" picture a la "Where's Waldo?" with the back drop being NY, and we could send it to TPTB as a hint. :p There's also a part of me that would love to see "CSI: NY: The Musical" written by Joss Whedon. :D
Click to expand...

:lol: Yeah, I'd kind of like to see that, too. I can see Danny singing "Walk through the Fire" and what was that song Spike sang? Flack would so rock that. :lol:
 
I dont necesarilly need him back but it would be nice to know what is going on with him. is he dead? is he still in coma? is he awake?
 
Of course, I voted to bring back Louie! Imagine how would that episode would be with Carmine's acting skills *daydreaming*. In my opinion, the comeback is due to happen at somepoint (definitely not in the next 7 episodes). It would be nice to see Louie being in trouble and Danny doing everything to get him out of it, or maybe Louie putting Danny in a trouble position. Anyway, the possibilities are endless (the half dead zombie idea isn't not bad, I have vivid images in my mind of that idea)

The poll is VERY interesting, congratulations Fay, if you gave a whole year I wouldn't have come up with something half as funny :D The musical idea got me thinking a little bit. I instantly imagined Danny and Mac dancing around and singing stupid songs :lol:. And you also have woken up a sudden urge to eat peanut butter.
 
Say what you will. I just stated my opinion (which every person is entitled to). I see what I see, say what I feel.
Thats all.


P.S.

I never assume, because when you assume u make an ass out of u & me (figuratvely speaking).









No offence intended
 
Definitely bring Louie back! And I think he would have turned a leaf if he was ok. I don't think he would just go back to the way he was before seeing as that lifestyle nearly got him killed. But it would be interesting to see, or hear, about that from Danny. It would be a nice end to that storyline.
 
Kimmychu said:
I want Louie to come back.

As a half-dead zombie.

Who eats humans. And is Danny's sidekick.

Wouldn't that be awesome?!
Click to expand...
I put my vote in on that one! Rockin' idea :D
 
I think we should bring Louie back during CSI:NY The Musical episode wherein Danny has amnesia and can't remember who the heck Louie is and Lindsay runs around rubbing her nose (a great departure from nose scrunching, so I am sure she will need an acting coach for this one) and singing to others asking if they smell peanut butter. :devil:

Clearly all this strike/strike over/seeing new episodes off in the not too distant future thing has caused my brain to crack out. Or maybe it was those horrible OT3 stories Fay inflicted upon me. :eek:
 
Faylinn said:
Then again, this is the same 25-year-old that saw The Nines the other day and asked me--in all seriousness--if koalas are telepathic and can control the weather. :rolleyes:)
Click to expand...

OK, and because of this I vote for the peanut butter option. This is the same sister that wants to come to LA in the summer? I say bring her, she's hilarious. That actually made me laugh out loud in front of the entire office... :lol: :D

Oh, right, this thread is about Louie... Erm, of course I want to know what happened to him, but I don't necessarily feel a need to see him again. Unless it would involve another flashback to their youth, and Danny could be dressed in that cap again. That was one of the (unintentionally) funniest moments I've ever seen on NY. :lol:

In all seriousness, we have heard that Louie is alive, and the complete lack of continuity in the RSRD storyline was ridiculous. To have a storyline like that for Danny and then never mention what happened to Louie is very disappointing, to the extent that I have to believe that it was mentioned but must have been cut from an episode later on, because it just makes no sense to completely ignore it. :rolleyes: But, as he was involved in a murder wouldn't he have been arrested and probably served some time for that? Unless he could have done some sort of deal? I just don't see him coming back in a nice, happy storyline, but just for Danny to have a conversation about how Louie's doing or something would suffice. It'd make me happy and would tie up the loose ends of the storyline. Oh, and as long as it doesn't involve Danny crying again (RSRD's second unintentionally funny moment), I like it when he does emotion, but that was taking it too far. :p
 
^You didn't like Danny bawling? :lol: I'm picturing you and MrElsie laughing as Danny sobs. :lol:

But yeah, I agree that it's kind of ridiculous that Tanglewood/Louie was such a huge and popular storyline for Danny and then it just got dropped. There really should be some kind of follow-up.

NOLAGRRL said:
I think we should bring Louie back during CSI:NY The Musical episode wherein Danny has amnesia and can't remember who the heck Louie is and Lindsay runs around rubbing her nose (a great departure from nose scrunching, so I am sure she will need an acting coach for this one) and singing to others asking if they smell peanut butter. :devil:
Click to expand...

YES!!! The perfect solution that incorporates all the poll options. :lol: :D I love it.
 
Dagummit, people, you weren't actually supposed to want a musical! :lol: :lol: :lol:

This is the same sister that wants to come to LA in the summer? I say bring her, she's hilarious.
Click to expand...
Don't encourage her. :lol:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top