csibabe said:
Poll results for page 8:
I picked "other", because I have absolutely no idea what "canon" is, so I would appreciate some help.
Canon is anything at all they present on the show, making it fact. If you see it, and it's there, it's true and it happened, all this makes it so.
So for
Sarah's poll, I voted 'Other'. I was torn somewhere between:
I choose selective canon - if things contradict, like Lindsay's age or Grissom's birthday, then I think it's my decision to choose which one to accept
and
Canon is relative - the writers really have no idea what they're doing one episode to the next. So if they say Grissom and Sara have been together for any period of time, it should be taken with a major grain of salt.
I mean, there are little things, like what
Adzix said about the library curator playing the shooter in Bang Bang, Tina being played by the con's girlfriend from Fahrenheit 932, there being two Ellies, and there going to be two different Lindseys, too. Not to mention Sara's ever-changing apartment (painted wall vs. cinder block, and now this seemingly out of place bedroom?). That kinda stuff you just accept as show technicalities - the kinda stuff you run into in producing film and television.
But it's the written, spoken, acted and
felt canon moments that I have a hard time rewriting in my head in retrospect. Decisions they make later in the show that contradict the more
real moments that the characters have experienced or shared with oneanother, because it is these moments that really make up who they are and where they're at - so much more than any technicality ever would.
It's why I struggle to believe Gris and Sara have been together since Committed. If you take WTG as a standalone episode, and only showed, I dunno, Bite Me, before that (with obviously the large lapses in time to represent where the other episodes were) then sure, I could take that. That progression and those interactions would ring true to me. But from the canon moments we had throughout the rest of S6? I'm sorry, but it's too much of a struggle for me to jump on that bandwagon with y'all.