TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 7 - Texture - FINAL RESULTS UP!
- Thread starter wibble
- Start date
Re: TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 2 - Curves
CHALLENGE 2: Curves – Voting
~ vegaslights, CSIVegasMiamiNY, DaWacko and EricaSJ are using their pass for this round.
Please read this post carefully before voting.
[1] Vote for the top 3 of least quality. You need to include a valid reason for each vote, otherwise it won't be counted.
[2] Any member of this board may vote.
[3] The photographers with the top two number of votes will be eliminated.
Here are some examples of good reasons:
31: The photo is overexposed
44: The subject is slightly blurry
59: Not enough contrast (between colours and/or shapes)
63: Ineffective composition
75: The photo has too many elements/no main point of interest
57: Lack of texture
Examples of bad reasons:
44: I hate the colours in the photo (personal preference)
63: The photo is boring
Here are the photos:
Curves 01
Curves 02
Curves 03
Curves 04
Curves 05
Curves 06
Curves 07
Curves 08
Curves 09
Curves 10
Curves 11
Curves 12
Curves 13
Curves 14
Curves 15
Curves 16
~ Please PM me straight away if you don't see your photo
CHALLENGE 2: Curves – Voting
~ vegaslights, CSIVegasMiamiNY, DaWacko and EricaSJ are using their pass for this round.
Please read this post carefully before voting.
[1] Vote for the top 3 of least quality. You need to include a valid reason for each vote, otherwise it won't be counted.
[2] Any member of this board may vote.
[3] The photographers with the top two number of votes will be eliminated.
Here are some examples of good reasons:
31: The photo is overexposed
44: The subject is slightly blurry
59: Not enough contrast (between colours and/or shapes)
63: Ineffective composition
75: The photo has too many elements/no main point of interest
57: Lack of texture
Examples of bad reasons:
44: I hate the colours in the photo (personal preference)
63: The photo is boring
Here are the photos:
Curves 01
Curves 02
Curves 03
Curves 04
Curves 05
Curves 06
Curves 07
Curves 08
Curves 09
Curves 10
Curves 11
Curves 12
Curves 13
Curves 14
Curves 15
Curves 16
~ Please PM me straight away if you don't see your photo
grissoms_gurl
Coroner
Re: TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 2 - Curves
02 - the photo is too dark
14 - the object isn't completely centered in the picture
15 - the photo appears a little blurry
Great pics y'all!! Fantastic job!
02 - the photo is too dark
14 - the object isn't completely centered in the picture
15 - the photo appears a little blurry
Great pics y'all!! Fantastic job!
Re: TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 2 - Curves
08: The other photographer is a distraction. It draws all my attention. I can see curves as well, but it kind of ruins the picture.
10: I assume waves present the "curves" but those are kind of on the "background".The beach and trees are in horizontal line and it's that straight line tha caughts my attention - not curves.
13: Yes...there is few curves but... what is it? (I am probably a blonde) It's odd somethingsomething and because I cannot figure it out, it's almost as you take a paper and draw a curve to it and send that. I don't want to offend, it just doesn't... work.
08: The other photographer is a distraction. It draws all my attention. I can see curves as well, but it kind of ruins the picture.
10: I assume waves present the "curves" but those are kind of on the "background".The beach and trees are in horizontal line and it's that straight line tha caughts my attention - not curves.
13: Yes...there is few curves but... what is it? (I am probably a blonde) It's odd somethingsomething and because I cannot figure it out, it's almost as you take a paper and draw a curve to it and send that. I don't want to offend, it just doesn't... work.
Muzzy_Olorea
Lab Technician
Re: TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 2 - Curves
13: There's no obvious focus to the photo and I can't tell what it's of which leads me to question its relevance.
08: The focus is on the other photographer, particularly his hand and it's a distraction.
15: Photo is blurry.
13: There's no obvious focus to the photo and I can't tell what it's of which leads me to question its relevance.
08: The focus is on the other photographer, particularly his hand and it's a distraction.
15: Photo is blurry.
Re: TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 2 - Curves
08: Picture seems distorted. There is no clear focus, and the other photographer is distracting
02: Photo is too dark, slightly fuzzy. At first glance, it is hard to see what the photo is actually of
10: while this is a very pretty picture, the focus does not seem to be on the curves. They are too much in the background.
08: Picture seems distorted. There is no clear focus, and the other photographer is distracting
02: Photo is too dark, slightly fuzzy. At first glance, it is hard to see what the photo is actually of
10: while this is a very pretty picture, the focus does not seem to be on the curves. They are too much in the background.
Bev
Pathologist
Re: TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 2 - Curves
08-The post is too angular to be considered curvey and there are too many distractions in the picture. Are we supposed to be focusing on the other photographer or the post? Its unclear.
02-Its too dark. I also found the points too angular.
16-While interesting, its out of focus.
Great work everyone.
Wibble- How long will voting last and when will you be putting up the next challenge? Any idea?
08-The post is too angular to be considered curvey and there are too many distractions in the picture. Are we supposed to be focusing on the other photographer or the post? Its unclear.
02-Its too dark. I also found the points too angular.
16-While interesting, its out of focus.
Great work everyone.
Wibble- How long will voting last and when will you be putting up the next challenge? Any idea?
heartagram69
Head of the Swing Shift
Re: TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 2 - Curves
8 - its hard to tell what the forcus of the picture is, at first i thought it was the other person, but then realised the theme and that it was the wall behind them, the person is distracting.
15 - it is out of focus
14 - there is too much going on. there are way too many straight lines and chunky things, that distract from the curves
good luck everyone
8 - its hard to tell what the forcus of the picture is, at first i thought it was the other person, but then realised the theme and that it was the wall behind them, the person is distracting.
15 - it is out of focus
14 - there is too much going on. there are way too many straight lines and chunky things, that distract from the curves
good luck everyone
csi_fan_uk
Police Officer
Re: TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 2 - Curves
Great photos everyone!
It's really interesting to see how we all interpretted the theme this time. Most people had a similar idea about tranquility but this theme has very few similar photos.
I hate this part but here goes:
8 - The pillar seems somehow distorted and is blurry at the top and bottom. I cannot tell whether the main focus is meant to be the pillar or the other photographer.
2 - The photo is too dark, especially in the bottom third.
14 - The main subject is not properly centered in the photo - it appears cropped at the bottom.
Sorry guys! Great photos nonetheless.
Gah! My last vote was meant to be in relation to photo 14 not 3! Because I chose photo 2 in second place, I inadvertently went numerical and then put 3 next! Sorry - I have edited.
Great photos everyone!
It's really interesting to see how we all interpretted the theme this time. Most people had a similar idea about tranquility but this theme has very few similar photos.
I hate this part but here goes:
8 - The pillar seems somehow distorted and is blurry at the top and bottom. I cannot tell whether the main focus is meant to be the pillar or the other photographer.
2 - The photo is too dark, especially in the bottom third.
14 - The main subject is not properly centered in the photo - it appears cropped at the bottom.
Sorry guys! Great photos nonetheless.
Gah! My last vote was meant to be in relation to photo 14 not 3! Because I chose photo 2 in second place, I inadvertently went numerical and then put 3 next! Sorry - I have edited.
quoth_the_raven
Corpse
Re: TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 2 - Curves
Really tough choice guys! There are some creative ideas on here!
8- Blurry and I can't really see what's in the photo. I actually think the photographer is a nice addition, it creates a sense of realism, humanism but it takes away what else is in the picture.
15- A little too blurry
13- A little blurry and hard to tell exactly what it is in the picture. It looks like a building structure obviously bu there's not enough of it in the picture
Really tough choice guys! There are some creative ideas on here!
8- Blurry and I can't really see what's in the photo. I actually think the photographer is a nice addition, it creates a sense of realism, humanism but it takes away what else is in the picture.
15- A little too blurry
13- A little blurry and hard to tell exactly what it is in the picture. It looks like a building structure obviously bu there's not enough of it in the picture
Drumchik
Captain
Re: TalkCSI LPS #1: Challenge 2 - Curves
*bounces in* I love all the pictures But if I had to choose....
8 - I'm not really sure what the main focus of the photo is. The post or the person.
16 - A bit too blurry
2 - There's darkness and the edges of the building are slightly blurry.
*bounces in* I love all the pictures
But if I had to choose....8 - I'm not really sure what the main focus of the photo is. The post or the person.
16 - A bit too blurry
2 - There's darkness and the edges of the building are slightly blurry.