Spoiler Rumors: What We Are Hearing

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't think it's a battle between Sara and Catherine. They were talking about Marg and Jorja instead. Personally I don't get why every time Marg and Jorja are brought up, people just automatically assume it's a battle between Catherine and Sara.
Click to expand...

Thanks...you are right...it wasn't a battle for me.


In fact, I think everyone on this show could be replaced (yes, even Billy Petersen), just not all at once.
Click to expand...

Honestly, I don't know if I agree with this...what sets CSI apart besides it's story base is that the characters have remained on the show. This show stands different to me because of the cast. Granted I would miss Jorja if she left, but it would not ruin the show for me.

I also read somewhere that WP said that Grissom did NOT want GSR revealed. I wonder why exactly? :rolleyes: And now that it is revealed, I just don't see it being the way it was.
 
i just dont want any of them to be replaced. they are all inportant characters and when you watch a show for seven years, you get attached to the characters...some more than others....the show would be different...so i am going to wait and see
 
I'm confused about someone said about Jorja and Marg in a battle. What it got to do with Jorja and Marg and their characters? Catherine and Sara don't get alone once in a great while, but Marg and Jorja get alone just fine. They just played their parts.
 
it's not a battle between Jorja and Marg, it's a battle between their fans, rather it's Jorja and Marg or Cath and Sara, whenever one is brought up it seems people have to bring up the other and argue about it. It's... annoying.
 
I could have sworn this read "Spoiler Rumors: What We Are Hearing?" Not who is replaceable and who is not, and the battle of characters/actors.

People said they wanted a place where they could post rumored spoilers for the NEXT SEASON EPISODES we thought why not, its not the "Lab" so what could it hurt.

Debating is one thing, going off topic a little bit is one thing, but when this takes a turn from "little bit" to 30 miles off its time to step in with a reminder of why this thread is here. Lets move it back to that reason please.
 
Sorry...I have to comment on this...

it's a battle between their fans, rather it's Jorja and Marg or Cath and Sara, whenever one is brought up it seems people have to bring up the other and argue about it. It's... annoying.
Click to expand...

I'm not battling anything. I also dislike when people assume or say that my intentions are to battle between Cath or Sara just because I compare the two. I actually like both of them.

Anyhow...has anyone heard anything regarding to what is supposed to happen to GSR if Sara is alive?
 
i haven't heard anything on GSR, but I did hear that melinda clarke will be returning, which might make things interesting in that area...
 
i haven't heard anything on GSR, but I did hear that melinda clarke will be returning, which might make things interesting in that area...
Click to expand...

Oh yeah? Maybe that could make it interesting for GSR or maybe they are bringing back LH for as a replaced love interest for Grissom.
 
EricaSJ said:
But didn't Carol Mendelsohn say that TGTBTD was Melinda/Heather's last appearance on CSI?
Click to expand...

she probably said that b/c i think originally in the script LH was supposed to die, but then they changed it, so maybe she said that before they made that change. (and thank God they made that change too, b/c i love LH and if they had killed her off... :mad: i wouldn't have been very happy, to say the least)
 
NicknGrissom said:

What do you mean, they don't have the same depth as Billy and the ladies? They do have the same depth as they do. Without Billy and Marg, there is no Grissom and Catherine, they are the lead of the show. Without Gary, George and Jorja, there is no Warrick, Nick and Sara, they are next after Grissom and Catherine. I can't forget about Eric, if it wasn't for the fan, he wouldn't bring Greg to live. They each have their different way.

If there is no cast, there is no CSI. You might well killed the show. They make the show. Billy is the one that want George and Jorja to played Nick and Sara.
Click to expand...

It's an opinion, of mine , and i stated that point for a reason ;)

For me - those three don't have the same depth of character in the show (nothing to do with their off screen personalities). When I watch that show, their characters just don't come over as strong, simple as that. Thats how I view them, Nick as a bit of eye candy for the ladies, Warick as the slightly mysterious one, and Greg as the comedy element. They dodn't have the same presence or intensity of character as the other main characters. Hence I don't think the show would really suffer if either of them went (not all at once, I wouldn't suggest that!).

anyway, I'll leave it now, cos as pointed out, this is a spoiler rumour thread. I'm sure this has been / will be discussed elswhere, and I'll pick it up there if need be!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top