Double posting simply because no-one else has for a while.
I finally got my letter done. Of course, it's long and verbose because I am incapable of ever being short and to the point :lol: And not my best effort either - I'm velcroed to the computer all day today working from home, after a lovely bachannalian day out yesterday :devil:
For what it's worth:
Dear CBS,
With the lead up to this year’s Golden Globes ceremony, I was once again disappointed, as I am every year, when no mention was made of anything or anybody related to the CSI franchise. In particular my favourite of the three shows, CSI NY. This has prompted me to write to you in hopes that you’ll put some energy and money into a campaign now it is leading up to Emmy campaign time.
In particular I refer to CSI NY. I have long enjoyed CSI and CSI Miami. When it was announced that Gary Sinise had signed up for CSI NY I was very excited. I deeply respect the man’s work and was sure it would be a quality show with him as the headliner. And it is a quality show. I feel, however, that it suffers from being the third show in the franchise, and is treated by CBS without the respect it should receive.
In the two and a half years it has been running, the cast have gelled extremely quickly and are now a very tight unit. It has a definite feel all of it’s own separate to the other two series. The fact that it consistently rates in the top 10 every week, sometimes up to top 5, proves that the show deserves the respect it should be getting and sadly isn’t, particularly compared to CSI and CSI Miami.
In fact CSI NY has become my favourite of the three series by far and it is the only television show in my life I have ever been totally hooked into. While initially I started watching because of Gary Sinise, it wasn’t very long before I was actually tuning in religiously every week to watch Carmine Giovinazzo’s portrayal of Danny Messer.
In a commentary on the Season 2 DVDs for CSI NY, James Whitmore Jr, director of the episode ‘Trapped’, had this to say about Carmine Giovinazzo: “Carmine’s work is improvisational, so real, so committed, and there is not a moment where he is not alive in the space. He is a wonderful, wonderful actor and a gifted, gifted man.” He went on to say that Carmine Giovinazzo is a magical actor, and that watching such actors that are so real with such craft is like watching a good sunset. He further said that “Peter wrote the episode for Carmine, and Carmine came in and kicked the crap out of it.”
All of this comes across on the screen to the audience every single time Carmine Giovinazzo is given something to work with. I have never seen a character so ‘owned’ by the actor as Danny Messer is by Carmine Giovinazzo. He brings passion, determination and unbelievably real emotion to Danny. He has made Danny a real, complicated and passionate human being, not just a character in a television show.
While so far in season there have been no Danny-centric episodes for Carmine Giovinazzo to get his teeth into, ‘Raising Shane’ perfectly showcases his ability to outshine. The episode was not about Danny, but he was truly a standout in the episode. From his absolute loyalty to his coworker and determination to prove him innocent, to being mesmerizing in the scene where he confronts Edward Furlong’s character, Shane, in the bar. The fear Danny felt was palpable. Giovinazzo played that scene so delicately to get a perfect balance between the fear Danny so obviously felt, and his devotion to the job and bringing the perpetrator to justice.
I believe ‘Raising Shane’ would be a good episode for an Emmy nomination. It was a gripping episode, with a strong ensemble feel to it, and a wonderful performance by the guest actor, Edward Furlong.
I also believe Carmine Giovinazzo deserves an Emmy nomination for Best Supporting Actor. It is patently obvious that he gives everything he has to his job, beyond the call of duty. He is an extremely talented and gifted actor who fully deserves the respect an Emmy nomination would give him. He regularly gets more press than any of the other actors on the show and has a huge fan base.
I urge you to get behind this show that really is a superior drama in its own right, and market and promote both ‘Raising Shane’, and Carmine Giovinazzo for Best Support Actor.
Yours sincerely
Julia Driscoll