New Rules - Feb 14/09
The idea of this thread is to have people give honest feedback (constructive criticism), to help you decide what level you belong in. This is easiest if it's done anonymously. Everything said in here is meant to help iconmakers. Nothing should be taken as offensive.
You may now send in artwork at any time to Dragonfly, by PM. If you cannot yet send PM's (you need to have been a member for 2 weeks and have at least 50 posts), you may email it to the hotmail address in her profile. Just be sure to put TalkCSI in the subject line!
You may send in Icons (either 100x100 or 140x140), wallpapers, or banners. You can send them all in, if you want. Each type will be rated separately.
Ideally, you should send in 2 or 3 of whatever type (icon, banner, wallpaper) that you want rated. It makes it easier to tell what level you're at.
When you send your artwork in, please state weather you want people to just state levels, or if you just want comments, or both.
-----------
Ok do to the challenges being put on hiatus - we are going to start this thread to help people figure out what category they belong in.
We are going to run this similar to a challenge. However - this will be anonymous and will be rating only - no voting.
This will be round #1. We will keep doing this for as long as we need to.
I would like everyone to submit 2 or 3 icons. PM them to me by Saturday September 29th at 8:00 EST
Any CSI cap from any of the 3 shows.
No animations
No vulgar words
Please size all icons to 100x100
Please let me know if there are any questions!
The idea of this thread is to have people give honest feedback (constructive criticism), to help you decide what level you belong in. This is easiest if it's done anonymously. Everything said in here is meant to help iconmakers. Nothing should be taken as offensive.
You may now send in artwork at any time to Dragonfly, by PM. If you cannot yet send PM's (you need to have been a member for 2 weeks and have at least 50 posts), you may email it to the hotmail address in her profile. Just be sure to put TalkCSI in the subject line!
You may send in Icons (either 100x100 or 140x140), wallpapers, or banners. You can send them all in, if you want. Each type will be rated separately.
Ideally, you should send in 2 or 3 of whatever type (icon, banner, wallpaper) that you want rated. It makes it easier to tell what level you're at.
When you send your artwork in, please state weather you want people to just state levels, or if you just want comments, or both.
-----------
Ok do to the challenges being put on hiatus - we are going to start this thread to help people figure out what category they belong in.
We are going to run this similar to a challenge. However - this will be anonymous and will be rating only - no voting.
This will be round #1. We will keep doing this for as long as we need to.
I would like everyone to submit 2 or 3 icons. PM them to me by Saturday September 29th at 8:00 EST
Any CSI cap from any of the 3 shows.
No animations
No vulgar words
Please size all icons to 100x100
Please let me know if there are any questions!
Last edited by a moderator:
