Talk LIMS #8: Final Results!
- Thread starter Dragonfly
- Start date
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
Hey folks, I've noticed in the last few rounds that some of the votes have been getting close to personal preference. I'm not pointing any fingers, but in general just try to watch that. I know it gets harder and harder every round, but it's not impossible.
Now, having said that, I still need a lot more votes for this round! Just a reminder that everyone who's participating should be voting please!
Hey folks, I've noticed in the last few rounds that some of the votes have been getting close to personal preference. I'm not pointing any fingers, but in general just try to watch that. I know it gets harder and harder every round, but it's not impossible.
Now, having said that, I still need a lot more votes for this round! Just a reminder that everyone who's participating should be voting please!
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
Least:
07 - Somewhat dark and appears to be oversharpened.
08 - The texture seems to washout the appearance of the icon as a whole.
13 - Nice crop, but the texture somewhat draws attention away from the subject of the icon.
Best:
11 - Gorgeous icon, the frame works well.
05 - Simple yet effective, the texture works well.
Gosh, that was difficult, all the icons are amazing!
Least:
07 - Somewhat dark and appears to be oversharpened.
08 - The texture seems to washout the appearance of the icon as a whole.
13 - Nice crop, but the texture somewhat draws attention away from the subject of the icon.
Best:
11 - Gorgeous icon, the frame works well.
05 - Simple yet effective, the texture works well.
Gosh, that was difficult, all the icons are amazing!
cathwillows
CSI Level Three
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
Gosh this is difficult!
Least
07 - Too dark and oversharpened
01 - The frame is too close to her eyes which looks kinda weird. It's distracting. It would have worked better if it weren't such a close close-up...if that makes any sense...
09 - Looks like not much has been done to the picture itself, regarding sharpening, hue/saturation, etc. The frame doesn't really work either.
Best
06 - Nicely done! The text is a nice connection between the background and the frame.
13 - Interesting crop, you tried something different and I like that!
Gosh this is difficult!
Least
07 - Too dark and oversharpened
01 - The frame is too close to her eyes which looks kinda weird. It's distracting. It would have worked better if it weren't such a close close-up...if that makes any sense...
09 - Looks like not much has been done to the picture itself, regarding sharpening, hue/saturation, etc. The frame doesn't really work either.
Best
06 - Nicely done! The text is a nice connection between the background and the frame.
13 - Interesting crop, you tried something different and I like that!
Miss_Undercover
Judge
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
Least:
07 - the icons looks oversharpened
09 - too dark, contrast is missing
01 - her face is too bright
Best:
13 - it's simply but I like texture and croppinh
08 - wonderful texture and light effect
Least:
07 - the icons looks oversharpened
09 - too dark, contrast is missing
01 - her face is too bright
Best:
13 - it's simply but I like texture and croppinh
08 - wonderful texture and light effect
AppleJack
Police Officer
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
Least
08 - The texture brings the icon out of balance and doesn't add anything to the icon
01 - Her face is to light and the frame is covering to much of her face
04 - The text is difficult to read. I would've made the text stand out more with a darker shadow or stroke.
Best
11
07
Least
08 - The texture brings the icon out of balance and doesn't add anything to the icon
01 - Her face is to light and the frame is covering to much of her face
04 - The text is difficult to read. I would've made the text stand out more with a darker shadow or stroke.
Best
11
07
fo_poozle
CSI Level Two
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
Least-
7- looks a little oversharpened, also there seems to be a bit too much contrast especially over her face.
1- but its cuts off of alexx's face at a weird spot, and is a little distracting
4- the text is hard to read, and blends into the background in certain spots.
Best-
13- i love the crop, its unique and works really well, and i love the softness especially over her face.
5- i love how you made her blend a bit into the background and your use of textures, and the font works really well.
this was really hard to choose :/
Least-
7- looks a little oversharpened, also there seems to be a bit too much contrast especially over her face.
1- but its cuts off of alexx's face at a weird spot, and is a little distracting
4- the text is hard to read, and blends into the background in certain spots.
Best-
13- i love the crop, its unique and works really well, and i love the softness especially over her face.
5- i love how you made her blend a bit into the background and your use of textures, and the font works really well.
this was really hard to choose :/
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
I'll just go ahead and say goodbye right now! :lol:
Hoping to post results tomorrow, but I still need more votes please
I'll just go ahead and say goodbye right now! :lol:
Hannah06_95
Police Officer
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
Arghh, i forgot to get my entry in!! Stupid gcses
Least -
7- bit to dark
4- text hard to read
8- No sure about the texture used on the icon
Best -
11
12
Arghh, i forgot to get my entry in!! Stupid gcses
Least -
7- bit to dark
4- text hard to read
8- No sure about the texture used on the icon
Best -
11
12
Mad_Maxine
Dead on Arrival
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
least
01 frame is a bit distracting and icon lacks the contrast
05 subject blends into then icon too much
07 way too darkk and over sharpened
best
03
08
least
01 frame is a bit distracting and icon lacks the contrast
05 subject blends into then icon too much
07 way too darkk and over sharpened
best
03
08
Joycie84
CSI Level One
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
Least
# 7: A bit too dark
# 1: The border takes all the attention away from Alexx
# 6: The background is overpowering
Best
# 13: Great cropping
# 5: I love the balance between the picture, the background and the text
This was hard, because I think all icons are amazing. I can't do that!
Least
# 7: A bit too dark
# 1: The border takes all the attention away from Alexx
# 6: The background is overpowering
Best
# 13: Great cropping
# 5: I love the balance between the picture, the background and the text
This was hard, because I think all icons are amazing. I can't do that!
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 7 - Voting!
Round 7 Results!
Time to say goodbye to two more artists:
Smokey
csifann1
Thanks so much for participating, I hope you had fun!
Voter's Choice: cathwillows
DragonflysBeenDazzled: egeria
Wonderful icons Ladies, congrats!
Next Challenge will be up soon!
Round 7 Results!
Time to say goodbye to two more artists:
Thanks so much for participating, I hope you had fun!
Voter's Choice: cathwillows
DragonflysBeenDazzled: egeria
Wonderful icons Ladies, congrats!
01: -12
02: 0
03: +2
04: -7
05: -1 +4 = +3
06: -2 +2 = 0
07: -13 +1 = -12
08: -5 +2 + -3
09: -4
10: +4
11: +8
12: +3
13: -1 +5 = +4
02: 0
03: +2
04: -7
05: -1 +4 = +3
06: -2 +2 = 0
07: -13 +1 = -12
08: -5 +2 + -3
09: -4
10: +4
11: +8
12: +3
13: -1 +5 = +4
Next Challenge will be up soon!
Last edited: