Talk LIMS #8: Final Results!
- Thread starter Dragonfly
- Start date
cathwillows
CSI Level Three
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 3 - Voting!
Least
11 - The coloring is odd...the red doesn't fit and doesn't seem to make any sense...
04 - I like the idea. A better fitting text brush should have been chosen.
15 - Again, good idea, but the text positioning didn't work too well.
Best
07 - Just <3 !!!
06 - The icon looks so smooth! Well done
Least
11 - The coloring is odd...the red doesn't fit and doesn't seem to make any sense...
04 - I like the idea. A better fitting text brush should have been chosen.
15 - Again, good idea, but the text positioning didn't work too well.
Best
07 - Just <3 !!!
06 - The icon looks so smooth! Well done
AppleJack
Police Officer
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 3 - Voting!
Least
11 That red on Sheldon's coat looks like it isn't supposed to be there. It looks untidy.
15 The text is too big. There's also a bit of blue from the background on Sheldon's labcoat.
18 Too dark and Sheldon has yellow teeth in this icon
Best
10
03
Edit: I'm sorry! I got the numbers wrong. Next to icon 11 on the right it says '12' but that icon is in the next row. I made the same mistake with icon 15, which I thought was 16. I feel so stupid! I'm glad I checked my post. I've corrected the numbers.
Least
11 That red on Sheldon's coat looks like it isn't supposed to be there. It looks untidy.
15 The text is too big. There's also a bit of blue from the background on Sheldon's labcoat.
18 Too dark and Sheldon has yellow teeth in this icon
Best
10
03
Edit: I'm sorry! I got the numbers wrong. Next to icon 11 on the right it says '12' but that icon is in the next row. I made the same mistake with icon 15, which I thought was 16. I feel so stupid!
I'm glad I checked my post. I've corrected the numbers.
Last edited:
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 3 - Voting!
Least:
11 - The colouring is somewhat odd, doesn't really work with the icon, seems to be red where there shouldn't be?
16 - Looks like very little has been done to the icon.
08 - Seems to be somewhat oversharpened.
Best:
04 - Altogether fantastic icon, nice theme.
15 - Nice effect, text is very fitting, looks great.
Least:
11 - The colouring is somewhat odd, doesn't really work with the icon, seems to be red where there shouldn't be?
16 - Looks like very little has been done to the icon.
08 - Seems to be somewhat oversharpened.
Best:
04 - Altogether fantastic icon, nice theme.
15 - Nice effect, text is very fitting, looks great.
LivingEnd
Lab Technician
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 3 - Voting!
Least
08 - oversharpened
11 - The coloring looks weird; the red of the backround takes the focus away from Hawkes.
15 - The text overpowers the icon, therefore taking the focus away from the subject.
Best
03 - I like the concept. Well done
19 - The coloring is nice and the icon has a beautiful atmosphere.
Least
08 - oversharpened
11 - The coloring looks weird; the red of the backround takes the focus away from Hawkes.
15 - The text overpowers the icon, therefore taking the focus away from the subject.
Best
03 - I like the concept. Well done
19 - The coloring is nice and the icon has a beautiful atmosphere.
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 3 - Voting!
Least:
02 - The cut doesn't look good, it seems to sharp around the edges.
15 - The text is too big and overpowers the icon.
13 - The backround looks too bright and the right upper half of the icon looks kinda empty... a different crop of the pic could have helped with that.
Best:
04 - I just love it... it's very well done
03 - A great icon, everyting fits together very well
Least:
02 - The cut doesn't look good, it seems to sharp around the edges.
15 - The text is too big and overpowers the icon.
13 - The backround looks too bright and the right upper half of the icon looks kinda empty... a different crop of the pic could have helped with that.
Best:
04 - I just love it... it's very well done
03 - A great icon, everyting fits together very well
starzsgirl
Captain
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 3 - Voting!
Least:
2 - Over sharped.
11 - Oddly colored with the black and white and red.
15 - Text is the focus rather than Hawkes.
Best:
7
17
Least:
2 - Over sharped.
11 - Oddly colored with the black and white and red.
15 - Text is the focus rather than Hawkes.
Best:
7
17
Miss_Undercover
Judge
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 3 - Voting!
Least:
18 - Looks too dark
14 - The colourig is too dark and contrast is missing
02 - Too over sharpened, the background are to bright
Best:
03 - Like the idea to to use two pics of Hawkes and the font
07 - Love the beautiful colouring and the text effect
Least:
18 - Looks too dark
14 - The colourig is too dark and contrast is missing
02 - Too over sharpened, the background are to bright
Best:
03 - Like the idea to to use two pics of Hawkes and the font
07 - Love the beautiful colouring and the text effect
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 3 - Voting!
I keep thinking that I can't vote in this, but I guess since I'm not running this round, I can :lol:
Least:
02 - I love the use of texture and the general feel of the icon, but Hawkes is too oversharpened.
15 - Also oversharpened
01 - I understand what you were trying to do with the colouring on this icon, but somehow it doesn't work. I'm not sure if I can explain it properly, it's just... too much, maybe? Or not enough? I'm not quite sure
Best:
19 - Pretty
03 - Love the contrast between the top and bottom. Well done!
I keep thinking that I can't vote in this, but I guess since I'm not running this round, I can :lol:
Least:
02 - I love the use of texture and the general feel of the icon, but Hawkes is too oversharpened.
15 - Also oversharpened
01 - I understand what you were trying to do with the colouring on this icon, but somehow it doesn't work. I'm not sure if I can explain it properly, it's just... too much, maybe? Or not enough? I'm not quite sure
Best:
19 - Pretty
03 - Love the contrast between the top and bottom. Well done!
egeria
This mod is Ready for the Laughing Gas!
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 3 - Voting!
Least
2. Hawkes face is too sharp and the texture cutout is too obvious.
18. The colouring is off, parts of Hawkes face look sunburnt, it's too red.
8. The icon is too sharp.
Best
7. Fantastic crop and beautiful colouring, the text is perfectly placed.
10. I love the frame and the reflected text, the colouring is fabulous.
Least
2. Hawkes face is too sharp and the texture cutout is too obvious.
18. The colouring is off, parts of Hawkes face look sunburnt, it's too red.
8. The icon is too sharp.
Best
7. Fantastic crop and beautiful colouring, the text is perfectly placed.
10. I love the frame and the reflected text, the colouring is fabulous.
roximonoxide
Lab Technician
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 3 - Voting!
LQ
15- That text is extremely loud and so contrasting to the overall softness of the rest of the image that it steals all focus from the graphic content of the icon.
4- A nice shot a merging a couple of images but a city scape is an awfully busy background to layer with someone's face, resulting in kind of a cluttered image. The tiny text also isn't really lending anything to the icon in style or placement, especially with such a busy image already.
11- Not every image translates well to a black and white, especially not without level and contrast correction, resulting in a rather greyed out subject.
BQ
2 - A little less sharpening would help, but whether or not it was, the cutout style looks intentional. The text is handled pretty nicely, so it's not stealing any focus and the layering effects make Sheldon's face stand out nicely as a focal point. Nice job.
19 - The crop and contrast is the best thing about this one but think it might be ever stronger without the text.
LQ
15- That text is extremely loud and so contrasting to the overall softness of the rest of the image that it steals all focus from the graphic content of the icon.
4- A nice shot a merging a couple of images but a city scape is an awfully busy background to layer with someone's face, resulting in kind of a cluttered image. The tiny text also isn't really lending anything to the icon in style or placement, especially with such a busy image already.
11- Not every image translates well to a black and white, especially not without level and contrast correction, resulting in a rather greyed out subject.
BQ
2 - A little less sharpening would help, but whether or not it was, the cutout style looks intentional. The text is handled pretty nicely, so it's not stealing any focus and the layering effects make Sheldon's face stand out nicely as a focal point. Nice job.
19 - The crop and contrast is the best thing about this one but think it might be ever stronger without the text.