Talk LIMS #8: Final Results!

Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4

Tough choice... loved all the icons! good job everyone...

Least

02: There's something wrong with this icon... don't really know what it is... somehow the focus on Riley is lost... maybe you should have made her bigger or lighter... to emphasize her more...

15: Though I like the coloring... that frame (or texture) is a little distracting

04: Too saturated

Best

11: Original crop, nice coloring

09: Nice coloring too
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4 - Voting!

Least:
(Oh gosh, this gets more difficult each round!)
15 - The border effect distracts attention from Riley.
16 - The background kinda washes Riley out, and is somewhat distracting.
05 - The effect makes Riley look somewhat grainy.

Best:
13 - Gorgeous icon, the colouring looks great and the text works well.
08 - Fantastic icon, it all works really well.

Well done everyone. :D
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4 - Voting!

Least:

15- Riley and the text are a bit blurry and the texture/brush is a bit distracting.
02- I love the text, but Riley kind of gets lost in the background.
04- a little too much contrast/saturation.


Best:

09- Nice coloring and I love how you made her eye color standout.
11- love the crop and how the face is smoothed out and the coloring is great too.


Great job, everyone.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4 - Voting!

Least:
4 - Riley's skin looks orange.
2 - She is blending in too much with the background.
15 - The bush doesn't work with the icon and there is no different to tell Riley from the background.

Best:
5
1
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4

Oh boy, they were all pretty good :thumbsup:
Least
15 - The whole concept of the icon is pretty nice, but that decoration is distracting and coveers the best part of the icon. Also the decoration doesn't suit the rest of the icon.
04 - Riley's skin kinds of looks sick because it's too yellow and it gets also too blurry.
05- I don't know whether it's my new laptop (I know it makes everything paler) or not, but probably that's because of the effect on the left....well it makes the rest of the icon too grainy.

Best
11- Absolutely love the way you colored Riley's face and improved her smile's coloring! Grat crop as well. Terrific job :thumbsup:
09 - Love the coloring of the whole icon and, above all, love how you made her blue **envy alarm on** eyes both stand out and match with the coloring of the background! Amazing!:thumbsup:
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4 - Voting!

ETA: D'oh! :lol: I meant 12 in 'Best'. Thanks, Meg!

Least Quality:
15- poor text placement, font choice and general text styling, though the brush/texture is kind of interesting and quite creative.
4- too yellow and overly contrasted, though the text is more tasteful and restrained.
1- the cut-out is too visible

Best:
12- subtle but strong coloring; decent text placement
11- love the crop and coloring, though the text is iffy.
 
Last edited:
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4 - Voting!

HappyHarper, you've voted for the same icon in both least and best. Can I get you to fix/change that please? Thanks ;)

Keep those votes coming! This is a good start, but not enough yet :D
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4 - Voting!

Least:
15 - that brush (?) looks really strange, like it doesnt fit in the icon at all :/
05 - the texture is kinda overloading the icon
01 - the crop seems strange maybe its just me, lol, but it makes riley look weird with on ear missing (?). and i - personally - dont like the plain blue background

best:
11 - i really love this one! super nice crop!
09 - i like the coloring of this one :)
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4

Least:

04 - icon is blurry, Riley looks to yellow and too much contrast
05 - too dark and grainy, the face is too orange
07 - her face is too bright

Best:

06 - love the colouring of the icon and the cropping. Is really perfect.
11 - beautiful colouring and like the idea of the cropping.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4 - Voting!

Least:

10: Looks like there wasn't a ton done with the icon, it could also use some blurring and could be a bit more creative with the text.
15: Odd texture, and the text is a bit wobbly.
14: The text is small and blurry.

Best:

08
02
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4 - Voting!

Least:
4- there's a bit too much contrast
15- the texture is a bit distracting and doesn't seem to go well with the rest od the icon
8- the text is oddly placed, and look like it cuts off the top of her head a bit.

Best:
6
9
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4 - Voting!

Least
05- The image is grainy and the letters run together making it hard to read.
04- The image is too saturated. Her skin looks yellow. Plus it has too much contrast in it.
10- The image is very grainy and blurry.

Best
06- The coloring and font are amazing on this. I love the effect.
12- The coloring is great, and the text works very well :D
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4 - Voting!

Least:
04 - too much contrast
05 - the texture does not fit the icon, and because it's not earased from the face it makes Riley look grainy
15 - the texture is distracting and the icon seems to lack contrast

Best:
6
11
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4

Round 4 Results!

The two participants leaving this round are:

Riley15.png
Teddy Bear Dr.

Riley04.png
Adorable_Crazy

Thanks so much for joining, and I hope we'll see you for the comeback challenge :)


Voter's Choice: speed_cochrane
VotersR04.png


DragonflysBeenDazzled: Axelsonfire
ModsR04.png


Great icons! Congrats Ladies :)

01: -3 +1 = -2
02: -7 +3 = -4
03: -1
04: -15 +1 = -14
05: -8 +2 = -6
06: -1 +7 = +6
07: -1
08: -2 +4 = +4
09: +7
10: -3
11: +10
12: +2
13: +2
14: -1
15: -15
16: -3 +1 = -2

Next challenge will be up soon :)
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 4

Sorry to see you go Nikki and Steph :(

Congrats Axelsonfire and Geni! Gorgerous icons! ;)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top