Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge 9 - Voting!
OK, I stared at the icons for two days now, and
still I'm not sure. Thanks
Meg for another tough round!
:lol:
least
4 - it's a great idea, but sadly the circle effect doesn't work well with this cropping and coloring, it's hard to identify the subject.
9 - nice idea, and I personally like the font you used, further more respect for choosing that screencap, it's the hardest to work with, but as it's already been said:
the right half is too saturated and with too much contrast, so the left side appears to be too grainy and blurry, it'd been better to "wash out" the cyan a bit instead of increasing the color. I hope I made any sense, sorry, it's hard this round.
8 - too blurry and also grainy, and the place of the text isn't the best. Perhaps working with a light effect instead of text would've fit better?
best
2 - I like the whole composition of this icon: crop, use of texture/brush, coloring, great! Perhaps a tiny bit too bright in some areas, but that's a matter of taste
6 - using this capture alone earns applause!
Seriously, I think you chose a great coloring, I like such icons, and also the crop is well done, nice lightning. The text is a bit distracting from the subject, though, perhaps a bit smaller? IDK, overall great work!
