Talk LIMS #7: FINAL RESULTS!

Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Valera ~ Now Up!

All I can say is OMG :eek:

Least
10 - the combination between b&W & the textures is let's say weird.
04 - the texture make the icon even darker
02 - as much as I love the texture, Valera's face is too orange

Best
01 - love the texture & the where the text is placed.
09 - very simple but also nice.

**can I have my cookies now??? :p**
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Valera ~ Now Up!

Least:

5 - too blurry, face and background have alomost the same colour
6 - too bright, very screaming colours
8 - Valera looks too yellow, contrast is missing

Best:

9 - good cropping, it's simply but I like this
7 - love the idea if thr cropping and the background, the fonts fits marvelous with the complete icon
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

Least:

10. It's a really fun background and the black-and-white part itself is very well-done, but I don't think the background and foreground (I think that's what it's called...) really work together. The background overwhelms Valera and makes her look more grey and dull. I think the black-and-white Valera would work better with a much duller background and that the background would work better with a brighter Valera. Also, there's a strange maroon-ish line intruding on Valera's face.

5. The background is fitting and gives her a certain really nice graceful, almost peaceful feel, but she looks too grey, especially in comparison to the much brighter background, and the text is pixely and hard to read. I think if she was a tad brighter and the background a tad darker, it would work better.

6. It's a cool effect with the bright car-type light in the dark, and that really fits with the surprised look on her face, but I think you took the brightness on her face a bit too far, making it harder to really see the detail on her face and making her face blend in a bit too much with the light itself (hope that makes sense).

Faves:

3. I absolutely love the coloring in this pic! It's also an interesting crop and the font has the perfect blend of classiness and sass, making it fit perfectly. The black text over the brighter coloring works well too.

7. I love the texture and the idea. The font and texture make it very fun, and it has a fun feeling of a candid yearbook photo. I also love how well the brighter colors are maintained and still work next to the rustier textured and darker background space.

Still, all of these are beautiful! :drool:
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Valera ~ Now Up!

This was really hard cause they were all excellent.

Least:

10- some of the texture is left in spots on her face
04- too dark
05- a little too blurry


Best:

01 very cool effect on icon
06 nice coloring
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

gosh, what a hards choices I've to do, all icons are awesome, sorry to all talented artists, no one should be eliminated... *wakes up* wait, but this is a challenge right? :lol:

Least Quality:
10 - I think the backgroung doesn't really fits there and it's overkilling Valera
05- The font is a little too pixely and the background is almost in the same color than Valera;
06- Too brightness on it

Best quality:
01 - I love it, the coloring and crop are really interesting!
07- The texture fits really nice!
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

Least:
10. Background too distracting.
06. Too bright.
05. Too blurry and the text is very pixely.

Fave:
03. Nice crop and coloring.
02.Like the concept, nice coloring and use of text.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

Least:
04 - it's too dark
06 - very bright, especially on her face
10 - interesting concept, but the background doesn't really work with grey colour

Best:
01
05

Good luck! :)
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

LQ:
10 The background is too distracting, leaving the focus off.
05 Looks too faded. Also, the font is too pixeled
04 Too dark.

BQ
03
07
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

Least:
10 - I do like the black and white and color, but there is too much of a contrast for the background color is too bright.

5 - There is an over all graininess to the icons and the text is hard to read.

7 - The texture over Valera distracts from the over all icon.

Best:
3
9
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

Least:
10 - background is distracting and black and white face doesn't fit it too well
5 - blurry and too dark is Valera's face
1 - too blurry

Best:
3 - nice bright coloring and cropping
7 - nice cropping and nicely added text
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Valera ~ Now Up!

LQ:

08 - too yellow, not enough contrast.
09 - slightly blurry, doesn't look much differnt to the original, way too plain.
01 - love the idea, but the cropping is odd and the text is hard to make out because the colouring is so dark

BQ:

04
06
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

LQ:
10 - it doesn't really go together ..
05 - it lacks a bit colour
08 - the blue doesn't really fit with the picture ..

BQ:
01 - wow !!
09 - lovely crop and you kept it very simple .. :)
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

Least
05 - The icon looks grainy and pale
10 - I like the b&w but the texture doesn't go well with it. The icon is kinda devided into two parts instead of being one balanced icon
06 - Valera is pretty bright in contrast to the background which wouldn't be a bad thing in general, but she is too bright and you can hardly make out details of her face

Best
01 - :eek: Awesome! Valera looks so smooth and the text is placed very well
04 - Nice sharpness, not oversharpened. The frame texture goes well with the icon and the light effect adds a nice touch to it
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

Least
01 - The icon is way too blurry and the font is very hard to make out.
10 - The texture is distracting.
05 - She blends in too much with the background.

Best
07
02
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Round 8 - Voting!

Come on people, keep those votes coming in! I'd like at least a few more before I post the results :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top