Talk LIMS #7: FINAL RESULTS!

Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

Least:
9 - The crop is too harsh and the text is hard to read.
10 - The insert does not work and it's hard to tell what it is of.
7 - Text is hard to read and the crop is oddly done.

Best:
4
14
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

LQ
15 - too dark
09 - blurry
12 - too much is happening at the same time

HQ
05 - love the texture
16 - looks like a cap from Sin City and i loved everything about that movie. ;)
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

Least
9 - Text is hard to read
5 - Too much color...one of the effects alone would have been good
15 - Too dark...love the blue, but a brighter face would have made for good contrast

Best
13 - I like the color and the "spacey" look
6 - Nice texture and text
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

Least:

10- Text is hard to read and the picture in the circle is blurry and hard to make out.
09- Text is hard to read and a little blurry.
07- Icon is a little blurry and text is hard to read.

Best:
13- Love the colors in the background and the text is cute.
14- Very nice icon. love the barcode, nice touch.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

Least
15: Really dark, which takes away from the many shades (of black and white) that could have added more dimension to it.
10: Unique idea but the text is very difficult to read and it took a while for me to see what was in the bubble. Perhaps if the image inside were darker or more contrasted, it would 'pop' more because it seems a little bit lost.
09: The crop, in my opinion, was actually done really well but the font used for the text really took away from the icon.

Best
13: Lovely crop, excellent use of texture/brush and the text really adds that something extra to it. :)
02: Unique idea and it works well. The red compliments the overall icon in a pleasant way.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

LQ:
15 - too dark
9 - not the best cropping and text is very hard to read
8 - Kendall's face is oversharpened

BQ:
16
12
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

Time for tough choices I guess :p

Least
11 - I don't think the texture fits perfectly with the rest of the cap & it makes the image a little bit too old-fashioned in contrast with the concept of the image.
15 - the effect of the coffee with the blue light is great, but the rest of the image is too dark for it.
09 - the font of this icon doesn't go along with the rest of it. It's too different from the pic & it's very hard to read.

Best
05- beautiful texture, which fits perfectly with the rest of the image & the effect of the coffe is amazing.
03 - it's like having breakfast with her b/c of the that yellow light & the text is perfect for the rest of the icon.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

LQ:

6- Blurry, too much light on the face.
10- The image on the circle appears blurry.
5- The textures doesn't fit the icon.

BQ:

3- Nice crop, text and use of the orange light texture.
2- Lovely on its simplicity.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

LQ:

06 - blurry, also too much light around the face.
09 - the crop is nice but the text is hard on the eyes and distracting.
15 - very dark, although I do like the blue light effect :).

BQ:

03
13
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

Least:
06 - blurry, with too much light
09 - the text is very difficult to read and it doesn't really fit the icon
15 - like the idea but the icon is very dark

Best:
02
16
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

Keep those votes coming! I could definitely use more!
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

Least:

15 - it's really too dark
14 - like the icon very much bit the background is too bright and Kendall looks a little blurry
05- to dark and contrast is missing, the textures fits not good with the icon together

Best:

13 - good cropping, like the light effect and the text
07 - it's simply but i like it very much
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

09 Unreadable text, probably because of the colour.
15 Too dark, allthough I like what you did with the damp coming out of the coffee.
05 The added effect makes it blurry.

Best
03
14
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

Least:
09- You can't really read the text.
08- Too dark and looks like too much contrast.
10- You can't tell what the smaller picture in the circle is at all.

Best:
13- I love the colour in it along with the textures.
03- The colour and the text is great.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Six - Voting!

Least

09 - Somehow I like the cropping, it's different and you risk s/th, great. Anyways, the text his nearly not readable and the chosen font doesn't go well with the rest of the style.
10 - Very creative ideas, I love small in-icon pictures, but it's very hard to identify at the first spot what actually is in the small circle.
15 - Yes, this icon is just too dark. Everything else is great: I love the crop, the steamy effect, the grid texture you used, but it gets bogged down in too much darkness.

Best (again there were more than 2 I wanted to vote for *sighs* so hard)

02 - as someone else already mentioned: this icon just stands out, awesome style. I like the simplicity and the soft color splash, great work!
14 - I love the whole composition of the icon, the text the brushes and the placing and cropping of Jordan, even the fact that Jordan is a bit blurry doesn't interfere, quite the opposite.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top