Talk LIMS #7: FINAL RESULTS!

Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Voting!

Least
11: Love the crop but the icon itself is very dark and the second part of the text where it says 'the gun guy', it looks like the first part was written and then the 'enter' button was pressed, which separates that section of text (which is what it's supposed to do) but perhaps creating a separate layer for each line to bring the text closer together would have worked better?
04: Unfortunate colouring. The character's skin colouring and the background colours don't seem to mix very well.
08: The icon is really creative but the scratch texture seems to overpower the icon, especially around the subject's face.

Best
03
16
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Voting!

LQ
11 Icon is too dark, and the text is unreadable. (And I don't think the maker intended it that way.
04 Odd colouring and overcontrasted, making Bobby's face yellow on one side and too dark on the other.
08 Creative idea, but it doens't fit the icon. The coloured part is too reddish.

HQ
07 Love the simplicity of it, and the crop.
15 Great colouring, excellent texture.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Voting!

Least:
4 - odd coloring
8 - Bobby's face in the smaller circle is too reddish
11 - too dark

Best:
15
3
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Voting!

I'd love a few more votes in here, so please keep them coming :)
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Voting!

LQ
11 too dark
04 Odd colouring and too dark
08 doens't fit the icon and too reddish

HQ
03
15
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Voting!

Best
04 - The image has lost some quality, perhaps because of over doing it on the coloring and contrast.
19 - You've got an interesting concept, but like someone else mentioned there's just no real harmony in putting these elements together and it leaves the whole thing feeling rather disjointed.
09 - Another great concept, but I think it's been pushed too far. All the brush work on it makes it feel a little cluttered, and with all of it stacked on the left, the icon feels too heavy on that side. I like the coloring here alright, but the image is starting to degrade a bit too.


Least
14 - Nice icon. The text is well handled and fun and bubbly. The colors are nice the whole things has a good balance.
10 - Nice coloring, and sometimes I like a 'widescreen' crop like this. I just wish there was something, a little embellishment or some such, to give it that little something extra.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Voting!

Least:
11 - too dark, contrast and colour are missing
8 - like the design of the icon but the little pic of Bobby faces is too red
1 - his face is too red

Best:
10 - it's simply but looks great
3 - like the idea of the cropping and the black & white colouring, fits marvelous together
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Voting!

I nearly ran out of time to do this:

least:
04- a little to yellow for his face
11- needs to be a little lighter
12- some of Bobby looks like he's been erased, but i love the text though

Best:
14
16
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Results!

LIMS 7: Challenge 5 Results!

The hardest part of this challenge is saying goodbye to the challengers...

Bobby04.jpg
by Smokey

Bobby11.png
by Adorable_Crazy

Sorry to see you both go! Thanks so much for joining us, and remember that there will be a comeback round later on....


Voter's Choice
VotersChoiceR05.png

Congrats Geni! Fantastic work!

Mod's Choice
ModsChoiceR05.png

Normally, this isn't my favorite style of icon, but you really pulled this one off nicely. All the pieces just fit together so well, I can't help but smile when I look at it. Great work!

01: -2
02: +1
03: -2+9 = +7
04: -19
05: +3
06: +1
07: +1
08: -14
09: -3+1 = -2
10: +6
11: -16
12: -2
13: 0
14: +4
15: +9
16: +7
17: 0
18: 0
19: -5

Next round will be up soon :)
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Results!

Congrats to Geni and Daquien, nice work!


:( Smokey, A_C...really sorry to see you both go.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Results!

Thanks, Egeria! :insert crying and wailing and gnashing of teeth smiley here: :lol:

Arrrrgh! I knew I was going down this round. Congrats to the winners, and keep up the good work everyone! I'll be sure to stick around to vote. :)
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Results!

*gives tissues and cookies to Smokey* I'm sorry to see you and A_C go, it was a tough round!

And congrats to Geni and Daquien, awesome icons! :D
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Results!

Cookies to A_C and Smokey for consolation! Sorry to see you guys go. But stick around, will ya ;)

Congrats to Geni and Daquien! :D
Your icons were really really good :cool:
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Five ~ Results!

Smokey and Adorable_Crazy, definitely sucks to see you both go from the competition. Hopefully y'all will be back next time. :)

:eek: Thanks for all the votes for my icon! <3

Congrats Daquien on your Dragonfly'sBeenDazzled Award! :D Lovely icon.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top