Re: Nick Fic Song Challenge Thread #2- Ch #14- "Superman Tonight"
Nick Fic Song Challenge
Round 15
Ladies and gentlemen, presenting round 15 of the Nick Fic Song Challenge! Thanks to everyone who participated!
Here are a few guidelines for reading and reviewing:
1. Remember, for now the stories are anonymous. Please do not reveal which story you wrote. We will unveil the authors next
Sunday, November, 7.
2.
Story authors/participants - Please leave feedback for
each story. That's why we're doing this...so we can learn from each other and improve as we go along. And because this is anonymous for now, please remember to leave some feedback for your own story too.
3.
Lurkers - You are most welcome to read and review the stories too! We just ask that you follow and respect the guidelines here as well. The exception is that you may leave reviews for
as few or as many stories as you like. (Authors - Please do not take offense if a lurker reviews only one or two stories or does not review yours.)
4. Please make your feedback as
positive and
constructive as possible. Constructive means that it's meant to be helpful and it's said in a nice way.
There will be zero tolerance for meanness here from anyone.
5. Please try to make your feedback a little more than just "Good job" or "Nice story". We all look forward to hearing some thoughtful input on our work.
And for now let's focus on the content of the story more so than the format, grammar, punctuation, spelling, etc. For some people this is their first fic and/or English may not be their first language, and those are all things that a good beta could fix if this weren't a challenge.
6. Feedback should be posted here in this thread and can be done all in one post or in several posts.
7. Remember,
we aren't voting for favorites on this or anything. We're just reading, reviewing, and enjoying!
8. Attention readers! Feedback posts will probably contain
spoilers. If you do not want to be spoiled, do not read the feedback until after you read the stories.
And now, what you've all been waiting for...round 15 of the
Nick Fic Song Challenge! Click on the "The Moment I Said It" link on the left to read the stories.
Note: If you see an error in your story or any problems on the page, please PM
Smokey ASAP.