It has to be asked CSI or CSI:Miami or CSI:NY
- Thread starter T'Bonz
- Start date
nickstokesfan
Coroner
Re: It has to be asked CSI or CSI:Miami
The only reason I ever subject myself to CSI Miami is that the stories aren't so bad -- but I don't like the cast AT ALL! I can't figure out who I like less: Horatio, Calleigh or Alexx.
CSI is my #1 show and I also like CSI: New York.
The only reason I ever subject myself to CSI Miami is that the stories aren't so bad -- but I don't like the cast AT ALL! I can't figure out who I like less: Horatio, Calleigh or Alexx.
CSI is my #1 show and I also like CSI: New York.
Ninjakitten
Victim
Re: It has to be asked CSI or CSI:Miami
My ranking of 'em would have to be:
CSI
CSI: NY
CSI: Miami
Mostly for me it's kind of a 'heart' thing, hard to explain better than that at this time of day, alas.
NY and Miami are actually close to on a par, for me. But Miami lost points for killing Speed (Woe! He was my favourite!) and because Horatio gets on my nerves at times. I really =like= Alexx, though. Body-chatting and all.
Maybe because if I were in her job, I'd talk to them too. It's not like she pours out her daily woes to them or expects them to answer in anything but evidence, after all, and I talk to =computers= at times, so.
Although a coroner who did hold one-sided entire conversations about her/his own life with the corpses could be pretty funny, actually. Not suitable to a CSI show, but still.
NY's characters aren't quite as well-drawn and memorable (overall) as the other two shows', but I find them more likeable than Miami's most of the time.
The original CSI gets everything right, though. So it's head and shoulders above the other two, for me.
My ranking of 'em would have to be:
CSI
CSI: NY
CSI: Miami
Mostly for me it's kind of a 'heart' thing, hard to explain better than that at this time of day, alas.
NY and Miami are actually close to on a par, for me. But Miami lost points for killing Speed (Woe! He was my favourite!) and because Horatio gets on my nerves at times. I really =like= Alexx, though. Body-chatting and all.
Maybe because if I were in her job, I'd talk to them too. It's not like she pours out her daily woes to them or expects them to answer in anything but evidence, after all, and I talk to =computers= at times, so.Although a coroner who did hold one-sided entire conversations about her/his own life with the corpses could be pretty funny, actually. Not suitable to a CSI show, but still.
NY's characters aren't quite as well-drawn and memorable (overall) as the other two shows', but I find them more likeable than Miami's most of the time.
The original CSI gets everything right, though. So it's head and shoulders above the other two, for me.
G
Guest
Guest
Re: It has to be asked CSI or CSI:Miami
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation is the best for me.
I love every member of the team and the way they all interact with each other.
Do not like Horatio and so can't really get into CSI: Miami and haven't really tried to watch CSI: NY though I think that looks quite good.
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation is the best for me.
I love every member of the team and the way they all interact with each other.
Do not like Horatio and so can't really get into CSI: Miami and haven't really tried to watch CSI: NY though I think that looks quite good.
GrissomFREAK
CSI Level Two
Re: It has to be asked CSI or CSI:Miami
One of the reasons why I like Vegas more than its spinoffs, is because the Vegas team spends more time analyzing and theorizing ... less talking ... greater emphasis put on looks and silences -or is it just me?
It seems -but maybe I'm wrong here, that's just how I see things, that the Miami team is more often seen on the field, running after the bad guys, whereas in Vegas they spend a lot more time in the lab.
There are some times when I wonder whether CSI: Miami is a forensic show or a cop show
My two cents
Same here
One of the reasons why I like Vegas more than its spinoffs, is because the Vegas team spends more time analyzing and theorizing ... less talking ... greater emphasis put on looks and silences -or is it just me?
It seems -but maybe I'm wrong here, that's just how I see things, that the Miami team is more often seen on the field, running after the bad guys, whereas in Vegas they spend a lot more time in the lab.
There are some times when I wonder whether CSI: Miami is a forensic show or a cop show
My two cents
G
Guest
Guest
Re: It has to be asked CSI or CSI:Miami
CSI.
Love Grissom...too much, in fact. Hehehe.
CSI.
Love Grissom...too much, in fact. Hehehe.
iluvroadrunner
Pathologist
Re: It has to be asked CSI or CSI:Miami
between those two? i'd have to pick vegas.
but i do like ny...for me, it's tie between ny and vegas.
miami's ok, but i really only watch it to drool over eric...and get my regular dose of soap opera for the week.
between those two? i'd have to pick vegas.
but i do like ny...for me, it's tie between ny and vegas.
miami's ok, but i really only watch it to drool over eric...and get my regular dose of soap opera for the week.
OK, I finally got off my rump and switched the title of this thread. Somebody pulled it out of the archives and dusted it off a while ago, so I probably should have added NY in then but heck- I'm nothing if not lazy!
GrissomFREAK
CSI Level Two
#1 CSI Whoever said that perfection doesn't exist was sooo wrong
#2 CSI:NY
#2 CSI:Miami
#2 CSI:NY
#2 CSI:Miami
Re: It has to be asked CSI or CSI:Miami
I'm a girl too and I have seen a limo hummer h2 twice now here in the city I live and couldn't keep my eyes away from it!
I also like Miami the most! Just because it is a show with a little more balls than the other two. Hehe I watch WaT for a little more realistic stories Then I really like speedle and since his leaving it has been 100% Horatio. It's just his charme or something. Can't explain...
I'm a girl too and I have seen a limo hummer h2 twice now here in the city I live and couldn't keep my eyes away from it!
I also like Miami the most! Just because it is a show with a little more balls than the other two. Hehe I watch WaT for a little more realistic stories
Then I really like speedle and since his leaving it has been 100% Horatio. It's just his charme or something. Can't explain...
GrissomFREAK
CSI Level Two
Re: It has to be asked CSI or CSI:Miami
This was posted in another thread
That's exactly it. Cops. I never could picture them as scientists. They sure don't look like scientists Always with a gun in their hand -well, maybe not ALWAYS, but compared to Grissom who's always holding a swab or looking through a microscope, wearing his lab coat ... you see my point
Pretty sure that's why I stopped watching these two shows. CSI is a forensic show. NY and Miami look more like cop shows. And that's why CSI is my number 1 Too many cop shows on TV.
This was posted in another thread
That's exactly it. Cops. I never could picture them as scientists. They sure don't look like scientists
Always with a gun in their hand -well, maybe not ALWAYS, but compared to Grissom who's always holding a swab or looking through a microscope, wearing his lab coat ... you see my point Pretty sure that's why I stopped watching these two shows. CSI is a forensic show. NY and Miami look more like cop shows. And that's why CSI is my number 1
Too many cop shows on TV.MrsGregHSanders
Police Officer
Re: It has to be asked CSI or CSI:Miami
CSI for sure, it's the original. Its stories are clever, and characters are engaging. Plus it has Greg, and Greg is god's gift to everything!
CSI for sure, it's the original. Its stories are clever, and characters are engaging. Plus it has Greg, and Greg is god's gift to everything!