H/Y H/C

Status
Not open for further replies.
But Horatio's relationship with Yelina is, you were married
to my dead brother, and I have feelings for you before
you married my brother, and I still do. If Calleigh is so
hung up on Horatio, how come she didn't say to Horatio, the
things she said to Hagen? If Horatio is so hung up on
Calleigh, how come he didn't say the same things to
Calleigh, he said to Yelina?

I'm not insulting anyone, and I respect all of your thoughts
and opinions, I'm just trying to understand.
It strikes me funny as to how you guys get that kind of
vibe, from the lack of romantic interaction. Not to
mention the lact of just plain interaction.

I have seen Horatio and Yelina make some moves, and said
some come-on lines, but has Horatio, and Calleigh said
things like that to eachother? If they were ment
to be together, how come niether of them mentions it?
Acts on it? Something, some little inication would help.
Even a glance would say something.



Shes got a point there
 
Posted by des08:
As this is an obvious H/C bashing thread, I am only coming on to say one thing in response to Roxbury, a correction of sorts to the idea that H/C have had no 'shipperness':

Kill Zone

Horatio: "Nice work. Ever consider a transfer to SWAT?
Calleigh: "I don't look good in all black." (she's in head to toe black)
Horatio: "I beg to differ."

Simple Man

John Hagen (speaking of Horatio): "All I'm saying is, that's one hell of a lonely road he's walking"
Calleigh: "That's why I'm walking it with him."

You said they've never had come on lines, or 'shipper' lines. Those two promptly disprove your theory, in my mind. There are many other 'shipper' instances I already got into, in detail, in the first Calleigh/Yelina thread. They don't need to be repeated here, because I have the feeling a few of you are sliding onto this thread to simply bash. That's fine - but the power of Caruso and Procter as a team, for me and many, many others, transcends even the advent of Yelina. We're not going away, gang.

Go ahead and root for whomever you choose -- but let's refrain from using words like "Puke" and allow for courteous differences of opinion.
Click to expand...


I have heard those 2 lines so many times :lol:
 
Don't care for H/C, in all honesty. I don't see any chemistry between David and Emily, and between the characters, I don't see any kind of special connection. Not to mention the age difference really bothers me. Actually, not the age difference per se, but the fact that Horatio looks and acts like he's her grandfather. I don't see what Calleigh could possibly bring into a relationship with Horatio. Relationships are 50/50, two way streets. I can't see Horatio, for lack of a better phrase, 'getting' anything from Calleigh (besides sex). To put it in other words, she could die tomorrow and his life would be no better, no worse. There's nothing about her that he can't live without. He's always been a mentor figure to her and the rest of the team.

I'm not completely opposed to a H/Y relationship, as others are, IF they were into each other before she married Raymond (which kind of has been implied). If Horatio was always her first choice, but she married Raymond for whatever reason, then I think it's fair game and kind of an interesting plotline to carry out. But honestly, I don't give much of a crap. If they're gonna get together, just get it over with. Stop dragging it. Caruso gets way too much screen time as it is. I wanna see what's going on with the other characters.

Obviously he's in love with Yelina. No question about that. And even when she wasn't around, I don't remember any potentially romantic moments between him and Calleigh. Nothing that made me go, "Oh, these two are gonna start knocking bottoms soon." I think the one relationship that DOES gives me that vibe, and ironically the one that's most overlooked, is Eric/Calleigh.
 
^I agree about H/C. I just don't see it. I think he's her mentor, but beyond that, I don't think she's any more significant in his life than Eric or Speed. Not to say they're not significant, cause they are, but it's not a romantic thing.

Like you say, H is obviously in love with Yelina. Why she's dating that tool Stetler is beyond me, though H did kind of turn her down at the beginning of season 2, so that is partially his fault.

It will be interesting to see how it plays out. I see some Eric/Calleigh potential, too, though he'd have to stop being such a playboy. :lol:
 
If I could pair someone in CSI/CSIM if we take ALL characters in those ...it would be H and Catherine :D
 
Posted by DaWacko:
If I could pair someone in CSI/CSIM if we take ALL characters in those ...it would be H and Catherine :D
Click to expand...

They had a very palpable chemistry in Cross Jurisdiction. I certainly picked up on some sexual attraction.
 
I love seeing Horatio and Yelina!
Not that I am crazy about them, but their chemistry is nice.
Horatio and Calleigh have got absolutely NO chemistry.
I don't see how that could ever work.

Actually, I am a Horatio/Tweaker-chic shipper.
Not that I want to see them romatically involved, I just love to see scenes between them.
 
I totally like forget blood brothers, how does h turn her down again?
 
Posted by Fabian:

Actually, I am a Horatio/Tweaker-chic shipper.
Not that I want to see them romatically involved, I just love to see scenes between them.
Click to expand...
I don't like shipping on CSIM but that seems like a good match! :D
 
Posted by catchmeifucan9:
I totally like forget blood brothers, how does h turn her down again?
Click to expand...

Hmm, on a 1-10 scale of believability, er, 1.5. :lol: Well-intentioned speech by H but body language and behavior saying the complete opposite. H trying to convince himself more than anything else but not fooling just about anyone else. Even S can see through it hence the deliberate taunting by S.
 
It should be interesting to see what they do with the Horatio, Stetler and Yelina triangle this season. I bet Stetler taunts Horatio all season. Stetler may become the person we love to hate. :devil:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top