Death Penalty? What's your opinion?

Actually, that's not entirely true. People are allowed to have world-view opinions here, thanks. ;) Because that's all they are really: personal opinions .
 
But each country has its own system of justice. France , for instance, is the opposite of the U.S. They believe that you have to prove your innocence, not the other way round.
 
Regardless, if someone thinks the death penalty should not exist, period , then that's what they think. I'm sure the opinion would have very little to do with the various countries views on doling out justice, and more to do with a personal view on humanity. And they're perfectly entitled to that viewpoint. As are all the people who believe the death penalty should exist.
 
i know those 'what if' questions are really hard to answer, because most people sometimes cant visualize themselves in the situation and come up with an answer.
but what id like to know is, if someone close to you, that you cared about (spouse, boy/girlfriend, sibling, parent etc) was tortured and killed by one of these sadistic serial killers, would your view on the death penalty change? would the simple fact that they had to live out the rest of their life rotting in a jail cell be enough closure for you? could you ever move past the fact that they are still alive and the person they took from you isnt?
 
^ My views would still stay the same. I support the death penalty always but I can understand how people would oppose it and I respect their opinion. But even if a loved one near me was killed by a serial killer, I'd probably keep on living my life out because it wouldn't be my decision to make on how to get them. It's not my job, it's the police's. And emotions do always seem to cloud the mindset of some people and that's when they make poor judgements so, I wouldn't want my living family to grieve another death if I did something rash.
But if the guy was caught and thrown in jail, it wouldn't be a matter of closure for me, because that would seem selfish. I would be glad that he wouldn't be able to go out and harm anyone else and cause anymore pain.
If he was put the death, I'd still feel the same as if he was put in jail so, I guess it's matter of opinion.
 
Boy I struggle with this issue.

On the one hand, I think it's pointless and it takes forever to be done because of all the appeals. So I don't see it as cheaper then life imprisonment.

On the other, especially when it comes to the murder of children, I do believe and eye for an eye. I also go along that line when it comes to the families of the victim that are left behind to grieve.

So I can't decide on this one.
 
Has anyone thought of the media's complicity in this matter? How it exploits the situation for profit?
 
Of course. I mean, if you've ever wondered why the news plays all the depressing things or things that would traumatize a child if they understood, it's simply for ratings. Murder sells.
 
OK. So you have the legislators making the laws, the legal system enforcing them, the psychiatric profession practically looking the other way, and the fouth estate exploiting the situation for their own benefit. And we're the ones who put them there in the first place!
 
NOPE it should be banned all over the world- it is a barbaric and hypocritical punishment and doesn´t belong in a civilized society.

1)By killing someone who´s killed someone you are just as bad.

2)Who has the right to decide who should be killed and who shouldn´t?

3)Considering the number of ppl that have been innocently executed it´s just not worth the risk.

4)It will never be possible to completely put yourself in the position of the person who committed the crime so it will never be possible to give a just death sentence.

5)The death penalty has no deterring effect what so ever- it only increases violence in society. Does anyone really believe that a person driven as far as murder will be thinking of the consequences of his actions? Most murderers have biological and/or psychological damages.

6) Death p. gives no closure for victim or perp families. Imprisonment is both a punishment and a chance for treatment closure and mediation. The perp should be forced to face the victims family as a part of the punishment/ treatment and acknowledge and take responsibility for the actions.
Click to expand...

I totally agree with this.
I'm against Death Penalty. Who are we to say someone has to die? We aren't God! Deciding someone has to die makes us just as bad as the criminal in my opinion.

Everytime I hear someone on CSI telling a criminal that he/she is sure he will do anything to get him/her the needle, it shocks me.
 
kismet ,
We have no right to speak for other countries as their legal systems are quite different from ours. What might be done is to have a world referendum on this question
with each nation having a say in the matter.
 
I don't know if I agree with it or not really. I mean if you took someones life they should take yours. But what if your innocent and they kill you then figure out 15 years later that you wern't the one that did it....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top