CSI: NY Season 4 Spoilers! Discussion in the Big Apple

Status
Not open for further replies.
Urgh! if we talk about soap operas:scream:

I guess we don't need Mac to be envolved inside the CSI Junior High soap opera as "special guest star":scream:

Besides if it happens eventually it will be to redeem Danny's behaviour before Lindsey's fans since his well-known moral code (a redeemption i don't care at all)

I'd love to know what Stella is going to say if she finds out:eek:

Debbie:wtf:
 
Elsie said:
Gaelen said:
The spoilers seem to hint at that.
Click to expand...
Would the writers really show Mac in such a bad light? On top of the DL drama? Somehow I really doubt it.
Click to expand...

This is one spoiler I really hope doesn't come to pass. Honestly, I will say that the spoilers do suggest that Mac definitely regrets his actions, but regardless cheating on the dead wife is just a step too far for me. :rolleyes: And not something I ever needed to, or will find any joy, in knowing. It also doesn't fit as something I personally think that Mac would do.
Click to expand...
I don't think it's 'Mac' either. He has faults, but cheating just isn't something that fits with his character as the writers have developed it so far. The faults they have given him - the tendency to get on his high horse occasionally, the black and white view of justice - do fit with the character. Danny's sleeping with Rikki because he wasn't on the same page as Lindsay with their relationship fit very well with his character IMO. Mac cheating just...doesn't. If they do do it, I suspect it may have been a one night stand/sex thing, not an long term affair. Both are cheating, and both are wrong, but there is a difference between the two. But still, I just can't see Mac as a cheater, and don't understand why the writers would portray a character who is allegedly the 'moral center of the show' , and certainly one of the main character, in that way. I suppose we'll find out on Wedsnesday, or later in the season.
And since when did CSI NY become about the characters' fidelity to their past and present significant others rather, than, um, murders in NYC and the people who investigate them?:rolleyes:
 
Gaelen said:
Nope, both Danny and Rikki starting freshly spoiler is for episode 19. According to csifan who posted the spoilers, there will be tension between Danny and Lindsay about Rikki in episode 18.
Click to expand...
Oh, okay -- thanks. I thought it was all for one episode. ::must pay better attention::

As for Rikki appearing just to tell Danny she's moving away, that's a predictable and terribly overused plot device, even in soap operas.
Click to expand...
Well, yes it is - but what's new about this arc anyway? The whole thing is a soap opera-ish plotline. But I agree with you, if this was simply a plot device to bring Danny and Lindsay closer together, as much as I love the idea, I'm disappointed that they had to bring Rikki into it. They cheapened the entire Child's Play storyline, and yes - TPTB could have used a much more mature way of bringing DL closer.

But that's what happens when the writers try to be "realistic" - life is a soap opera, can't expect TV to not reflect that can we? :rolleyes:

As for the Mac spoiler -- hmm, I'm mixed. I'd like to see more of his FLAWS because he's Super!Mac all the damn time, but likewise, it might be damaging to his character. I wonder if it'll even make the cut. This is all for tomorrow's episode right? The Mac thing , I mean.

All we know about Claire's relationship with him before she died was that he loved her very, very much and now, all of a sudden, we find out he cheated on her in the past?
Click to expand...
Maybe that's why he loves her oh so much? Part actual love, part guilt? Who knows. If TPTB use one more storyline that deals with guilt, I think I'm going to faint from overdramatic exposure.

"Who Wants To Be A Millionaire" has better dramatic tension than this. :p
Click to expand...

People didn't you see the look on Danny's face when Lindsay confessed her love to him. He is bound to make things right and according to the video here......there is gonna be a happy ending for Danny and Lindsay which would mean that Rikki will be out of the picture for good:

http://vids.eonline.com/services/link/bcpid1396519019/bctid1499647328

However my opinion about Episode 19 is Rikki is gonna tell Danny she's moving.....not to follow her call her or anything and to go back to Lindsay.

I sense the finale will be Lindsay getting hurt and Danny coming to her rescue. Something like Snowday but this will be a lot of I love you's and I forgive you etc and a stronger DL relationship as lovers.
 
Personally, I hope to god that the finale isn't DL heavy. I love DL to death, but I'm sure you all agree that I think we've had enough of the Danny/Lindsay drama to last a season.

I just want them to fade into the background to work whatever they need to work out and leave it there for now.

As for Mac cheating, no I don't think it could have been a long affair. It was most likely a one-night stand - Mac drunk (is that possible?) or something along those lines.

But still, I just can't see Mac as a cheater, and don't understand why the writers would portray a character who is allegedly the 'moral center of the show' , and certainly one of the main character, in that way. I suppose we'll find out on Wedsnesday, or later in the season.
And since when did CSI NY become about the characters' fidelity to their past and present significant others rather, than, um, murders in NYC and the people who investigate them?:rolleyes:
Click to expand...
Which is why I think it's most likely going to be cut. But who knows? We may have misinterpreted the spoiler...nothing's set in stone and we're talking about the CSI:NY writers here. They come up with things out of the blue all the time. :p
 
Where did this spoiler that Mac cheated on his wife come from??? That was completely out of the blue for me. If that was true, then I have completely lost any respect for this show. Infidelity should not be a recurring event on this show unless it is dealing with the actual crimes not the main characters.
 
The implication of Mac cheating has been in the spoilers for 4.17 since we first saw them, but with the way it was presented (not entirely clear what happened), I don't think anybody wanted to point it out and cause drama without knowing the full story. I for one am hoping that someone nixed the idea and we won't have it on screen, however the events panned out. We'll see, though. *sigh*
 
Fay sounds sad :(

Stare at your avvie, it makes me grin :p

The implication of Mac cheating has been in the spoilers for 4.17 since we first saw them,
Click to expand...
Then I have seriously been ignorant. But yeah, I really want to know what this whole thing's about. I can't see them making such a big deal out of it though...who knows.
 
where is this video from?

and can they please not explore Mac's cheating or sth? what is with this theme and CSI lately? is it gonna be used as a parallel to the D/R/L saga?

:confused:
 
Will no one be mad at me if I tell them......

I AM UTTERLY CONFUSSED. I am so freakin' lost with all these episodes and what we know and what is speculation. It's like sorting through tiger crap. You are like, is this a spoiler or speculation. Is this what we know or is it an opinion. Geeezzzz! talk about your brain going numb:confused::eek::scream: I am trying to sort so much out and I am just exhausted. It is like Loral and Hardy's "Who's on first" skit.

Can I get some clarification, and only the facts as we know them! Ole girl here can't take but so much confusion. I get easily confused?
 
^messygirl73, this thread is for spoiler speculation. There is a seperate spoiler thread for just the spoilers so you dont have to dig through pages and pages of speculation. :)
 
:rolleyes:
Gaelen said:
Personally, I hope to god that the finale isn't DL heavy. I love DL to death, but I'm sure you all agree that I think we've had enough of the Danny/Lindsay drama to last a season.

I just want them to fade into the background to work whatever they need to work out and leave it there for now.

As for Mac cheating, no I don't think it could have been a long affair. It was most likely a one-night stand - Mac drunk (is that possible?) or something along those lines.

But still, I just can't see Mac as a cheater, and don't understand why the writers would portray a character who is allegedly the 'moral center of the show' , and certainly one of the main character, in that way. I suppose we'll find out on Wedsnesday, or later in the season.
And since when did CSI NY become about the characters' fidelity to their past and present significant others rather, than, um, murders in NYC and the people who investigate them?:rolleyes:
Click to expand...
Which is why I think it's most likely going to be cut. But who knows? We may have misinterpreted the spoiler...nothing's set in stone and we're talking about the CSI:NY writers here. They come up with things out of the blue all the time. :p
Click to expand...

Yeah, I don't think we're gonna find out Mac was leading an entire different life with Quinn somewhere ala Brothers and Sisters,:)p) or even that he had an affair. Maybe he and Claire had a big fight, he went out and got wasted, Quinn was there, there was flirting, they slept together. It happens. It's not right, but it happens to many people, men and women. I have a strong feeling Mac will have experienced some serious guilt about it (guilt, guilt, more guilt).
Of course just because he has a preexisting relationship with Quinn doesn't definitely mean they slept together. Maybe she is an old love interest, but nothing actually happened between them. Jane Parsons was a 'love interest' for Mac, and nothing ever happened between them (except in my head;)) And you're so right about how with the NY writers nothing's set in stone. I found this ancient interview with AZ from 2005 when he was talking about Mac and Jane maybe getting it on, and the s1 finale involving Mac receiving shocking info re Claire, and Stella remembering finding her father murdered - none of that ever happened! Nor did that scene that was supposed to air at the end of one of the Ruben eps with Danny and Lindsay where Lindsay went to his place and he looked like he wanted/was expecting someone else. Even the idea of Jordan being Mac's new lady didn't really pan out immeadiately as the spoilers implied.:rolleyes:
Well, we'll wait and see what happens this time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top