From New York:
C1: --nny? -re y-- t--in- -er i- or -- I?
C2: --e'- not -oin- in!
C1: Yo- -no- t-i- --- -ot to -e --t on ---er. T--t ---'- -r-b-bly -lre--y on t-e --one -it- -i- l--yer, tellin- -i- -ll -bo-t t-i-.
C2: -l--, I'- -onn- t--e -er -o-e.
C1: I'll be -t -y -e--. I -i-- yo- one -o-r. --ter t--t, I'll -o ---t I -ot to -o.
Letters guessed: E, L, T, I, R, Y, B, O, N
Three letters at the time, BT, I'll take yours next time.
So only two more letters, kids!