Talk LIMS #8: Final Results!

Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5 - Voting!

Least
14 - The icon looks really washed out, you can hardly make out the background.
13 - As said before, the background is too distracting.
07 - Delko looks a bit grainy and the text is a tad too big.

Best
06 - Great coloring!
05 - Maybe a bit over saturated, but it's still nice.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5 - Voting!

Least:
14: Desaturated too much, the background is almost white.
01: Needs to be sharpened a little.
07: The text is oddly placed, there's also spots on Eric's face that could have been blurred to look clearer.

Best:
12: I love what you did with the text, putting the bigger text behind the smaller and lowering the opacity of it. The background matching Eric's shirt is a nice touch too.
05: I love the colouring.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5 - Voting!

LQ:
14 - Eric's skin doesn't look natural and the background is too bright.
02 - With the background and Eric black and white, both things don't look good together. Eric blends too much with the background. Maybe adding a background with color or instead of putting the picture black and white, putting some color.
01 - The picture is too dark and a little bit blurry.

BQ:
12 - Just "WHOA!". Absolutely fantastic! The backgrounds fits perfectly with the coloring, awesome text (i love that effect), everything's perfect! :D (please the artist who made this icon could pretty please tell me how you managed to get that coloring when the challenge's over? :p I'm completely in love with it! Thanks.)
06 - Again, awesome coloring! Looks really nice and the text color fits perfectly! Good job :)
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5 - Voting!

Wow this is getting hard.

Least Quality
02 The face is blurry and the character is too blended into the background.
12 the face looks disproportionate to the rest of the body.
01 the face appears fuzzy.

Best Quality
09 Nice and crisp. The wording is nicely placed
13
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5 - Voting!

Least
02 - More colour in the background would've have made Delko stand out more. Now it's just boring.
14 - Background is too bright and Delko looks 'flat'.
05 - Delko's skin is too red, it looks unnatural.

Best
15 - Great colouring, nice font and I really like the subtle fingerprint in the background!
12 - Beautiful background! The font, tiny text and colours fit together perfectly.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5 - Voting!

Least
15 the brush gives a first blush feeling of bluriness (...lmao)
14 too bright
10 a bit plain and oversharpened

Best
05 love the coloring
02 great texture, icon looks very neat
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5 - Voting!

Least:

14 - it's too bright and somehow lacks color
02 - he kind of blends into the backround and his face looks a little blurry
13 - the backround is too prominent and takes the focus away from the subject oh the icon

Best:

12
03
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5 - Voting!

Least:
01 - Looks somewhat blurry.
14 - The background washes out Eric and is somewhat distracting.
13 - The background distracts you from the subject of the icon.

Best:
03 - Gorgeous colouring/texture! Great icon!
08 - The background looks great, works well. Fab icon!
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5 - Voting!

least:
2-looks a bit too blurry, and maybe a little to much contrast.
5-although i love the cropping and how well you blended him and the background, the coloring is off it looks a bit to over saturated, especially over his face
13-the background texture is a bit overpowering and distracts from the subject

best:
11- the coloring is gorgeous
12. the coloring is fantastic and it all blends really well with the backround
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5 - Voting!

I'd like to post results over the weekend, but I still need lots more votes ;) *sets out cookies for those that have voted*
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 5

Least:

01- is a little blurry and dark, looks too orange
10- too dark and looks over sparpened
15- too orange and dark

Best:

03- love the colouring and the light effect. Really nice !
12- very beautiful colouring and great texture. Fits nice together !!
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top