I guess it boggles us that someone can be so un-objective with their favourite character.
When you get right down to it, everyone is "un-objective" about their favorite character. By their very nature, opinions are not objective, they're
subjective. Research conducted according to scientific criteria is objective.
I think as far as board behavior standards go, everyone's opinions are fine and welcome as long as they're not a personal attack on anyone else.
Ray is not a "newbie" he's been on since S/9, and is not a bumbling idiot, he's a smart experienced man who's been around and knows what he's talking about.
Sorry, but I agree with others who define "newbie" as the newest member of the team . . . which Ray is.
A band director I used to work for told me something I've never forgotten: You never stop being a "freshman". You're a freshman in your first year of high school, then again in college, then again when you start your first job, then again when you transfer to a new job . . . and on it goes all your life. Just because you're not a kid anymore, or you may have reams of experience in a given field, whenever you start over, you're a "freshman" all over again.
Also, my take on the hourglass scene is similar to that of others, that others on the team were humoring Ray while it seemed that he was talking down to them. I don't think he really is; I agree with what someone else said, that that's how he processes things, by thinking out loud to others. But it's coming across as talking down to them, the more experienced members of the team . . . hence the shared looks.
Overall comment: I watched the episode again last night and was even more impressed by how good it was. In some rather intangible ways, it felt like "CSI" of old, with all the series regulars behaving in ways that came across like old friends . . . meaning that their behaviors really resonated with me in a believable way, one that connects with the history of the series. I hope this wasn't Zuiker's last stint with the mothership!