Marg/Catherine #5.0: She's Got It All

Status
Not open for further replies.
thanks Dardeile ..I remembered another girl for Lindsay;s role and I got a bit confused.. ;)

something related to Sam and Catherine,old one again..She asked a DNA test during a case in which he was involved and found out that she was his daughter...Sam knew it from the beggining he was her father or not? :rolleyes:
 
ZOMG REALLY? :eek: I didn't know he knew about it before Catherine... I thought Catherine had told him on Inside the Box...
How do we know he knew it before Cath? (Sorry for the stupped question, but hey, it's Sofie! :p)
 
Well, when she tells him he's not surprised, and he says certain things that kinda make you realize he's always been aware of that ;)
 
I'm not totally convinced that Sam knew. That scene in ITB when Cath told him, sure he didn't show any emotion about it, but remember - he's a casino mogul with a great poker-face, and he wouldn't outwardly show emotions on whether he knew or not.

I always saw it as Sam had an idea he was her father, but wasn't sure. Remember, it wasn't until after Catherine told him about the DNA results that he started doing something about it (i.e. the check in Jackpot, telling others about their relationship in Grave Danger etc)
 
He couldn't have told anyone as long as Catherine didn't know about it...

But I agree that he was probably not a 100% sure. I guess he always suspected it, Catherine's mom might even have placed the idea in his head. But the DNA confirmed it for him, until then he was just considering it possible.
 
In the ep "Burked" (some scenes cut for relevent ones).

SAM BRAUN: I would've taken you home right then if I could have.
CATHERINE: I know, but you were married and I was a baby. It would've never worked.

At the end of the show

SAM BRAUN: You know, I should've married your mother.
CATHERINE: Well, considering I was six months old when you guys lit the flame ... a lot of time has passed. You had plenty of chances.
SAM BRAUN: Just wasn't in the cards, Catherine. It just wasn't in the cards.

---------------

The Scene From ITB I cut off part of the scenes to get to the relevent parts.

CATHERINE: I guess I didn't have a good enough reason until now, but ... I tested my DNA against the unknown sample. (She sighs.) -- And wouldn't you know ... there were seven alleles in common.
(He leans forward and shakes his head.)
SAM BRAUN: That supposed to mean something?
CATHERINE: It means that you and I are biologically related.
SAM BRAUN: Do you really think I could murder someone?
CATHERINE: Science ... tells me that you did. So, yes, I do. (Her voice breaks.) It's just such a lousy way to find out that you're my father.
 
awes, we got destiny to drop in. thanks for the lines.

i think sam knew. i think he and lily purposely hid the fact from catherine for whatever reason. who knows! parents do strange things sometimes thinking it is for the best.
 
Yep and no one had to be yelled at or smacked for me to come in. :lol:
 
Thank you, and I get in here when I can, you all know that, I read the thread every day and when I have time, or something to contribute, or have to ruin some fun, lol I'm here. ;)
 
Woo does anyone no what that club was called that Cath's old toy boy at the start of season 5's club was called, the guy was Chris I think.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top