LIMS #6 Final Challenge!: 140x140 - Winners!

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 7: No Selective Coloring ~ Now Up!

nah, just get it in on Sunday whatever timezone you're in. i consider it Monday when it's Monday for everybody in the world. ;)
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 7: No Selective Coloring ~ Now Up!

yeah, so to express myself better than in my previous post, i'm extending the deadline to Sunday, i will not have time today to post the challenge. which should help the remaining three icon makers to get their work in. :) this is only a one time extension, i will not do that again in the future challenges.
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 7: No Selective Coloring ~ Voting!

TalkCSI LIMS Challenge 7: Voting!

Voting Rules:

~ Absolutely anyone may vote!
~ Vote for the Top 3 of least quality, and the Top 2 of best quality.
~ Votes for least quality Must have a reason, or they will not be counted. Reasons for best quality are strongly encouraged.

(the following examples may have been "borrowed" from other sources)

Good Examples:
34: Text is oddly placed
50: Icon is over sharpened
62: Image is too blurry

Poor Examples:
96: I don't like the colour (personal preference)
52: Tiny text/decorative brushes are unreadable (it's supposed to be that way)

Here are the icons:

01
9-6.jpg
02
1-7.png
03
10-5.jpg
04
2-7.png

05
3-7.png
06
4-7.gif
07
5-7.jpg
08
6-7.png

09
7-7.jpg
10
8-5.jpg


Vote away :)
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 7: No Selective Coloring ~ Voting!

Awesome job guys! :D

Least Quality

10 - crop is a bit too severe.
5 - Though overall icon looks great it is abit too orange/saturated around Sara's face.
2 - abit too dark and blurry.

Best Quality

8 - the colouring, text and crop are all fantastic nice job! :)
9 - I love creativity shown in this icon its awesome and everything works well together. Great job! :)

Goodluck you guys :)
 
Last edited:
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 7: No Selective Coloring ~ Voting!

LQ:

2- Too dark.
10- The blending image doesn't work too well, it's too dark and takes too much space.
1- Centered cropping doesn't suit the icon and it's a little bit blurry.

BQ:

9-Creative.
8
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 7: No Selective Coloring ~ Voting!

Least:

02 - too dark and it looks a little brownish
05 - Sara's face is too orange
04 - too bright, contrast is missing and blurry

Best:

10 - good cropping and creative
8 - simply but I like this
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 7: No Selective Coloring ~ Voting!

Least:
02 - Too dark. Sara also looks a little orange.
01 - Blurry. Colour seems off somehow... maybe that's just me?
05 - Sara looks very orange. A tiny bit over sharpened.

Best:
08 - Great colouring, nice crop, good job!
09 - Creative, stands out from the rest of the icons.
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 7: No Selective Coloring ~ Voting!

Least
02 - too dark and yellowish
05 - oversharpened and Sara's face is a tad too orange
04 - the icon lacks contrast and the text is a bit blurry

Best
09 - very creative!
08 - nice coloring and use of curves (well I think that's what you might have done :lol: )
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 7: No Selective Coloring ~ Voting!

LQ
2 - way too dark.
5 - her face looks orange
8 - I don't like the text placement on this and the right side of her face looks almost white

BQ
7
9
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top