LIMS #6 Final Challenge!: 140x140 - Winners!

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting!

TalkCSI LIMS Challenge 8: Voting!

MelC is using her free pass for this challenge.

Voting Rules:

~ Absolutely anyone may vote!
~ Vote for the Top 3 of least quality, and the Top 2 of best quality.
~ Votes for least quality Must have a reason, or they will not be counted. Reasons for best quality are strongly encouraged.

(the following examples may have been "borrowed" from other sources)

Good Examples:
34: Text is oddly placed
50: Icon is over sharpened
62: Image is too blurry

Poor Examples:
96: I don't like the colour (personal preference)
52: Tiny text/decorative brushes are unreadable (it's supposed to be that way)

Here are the icons:

1.
1-8.jpg
2.
2-8.jpg
3.
3-8.jpg
4.
4-8.png

5.
5-8.jpg
6.
6-8.png
7.
7-8.png


Good LUck all! :)
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting Open!

Least:
3 - too blurry
6 - too blurry
5 - a little bit oversharpened

Fave:
4
2
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting Open!

Least
03 - a bit pale, kinda blurry and the text arrangement isn't the best
06 - it seems as if there hadn't been done much to the icon; the notes could have been highlighted a bit more
02 - too blurry and the "70s" draws some of the attention from Nick

Best
01
05
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting Open!

Okay this is really hard this time around because I like all of these icons.

3 - Image is a bit too blurry
6 - Is a bit too blurry.
1 - The font blends in too much and is hard to read.

BQ:
4
5 :)lol: cause you know he does this when no one is around)
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting Open!

LQ:

3- Too blurry.
6- Oversharpened.
4- It appears a little bit blurry.

BQ:

1- Nice texture.
2- Original.
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting Open!

l
06- blurry
05- a little orange-ish
03- oversharpened

m
07
04

Greeeeaat job everyone!
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting Open!

Least:
06 - a bit oversharpened
02 - blurry
07 - Nick is a bit... fuzzy

Best:
04 - Great colouring!
05 - Very nice :lol:
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting Open!

Least:

07 - the text seems overwhelming
06 - blurry
03 - blurry

Best:
02
01
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting Open!

Great job everyone! What a hard vote

Least:
03. over sharpened, pale
05. blurry and text placed odd
07. blurry color seems fuzzy

Best
06. nice idea and good color/crop
02. crop and color well done
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting Open!

LQ
1 - the text is hard to read and the icon as a whole seems very orange
6 - Nick's face seems fuzzy, blurry
3 - Cath is very faint and blurry

BQ
4
2
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting!

Wow! This is hard, they all look so good. :lol:

LQ:

1 - a little blurry
3 - Cath is a little fuzzy
7- a little blurry/fuzzy

BQ:

6
2
 
Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 8: Music ~ Voting!

Wow! I love all the icons, this is well hard

LQ:

3 - too blurry
5 - a little oversharpened, pale
6 - too blurry

BQ:

1
7 :eek:
 
Back
Top