LIMS #6 Final Challenge!: 140x140 - Winners!

[CSI_Kat]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

LQ
2 - too dark
9 - coloring is off - looks a bit yellow
10 - his face and the background almost look the same color

BQ
11
12

 

[Deirdre]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

Least:
3 - too bright and blurry
10 - blurry
4 - colour of background is quite similar to colour of Horatio's face

Favourite:
11 - very pretty with nice colouring, cropping and text
12 - funny text

 

[Fighter]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

Least:
01 - too dark and Horatio's face a bit too red
10 - blurry and colouring a bit odd
09 - too bright

Best:
11 - great colours and text
07 - again, nice colours and text fits perfectly

 

[cathwillows]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

Least

02 - too dark, unfortunate crop (her hands are cut off), the font doesn't really fit and the whole icon looks kinda grainy
07 - the text is overpowering and arranged uncreatively and the icon itself looks too plain (not enough contrast, no specials)
06 - oversharpened and Horatio appears too orange

Best

10 - Even though it lacks a bit of contrast, the icon looks interesting. I like the arrangement of the text and the choice of color is great
12 - Cool! I like the contrast between the white background and Horatio and the text goes very well with the pic

 

[Macayla]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

Least:
02 – Too dark and over sharpened, text doesn’t fit
09 – Odd coloring, it’s too flashy
01 – Horatio is too dark and red

Best:
05
11

 

[Dragonfly]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

Least:
01 - Too dark
06 - Over sharpened
02 - Dark and oversharpened

Best:
08 - Nice colouring, good cropping
11 - Nice colouring, text works very well

 

[addictedtoSpeed]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

Least:
10. too blurry and the colors are too muted
07. too much of the same color, needs brightening up
04. Face and background look almost the same color-orangish/yellowish

Best:
11
06

 

[CSISneaky]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

Least:
09 - Colouring is off
08 - Oversharpened
06 - Oversharpened

Best:
10 - Nice colouring and text placement
11 - Nice crop and colouring

 

[dopebabygirl]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

LQ:
9 - Odd coloring
10 - blurry and colouring a bit odd
2 - Dark, hands cut off

BQ:
3
7

 

[twiztid4togo]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

LQ
09 blurry and text cut off by black trim
10 too blurry
12 over sharpened

BQ
04 nice color and cropping
08 cropped well done

 

[MelC]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ VOTING!

Wow... I'm seeing sungla-- I mean, Horatio everywhere...

Least:
06 - oversharpened and the coloring's a bit too yellowish/greenish (but I do like the crop and the light text at the background)
04 - oversharpened and I find the brush is a bit distracting
08 - oversharpened

Best
05 - Although the icon's a bit blur, but I love the crop very much and the text is well placed..
12 - Usually I'd love a bit of a background in icons but the background (or lack of it) brings the attention to Horatio and the text fits!

 

[Adzix]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ Results!

LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ Results!

Tally:

01 ----
02 --------
03 -+
04 ---+-
05 +++++
06 -+---+--
07 +--+
08 -+-+-+-
09 ---------
10 +-----+-+--
11 +++++++++
12 +-++++-+

And so the following icons got the most negative votes:

by nattybatty55

by LivingEnd

You guys done an amazing job getting so far! i hope you'll come back for the Lucky Looser challenge and continue voting in this round.

Awards

MelC wins the Voter's Choice Award and gets a new shiny banner Congratulations!

Macayla receives the ACIA Award thanks to the wonderful and original coloring as well as great use of text. Love your icon!

I'll be posting the next challenge soon.

 

[MelC]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ Results!

Sorry to see both of you go, nattybatty55 and LivingEnd....

Congrats, Macayla...

Thanks for the votes! To be honest, I thought my icon was a bit plain since the no layers rule, but I'm glad you guys liked it.

 

[dopebabygirl]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ Results!

Sorry to see both of you go, nattybatty55 and LivingEnd.

Congrats MelC and Macayla

 

[FieldMouse]

Re: LIMS #6 Challenge 5: No Layers! ~ Results!

So sorry to see you go Nattybatty and LivingEnd.

Congrats to MelC and Macayla