doublehelix:
I tend to dismiss the argument that there are too many characters on the show. In previous seasons there were the losses of Meagan, Speedle, and a hodge podge of various detectives that came and went. Since then we've added Ryan, Natalia, and Frank. So character wise we're pretty much at the same level now as we were then.
I agree that there always were a lot of actors working on the show, but there were never more than six regulars (in the credits) from Seasons 1-4 - now there's seven. (In seasons 1 &2, for the most part, there were only five regulars - the CSIs and Alexx, so there was much more room for those characters to grow. There was no obligation to make sure this detective or that lab rat got three scenes per ep b/c they weren't regulars.)
I think it's better when there's rotating detectives and not the same old same old every week. (I'd hope the new coronor would just pop in now and again, or rotate between a couple of actors - he or she doesn't have to be a regular).
When you have seven people that you HAVE to give screen time to, someone is bound to suffer, and in this case it was Alexx. It's the fact that they have an obligation to fit everyone into at least two or three scenes a week, but they don't group them together - they have all these two-character scenes now. So the team seems really disjointed, and it's like playing this game - "Will Calleigh be in the end of the episode b/c she was in three scenes in the beginning?" or "Will Ryan show up in the first 20 mins.?"
The show just feels too crowded to me, especially w/all these recurring cast members they're adding, like Kyle and Julia, etc. And then you've got Stetler and Jake (well, who knows if he'll be back) and occassionally Yelina. So it's a pretty freakin' big cast. And it never felt that way to me in Seasons 1-3.
In the end, Alexx got the short end of the stick. I always felt her character was more connected to the CSIs and was brought in to do more than just a 2 min. autopsy scene. When they dropped Meghan in Season 1, that left five strong regulars who carried the show well w/a few supporting actors. Alexx had a chance to shine b/c of this. Now it's kind of a mish-mosh and the team just doesn't feel like a team.
I don't know what the CSIs (especially poor Ryan, who keeps getting screwed
) are going to do w/out their "Team Mom". I just hope she gets the nice exit that she deserves - she's earned it, sticking it out this long.