CSI: NY Bloody Murder/Blood OnThe Sun books

Re: CSI: NY BLOODY MURDER/BLOOD ON THE SUN BOOKS

Mel23 said:
Can someone spoil me on the last page thing? I've heard comments from some fans about not liking something about Mac and Stella's ending on the last page.

Stella's not on the last page...which might be what they're complaining about. The book ends with Mac and Jane talking about Mac's wife and how he was dealing with her death.

I really like these books. Stu puts a real touch to them that I just love.
 
Re: CSI: NY BLOODY MURDER/BLOOD ON THE SUN BOOKS

*nod* I think it was the Mac and Jane part, many fans don't like her much. I had misinterpreted the original post to that topic anyhow, so my bad.

I agree, both books have been good. Well, all three.
 
Re: CSI: NY BLOODY MURDER/BLOOD ON THE SUN BOOKS

Blood on the Sun is a major improvement over Dead of Winter.
 
Re: CSI: NY BLOODY MURDER/BLOOD ON THE SUN BOOKS

Talk about typos dudes. In Dead of Winter, page 250, Don was mentioned twice, doing separate actions.
Overall DOW is okay. Long and consuming but I don't see the SMACked action the fans keep shouting about.
 
Re: CSI: NY BLOODY MURDER/BLOOD ON THE SUN BOOKS

Not what I was expecting either. I think the author's mixing up both Don Flack and Carmine's history with Danny Messer's.

That's the problem with a lot of TV-tie in books like this. By the time the writer has finished writing their book, the series has moved on and established canon that may or may not contradict with what the writer had planned. I'm guessing that maybe the original character outline for Danny mentioned a police background in his family, but that was later changed on the show. But by then the book was already drafted and couldn't be changed. Just IMO.
 
Re: CSI: NY BLOODY MURDER/BLOOD ON THE SUN BOOKS

I enjoyed the book but -- like most people here -- did NOT like the hint of Mac/Jane shipperness in the book, which has never been an issue on the actual show. If Mac is going to get "involved" with a woman he works with, I definitely want it to be Stella.
 
Re: CSI: NY BLOODY MURDER/BLOOD ON THE SUN BOOKS

^ From what you folks have posted here, looks like Blood on the Sun is a good buy. I happened to see a copy in a small local bookstore here, and I was thrilled! But I'm torn between buying it or NY's S1 DVD. Shouldn't be a hard choice there, I suppose. :p But I will buy the book one of these days.
 
Re: CSI: NY BLOODY MURDER/BLOOD ON THE SUN BOOKS

Long and consuming but I don't see the SMACked action the fans keep shouting about.

well, you know SMacked shippers... every little detail we can see... :lol: I am a SMacked shipper and yes, I did squeal in some parts of the book.

I wrote a SMacked fic after reading the book(BotS) cause I wasn't satisfied with the ending...:lol:
 
Back
Top