CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Round 1 - Final Challenge - RESULTS

Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

Sorry, i thought that i have to comment only 2

#11 has too much coloring
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

I think you have a mistake in the instructions, Tuesday:

tuesdaymorning said:
-Comment to this post with your chosen 3 icons. (make sure to look at all of the icons, and don't randomly pick bad ones, pick the TOP TWO OF LEAST QUALITY).

Remember to vote for 3 icons.
Click to expand...

Are we voting off 2, or 3 icons? And do you we put them in any particular order (i.e. worst first, or worst last)?
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

17 - over sharpened n a little orangey
4 - looks a little grainy/random pixely patches
1 - the softer focus doesn't fit with the black/white colouring

eep! that was hard
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

#17: It's oversharpened and very orange/brown.
#2: It's too bright and the picture's blurred.
#8: The scale seems wrong, her face looks stretched.
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

17-over sharpened and too colorized
11-over colorized
13-sharpened a little too much and border swirls seems a little out of place
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

17 - the image is too sharp
1 - it's not creative enough
2 - in other circumstances i wouldn't be able to identify who's on the icon

i hope my reasons are ok. if not, tell me and i'll change them or my votes. thanks :)
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

17-It's too oversharpened and too orange/brown
2-It's too bright and blurry
1-It'S blurry and not creative..

I hope thia reasons are OK :)
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

12 - animation is jarring and unnecessary, text is difficult to read, picture is pixelated
17 - overly sharpened, too dark
07 - bad cropping (her nose looks weird), uninteresting/unnoticable colouring, plain
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

MyIronLung, you may not vote off icons since you are not included in the initial list of participants.
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

but doesn't TM said that:

-You don't need to be a participant of the challenge in order to vote.

so everyone can vote right :)
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

17: too sharpened
07: the cropping makes her nose look weird
01: the text and overall look is a bit plain
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

17. It seems to be a little sharp, so it's definitely a major turnoff. The color is also odd. It clashes with the background.

02. A little too bright. The cropping looks a little off as well, whereas half the left eye is showing so it makes the picture less symetrical.

08. The stretching definetly is a turnoff for the icon. It doesn't look like the cropping was working.
 
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25

17 - it's oversharpened and too much of the orange/brown colour
2 - colouring is too overwhelming/too bright
4 - a bit too blurry
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top