CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Round 1 - Final Challenge - RESULTS
- Thread starter tuesdaymorning
- Start date
life_style
Pathologist
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25
First I just want to say: Good job, everyone
Your icons are all really pretty!
These are my votes:
17 - Too sharp. The colouring dominates the whole icon, which takes attention away from the subject (Vanessa). Very creative though.
02 - The nose kind of disappears, I think it's too highlighted. You were also very creative though.
07 - First off, interesting crop. However, my main critique about this is that it brings out the "less attractive" stuff in her features, for example her nose looks kind of weird.
Wow, I feel really bad for voting. It's hard to choose the three you like the least, when you like all of the ones you people have made :lol:
First I just want to say: Good job, everyone
Your icons are all really pretty! These are my votes:
17 - Too sharp. The colouring dominates the whole icon, which takes attention away from the subject (Vanessa). Very creative though.
02 - The nose kind of disappears, I think it's too highlighted. You were also very creative though.
07 - First off, interesting crop. However, my main critique about this is that it brings out the "less attractive" stuff in her features, for example her nose looks kind of weird.
Wow, I feel really bad for voting. It's hard to choose the three you like the least, when you like all of the ones you people have made :lol:
sherlockanne
Lab Technician
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25
Wow these are all so great! This is tough...
17 - Interesting effect, but it looks way over sharpened and the coloring is a little strange.
12 - The animation is distracting and the text is a little difficult to read.
01 - The whole look is just too plain.
Great job everyone!
Wow these are all so great! This is tough...
17 - Interesting effect, but it looks way over sharpened and the coloring is a little strange.
12 - The animation is distracting and the text is a little difficult to read.
01 - The whole look is just too plain.
Great job everyone!
quickbeam_cw
CSI Level One
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25
Wow, these are ALL so beautiful, everyone! It's so great to see the different interpretations of the pic, and was EXTREMELY difficult to choose. But, what must be done, must be done.
17 - difficult to see the right-hand image; I liked how you put a close up of her eyes on top, but they are also very difficult to see
14 - a little too contrasty, although I really like what you did with her lips, they really stand out. However, the contrast on her skintone sort of distracts from the lips.
05 - very interesting crop, and although I definitely liked your creativity with it, I found it sort of excludes too much of the subject. Also, the colouring of each half separately is nice, but together I find they don't really fit.
Once again, well done everyone, and I hope to see more of your lovely work in the future.
Wow, these are ALL so beautiful, everyone! It's so great to see the different interpretations of the pic, and was EXTREMELY difficult to choose.
But, what must be done, must be done. 17 - difficult to see the right-hand image; I liked how you put a close up of her eyes on top, but they are also very difficult to see
14 - a little too contrasty, although I really like what you did with her lips, they really stand out. However, the contrast on her skintone sort of distracts from the lips.
05 - very interesting crop, and although I definitely liked your creativity with it, I found it sort of excludes too much of the subject. Also, the colouring of each half separately is nice, but together I find they don't really fit.
Once again, well done everyone, and I hope to see more of your lovely work in the future.
ziggystarduzt
CSI Level Two
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25
Wow, there are some really gorgeous icons here!!! This was a hard decision to make
17- quite oversharpened, pixellated, and grainy.
2- A little too much contrast
1- I found it rather plain and soft. Not overly creative.
Wow, there are some really gorgeous icons here!!! This was a hard decision to make
17- quite oversharpened, pixellated, and grainy.
2- A little too much contrast
1- I found it rather plain and soft. Not overly creative.
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25
17 - Too sharpened, image too burnt, too little contrast
14 - The coloring is too dark, not enough contrast
3 - Cropping aspect ratio for mini frame a little off (I tried to overlook this, but the mini VF keeps winking at me, I swear! )
Mods, I think someone already asked this, but can we mention the ones we like most too? At least after the round is over?
17 - Too sharpened, image too burnt, too little contrast
14 - The coloring is too dark, not enough contrast
3 - Cropping aspect ratio for mini frame a little off (I tried to overlook this, but the mini VF keeps winking at me, I swear!
)Mods, I think someone already asked this, but can we mention the ones we like most too? At least after the round is over?
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25
Well considering this is the 'Last Iconmaker Standing' competition, and the main idea is to vote off our least favorite icons, and wouldn't commenting on the ones we likes the best after the fact defeat the purpose of this competition?
But who knows, I think it's a nice idea anyway.
Well considering this is the 'Last Iconmaker Standing' competition, and the main idea is to vote off our least favorite icons, and wouldn't commenting on the ones we likes the best after the fact defeat the purpose of this competition?
But who knows, I think it's a nice idea anyway.
Hottie_Cath
Corpse
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25
17 - The icon is oversharpened and grainy
2- too much contrast and too blurry
4- icon looks too washed out
17 - The icon is oversharpened and grainy
2- too much contrast and too blurry
4- icon looks too washed out
life_style
Pathologist
Re: CSI/Miami/NY LIMS - Icon Challenge #25
Just a question; when will this first challenge end?
Just a question; when will this first challenge end?