Interesting question! Horatio has my vote, hands down. He's older, maybe not quite in tip-top form, but he would fight a whole lot smarter than his juniors. BRAINS WIN OVER BRAUN EVERY TIME!
I pick H because...he would probably out smart all of them, kick everbody butt, then put his sunnies on and do his pose! *haha ok,^^^^^^ that is cheeeeesy!*
Horatio would have more experience and knowledge than the rest of them. He is in reasonably good shape. Speed would be my second choice. Being dead might have its advantages.
I am not sure why they would be having a fight among them. Hopefully, they would be able to settle any arguments without a fight. But to answer the poll, I picked Horatio Caine, the secret identity of Super H. Born on the planet Krypton before it exploded, H can leave a building seconds before an explosion without getting a hair out of place. He can spot a trace clue from fifty feet away with his telescopic vision. So, he must have the super strength to win a fight... IF they had one.
Wait...why are the 4 of them fighting in the first place? I don't want to see them fighting, I want to see them working together (well, with Speed resting peacefully)! I'm just being a nerd. I voted for Ryan just out of my love for him (although you never now...), but realistically? I may have to give the edge to Eric...
Thats right. H does have telekepathic powers and I am still being convinced that Speed was born on planet Krypton.