TalkCSI LIMS . Round 2 . Challenge #8. FINAL RESULTS ARE IN

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

01 too dark
02 too yellow

i think this was the harderst choice so far, amazing job yo.
 
Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

*Is very confused* Wait... Isn't the deadline for submitting entries Sunday, December 31 8pm GMT??? Maybe I've got the date wrong cause things have been so crazy here and we're having a party today, but according to the clock it's still 4pm on Sunday... It's no big deal, it's just that I was going to submit my icon today. :confused: Sorry if I'm totally off!
 
Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

sherlockanne said:
*Is very confused* Wait... Isn't the deadline for submitting entries Sunday, December 31 8pm GMT??? Maybe I've got the date wrong cause things have been so crazy here and we're having a party today, but according to the clock it's still 4pm on Sunday... It's no big deal, it's just that I was going to submit my icon today. :confused: Sorry if I'm totally off!
Oh God, I made a mistake. I'm so sorry. :( It's been crazy around here as well and I got confused.

I've thought about this and here's what I propose we do:
1. Void all votes that have been posted so far.
2. I'll accept entries until the set deadline [Sunday Dec 31, 2006 8pm GMT]. All iconmakers can submit/resubmit until then.
3. I'll PM all the remaining iconmakers if this setup works for them. If so, we'll proceed to voting on the next day [Monday].

I'm sorry to everyone [to iconmakers and those who voted]. We'll hold off voting until further notice.
 
Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

Okay let's try this again. :)

Challenge #7 - Robert David Hall - VOTING

* Dardeile is using their free pass for this round.
* Lost2MuchSpeed has failed to submit an entry and is automatically eliminated. Thanks for joining; I hope you had fun.

We're back to our old ways of voting. Please vote for 3. We'll be eliminating 2 iconmakers.

- Vote for top 3 of least quality. Include a valid reason for each vote, otherwise it won't be counted.
- Any member of this board may vote.
- The makers of the icons with the top two number of votes will be eliminated.


Examples of good reasons:
50: The text is oddly placed
68: The colouring is overpowering
72: The icon is oversharpened
56: The icon is too blurry

Examples of bad reasons:
50: I hate the colour pink. (Personal Preference)
78: The tiny text/decorative brush is unreadable." (Because they’re supposed to be that way.)

01
6af6c8c7.png
02
eedd0f22-2.jpg
03
eedd0f22-1.jpg
04
eedd0f22.jpg


*PM me if you don't see your icon
 
Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

Sorry about the mixup cofi!

Well I'd vote for three but one of them is mine so it would be pretty obvious which one it was if I did... :eek: So I'll just vote for two to make it fair...

02 - Too dark on the right side and a bit plain.
04 - Doc's face is a little too pink.

(if you still want me to vote for three, let me know :))

Good luck all! :)
 
Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

#3 needs more contrast
#2 too plain and you cannot see his right eye cause it´s too dark
#4 face looks a bit pink
 
Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

02 - too dark
03 - too yellow
01 - the cropping is too conservative (okay, i admit, i totally couldn't figure out a reason cuz the icon is great, lol)

awesome job y'all.
 
Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

sherlockanne said:
Well I'd vote for three but one of them is mine so it would be pretty obvious which one it was if I did... :eek: So I'll just vote for two to make it fair...

02 - Too dark on the right side and a bit plain.
04 - Doc's face is a little too pink.

(if you still want me to vote for three, let me know :))
I know which one sherlockannes is, so I'm voting for two (atm) as well

02 - Too bright
03 - Too dark
 
Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

3. The text is a bit plain
1. It doesn't look like Doc Robbins has been edited
4. His face is a bit pink
 
Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

4:The face is too smooth..Or blurred, don't know what it is, actually.
2:Too dark on the right.
3: Too much yellow...
 
Back
Top