TalkCSI LIMS . Round 2 . Challenge #8. FINAL RESULTS ARE IN

[sherlockanne]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

Great job guys!

10 - Far too bright and oversharpened.
01 - Archie's face looks distorted. Oversharpened?
13 - Too blurry, his face is a bit fuzzy.

Good luck everyone!

 

[Chez]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

#10 - too bright
#13 - the colors of the sidebar don´t match
#01 - the pink background looks strange

 

[Lauw]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

#12 - Bad cropping, Archie is too small and sharpened
#13 - Too blurry
#1 - His face looks distorted

 

[saraholic]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

#5- It looks like he has antlers growing out of his head, plus the crop makes everything look a little too white.
#10- Too bright.
#12- The crop makes him look too far away, plus it looks a little too bright.

 

[Macayla]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

13 - Too blurry
12 - crop looks to far away
08 - Too dark

 

[life_style]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

First of all; good job guys, they are all so pretty!

12. He's too far away, it's kind of hard to tell it's him.
13. Too blurry.
5. The fact that the white color joins in with him kind of makes it look odd and disturbs the entire icon (I guess you could say it's a bad crop in a way).

 

[Lost2MuchSpeed]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

12 - over sharpened n odd crop
13 - he's a little blurry
1 - also oversharpened

eeepp. good luck

 

[Astrid]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

12....oversharpened
10....too bright
5.....Too mcuh white not enough Archie

 

[Adzix]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

12 - he's not really recognizable
10 - too much sharpen
13 - too blurry

GREAT job you guys!

 

[Nim]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

*running*
Wooo, just in time to vote!!!

Wow, nice icons!!! mmm, let me see...

12 - the subject is too small and sharpened
10 - too bright
5 - too much white around, and Archie is too saturated

 

[cofi_shot]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

Challenge #3 - RESULTS

We must now say goodbye to two iconmakers:

by Chez and

by Astrid

Thanks for joining! I hope you stick around.

Mod's Choice

Archie is love! Fantastic everything (coloring, cropping, etc.)

Tally
01 : 08
02 : -
03 : -
04 : 03
05 : 06
06 : 03
07 : 01
08 : 01
09 : -
10 : 18
11 : 01
12 : 35
13 : 20

I'll post the next challenge later so watch out for it.

 

[Macayla]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

Congrats to Sherlockanne, you deserve it

Chez and Astrid, you did a great job, hope you'll join next time too

 

[Chez]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

That happens if you do icons in a hurry But it was fun anyway. Good luck to the other iconmakers.

 

[wibble]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

Congrats to Sherlockanne!

Hope you join us again in the next round Chez and Astrid.

 

[Dragonfly]

Re: TalkCSI LIMS ~ Round 2

*cookies for Chez and Astrid
Congrats Sherlockanne!