Talk LIMS #8: Final Results!

Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

This is getting difficult!

Least
6 - The text is oddly placed, too much space between 'S' and 'tella'.
7 - It looks like nothing much has been done to the icon. Love the sparkling blue heart but Stella looks kind of flat.
2 - The text is too big and her lips and eyes are too red (or is it orange?).

Best
5 - Love the colouring, great font!
8 - Stella in black and white looks good! Cool font.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

least:
02 - the white box makes it look a little bit strange
12 - oversharped?
06 - stella looks abit unsharp and i personally dont like the text....

best:
01
10


i KNOW i'll be out this round, lol, but good luck to all of you :D
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

Least
10 - text blends in with the bright background making it difficult to see.
02 - text box is a big too large, overpowering the subject.
07 - very dark.

Best
05 - The coloring is really pretty.
03 - I like the font and the texture.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

LQ
02 Bonasera overpowers the icon
10 the name is too cramped together
12 oversharpened

BQ
07
03
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

Least:
03 - the frame and the text take too much focus away from Stella. The icon is also rather dark and lacks color
07 - it dosn't seem as if there has been done alot to the icon. It's also dark and could've been colored more.
06 - Stella's face is too bright and the text might be a little too big

Best:
10 - I really like the coloring
11 - also beautifully colored and the frame works well with the crop
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

Least
03 - Too dark. The texture/frame doesn't really fit and the text seems too big.
04 - oversharpened or oversaturated, not sure. There is nothing really outstanding about this icon.
08 - I like b&w effects, but this one looks grainy. Also, the text it too big for a close-up icon and the positioning could have been more creative.

Best
This was a close call...

10 - I like the coloring and the positioning of the text.
01 - The text adds a nice touch to the icon, although the picture itself could have been sharpened a bit more. (Please, could the person who made this icon tell me which font you used for "not easily" after the challange? Thx :D )
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

Least:

07 - it's very dark and it looks like alot hasn't been done to the icon. The text also doesn't imo add much, it would look better if the colouring was brighter.
12 - oversharpened
03 - Also very dark and plain. Text/brush overwhelms the icon imo.

Best:
1
10
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6

Least:

02 - Her face looks too orange
03 - The icon is a little to dark
07 -Too dark, colouring and contrast are missing

Best:

01 - Love the coloring and the text
10 - Beautiful coloring and like the font
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

Least:
3- the icon is a bit dark, and the frame and text are a bit overpowering
7- doesn't really look like much has been to it, could have maybe used a bit of coloring.
6- looks like there maybe too much contrast, especially over her face.

Best:
5- the coloring is stunning and the textures that were used fit really well and aren't overpowering at all.
11- i love the coloring it's bright but natural and the frame is a nice touch
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

Least:

07: Doesn't look like a lot has been done except for adding the text.
03: Like my first choice, there doesn't seem to be a lot done to the icon except for the frame and text.
06: I love the text, but it's a little too big, and the actual picture is too bright.

Best:

11: Love the colouring and the white border looks really good.
12: Awesome colour and text.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

We still need more votes, please! I'd like to post results tomorrow, but there are ties that need to be broken.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6

Least:

10- A little too much contrast or brightness, makes the color look a bit washed out.
05- A little blurry on her face.
06- A little too much contrast or brightness on her face. Love the text though.

Best:

11- Very nice coloring.
03- love the text and the bar/texture on the side and bottom.


Great job, everyone. :)
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

Least
03 - plain
07 - plain
08 - it seems the text is *crammed* into the icon

Best
11 - great coloring
01 - i like the font and overall effect of the text
 
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6 - Voting!

Least
07: Doesn't appear that much has been done with the icon -- some colouring and a little contrast may have helped make it pop.
03: Adding some more colour to the subject of the icon may have made it more cohesive overall with the texture and text.
02: The colouring seems a bit unnatural; Stella is really orange.

Best
05
12
 
Last edited:
Re: Talk LIMS #8: Challenge 6

Round 6 Results!

The two participants leaving this round are:

Stella07.png
heartcore

Stella02.png
shazza_018

Thanks so much for joining, and I hope we'll see you for the comeback challenge :)


Voter's Choice: Miss_Undercover
VotersR06.png


DragonflysBeenDazzled: luf100
ModsR06.png


Wonderful icons Ladies, congrats!

01: +5
02: -9
03: -9+5 = -4
04: -1
05: -1+6 = +5
06: -7
07: -12+1 = -11
08: -2+2 = 0
09: 0
10: -4+5 = +1
11: +7
12: -3+2 = -1

The next challenge will be the comeback challenge!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top