Talk LIMS #7: FINAL RESULTS!

Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Voting!

2- Jumped out straight away, obviously you have a lot of patience to do this
8- the slogan made me giggle and it's just a great choice of colour
4- just felt different and quite simple but still effective

Really hard choice in two ways,
1. all the work was fab, with some really nice effects, text etc used
2. I love greg :drool: lol
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Voting!

09: love the whole composition of this icon, great work!
03: nicely done - crop, coloring, place of text and choice of font. Could've been a bit brighter, though ;)
08: simple, but s/t less is more, right? Good coloring and the icon is clear but not over-sharpened nor over-contrasted (you get what I mean :D) and the text is placed well and has been highlighted with the black color as background: great work!

I had to make a decision, there were again more than three icons I would've wanted to vote for, great icons everyone!
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Voting!

Okay, as it stands now, we've got a three-way tie for second place. I had been hoping to do the top 2, plus a mod's choice. That won't really work now, but I'd still like to bring back an uneven number. So, we have two options here:

1: I can take the top 4 plus a mod's choice, letting 5 people back into the challenge
2: I put up a tie-breaker vote between the top 4 icons, and let the top 2 plus a mod's choice (chosen from all the icons) back into the challenge

Now, I can make the decision myself, but I'd like to get your opinions on the matter. Which would you prefer?
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Voting!

I say second option !! :p I don't know exactly what's top 4 but I'm curious .. and I think letting 5 people back in is maybe a bit to much .. ( sorry )
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Voting Closed ~ please read

I'm in favour of the first option.. it just seems easier for all concerned.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Voting Closed ~ please read

I think the second option is better. 5 people seems like a lot to let back. This is my first time participating in the LIMS and I'm not sure how long it lasts, and although we do vote out two people each time, it seems like bringing 5 people back will be just a little too much. I think just three is better. That's my opinion, though.

So I vote option 2.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Voting Closed ~ please read

I would say the second one, five people are too many, it would make the challenge be too long...
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Voting Closed ~ please read

2nd option, agree with what has been mentioned above. Five back might just be to many, since normally 2 are voted out every round.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Voting Closed ~ please read

I vote for the second option as well. Five people coming back would add a sizable amount of time to this LIMS that a lot of people hadn't accounted for.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Voting Closed ~ please read

Second option sounds best to me too. Bringing back 5 contestants may be a bit much, (no offence ;))
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Comeback Challenge ~ Tie Breaker! Please Vote!

Alright, most people seem to want option 2, and I was leaning that way myself. Sooo, here are the top 4 icons from the Comeback voting. I'd like to keep as close to a regular schedule as possible, and don't want this to drag on, so I'm only going to leave this open for a day or two. Please get your votes in as soon as possible :)

Remember, top 2 icons, plus a mod's choice (selected from the original 10) will be brought back into the challenge.

Voting Rules:
~ Absolutely anyone may vote!
~ Please don't vote for your own icon.
~ Vote for the 2 icons of best quality
~ Reasons/Comments are highly encouraged :)
~ If you wish to leave constructive comments for those (or some of those) that you didn't vote for, you may do so.

01
Greg03.png
02
Greg05.png
03
Greg06.jpg
04
Greg08.png

Any problems, please let me know!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top