Talk LIMS #7: FINAL RESULTS!

Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Voting!

LQ:
6- too dark
21- too blurry
20- too bright

BQ:
8- love the over all icon. Especially the design in the upper right corner
16- the crop and the coloring is great
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Wendy Simms

LQ:
22-purple, too much purple
15 -color and blurry
21-no sharp and blackground

BQ:
2 -good cropping job,
12-color
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Voting!

Least:

06 - Seems like nothing much has been done, besides the crop.
22 - The colouring is kind of odd.
16 - Seems to be oversharpened.

Best:

18 - Great colouring and cropping, the skull looks great, it really adds to the effectiveness.
14 - The cropping looks good, as does the effect in the background.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Voting!

least (cringe...sorry! I hate this part!)

20: the contrast is too distracting
11: Interesting crop but the black side bar takes away from the image.
12: The icon looks washed out, Wendy looks pale and blurry.

best
17: the 'halo' and lighting is really pretty, the colour is subtle and suits the icon.
9: great crop and colouring, the heart brush is really effective.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Voting!

I so hate doing this... :(

LQ:
06 - too dark
10 - too blurry
21 - blurry, and the background's overwhelming

BQ:
19
12
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Wendy Simms

Least
22 - There's something in the texture which doesn't look good to me. Also the purple is a little bit too much for the original cap.
02 - Ther's too much space not used because of the frame.
06 - Too dark.

Best
14- I just love the texture.
03 - Love the texture.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Voting!

LQ
06 - nothing has been done to the icon
22 - the purple coloring doesn't fit and Wendy's face is oversharpened
20 - too bright and overcontrasted

BQ
14 - i like how the texture has been incorporated into the icon
16 - interesting idea, the coloring and contrast are nicely balanced
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Voting!

Oh this is hard. I hate having to choose "least" quality, but here goes.

Least
22 - the color overpowers...maybe a blend of other colors would have worked better?
19 - the dark shadow at the bottom detracts from the overall picture
6 - dark and seems like a simple crop with no additional effects

Best
18 - I like how this version cuts the corners of her mouth so she looks more serious (or as serious as a dead body can look :lol: )
1 - nice crop and lighting
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Voting!

Thanks for all the votes so far everyone! As always, please keep them coming. The more the merrier!

I'd like to post results on Thursday if possible, so get your votes in before then :D
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Voting!

LQ:

22- The face appears dark and the purple background is a bit overpowering.
10- Too blurry.
20- Too bright.

BQ:

7- Good colouring.
9- Nice icon.
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Voting!

First of all: great work everyone! :)

LQ:

21 - A bit too blurry and the texture is kind of distracting from the subject.
10 - The cropping is a bit unfortunate and it's a bit blurry because of the texture layer - using the eraser tool in the region of the face might help.
22 - Well, the cropping is good and the icon is also sharp enough but somehow the background color/texture (?) doesn't fit in. I hope I made any sense...

BQ:

11 - Love the style and it looks pretty scary - great work! (perhaps it could've been a bit brighter, but that's all ;))
09 - Good coloring, cropping and nice heart-effect :D
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Wendy Simms

Least:

14 - too bright, Wendy's body looks to orange, a litlle blurry
6 - too dark, colouring is missing
18 - too dark, not good cropping

Best:

1 - like the natural look, good gropping, nice colouring
2 - is simply, but I like the photo frame effect
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Wendy Simms

Talk LIMS #7 Round Three ~ Results

Once again, two of our participants have been eliminated:

Wendy06.jpg
by FallenForFlack

Wendy22.png
by ILuvJonathanTogo

Hope you enjoyed yourselves! Thanks so much for joining us :)


Our banner winners:

Voter's Choice:
VotersChoiceR03.png

Congrats! Well deserved :)

Mod's Choice:
ModsChoiceR03.png

I absolutely love the colouring in this one. It's also nice to see a different crop. Great work :D

01: +3
02: -2+3 = +1
03: -2+1 = -1
04: -1+3 = +2
05: 0
06: -14
07: +4
08: -2+2 = 0
09: +6
10: -6
11: -2+4 = +2
12: -1+3 = +2
13: -2
14: -4+5 = +1
15: -3
16: -1+3 = +2
17: +2
18: -2+2 = 0
19: -1+3 = +2
20: -5
21: -10+2 = -8
22: -11
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Results!

I'm actually quite relieved to be out, lol, my creativity is gone as you can see in my lack of doing more than cropping in my icon.

Congrats to Adzix and Miss_Undercover!
 
Re: Talk LIMS #7: Challenge Three ~ Results!

Sorry to see you go Kristine and ILuvJonathonTogo, it's been great having you with us. :D Well done Adzix and Becci, both of your icons were awesome. :D Great job!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top