Originally Posted by
Wyoming 
This post is in reference to the problem that some people who are entering into the beginners category really belong in the advanced category, vice versa and all that good stuff. If some people are doing it to win (which I don’t think they are) then this will fix that problem, we hope.
Okay, so we’ve asked tons of opinions and I’ve gotten help from people from other boards who run sites that are strictly for art purposes. I’ve heard the same answer from almost everyone, and it looks like the criteria idea is the one that is going to stick. So, in my lousy attempt to make all of this make sense (especially since I took 3 hour test this morning) please bear with me.
Cinegirl and I have made our decision, and here is how it is going to go:
First off, these are
guidelines. They are not written in stone, because we understand that some circumstances are different than others. BUT I would like everyone to read them and use them so that you can determine what category you are in if there is a beginner and advanced challenge. Se we really encourage you guys to use them and put yourselves in the right category. We’re doing it this way so that no one feels like they are getting their toes stepped on. We still want you guys to pick your categories and have as much freedom as possible.
Here are the guidelines for entering into advanced. If you feel you do not meet these, you might consider beginners.:
1. Icon makers who have been at it for six months or more.
2. Knowledge of coloring, textures and brushes is wide.
3. Consider how many tutorials you have gone through, they make you a heck of a lot better. The more you followed, the more towards advanced you have become. Also consider how much you have used them since you followed the tutorial.
4. Look at the compliments you get. If someone seems amazed at your icon, and uses it without requesting it, that’s saying something. Consider how many times this has happened to you.
5. This is the most important one. If you have won
Three or more challenges in one particular area of art (icons, banners, ect) then move up to advanced, give someone else a chance to win beginners
.
6. Take what you know about fanart, and compare it to what you have seen. Where would you put yourself?
7. This one probably trumps number 5. Use your absolute best judgment. Put yourself in the category you truly think you should be in, and if you aren’t sure, pm someone who can help you.
Note: For example, if you enter an advanced challenge for an icon, it does not mean you have to enter the same level for a wallpaper challenge, or a banner challenge, ect. Use your judgment for each category, and use the guidelines to help you pick a category.
