CSI: New York--'Not What It Looks Like'

CSI Files

Captain
Synopsis:

When three women dressed as Holly Golightly from Breakfast at Tiffany's rob a jewelry store, they leave the assistant manager dead in their wake. Stella quickly determines the death was an accident--the security gate hit the trigger of one of the fallen guns, causing it to fire at the hapless man, but Lindsay notes it's still murder since it happened during the robbery. The CSIs discover that the women escaped out an old air vent that no one employed in the store knew about. Inside it, Lindsay discovers the discarded disguises and rifles. Danny puzzles over the lack of stress marks on the shattered glass from the jewelry cases, and brings in his dog to prove a theory he has. He thinks the women used a sign wave generator to shatter the glass, and he proves his theory when his dog reacts to the wave generator and a piece of glass he's testing shatters, leaving no stress marks. When a young woman is caught trying to get a necklace appraised, the CSIs think they have a real lead, until it turns out she was at the scene and simply picked up a necklace that dropped by her when the robbers were collecting their bounty.

Mac and Detective Angell arrive at the site of a building demolition, where the mummified body of a woman suspected to be Pauline Rayburn, the wife of Councilman Matthew Rayburn, has been found. Peyton Driscoll and Sid Hammerback confirm her identity, and assess that she's been dead for three to four weeks. A cadre of reporters and an eager young ADA named Jeremy Bloomfield are eager for Mac to confirm she's been murdered, but Mac refuses to jump to conclusions. When Peyton declares the young woman died of a heart attack, he urges her to go back and reassess the COD, and she counters that he needs to bring her evidence that will give her an idea of where to start. Mac and Adam return to the apartment to take a computer image of it. Mac finds a dead beetle stuck to the wall. Prints in the apartment lead them to Sal Bavado, who admits he was hired by Rayburn to dump the body, but he denies killing her. ADA Bloomfield is eager to arrest Rayburn, but Mac urges him to hold off until they have conclusive evidence of something more than a body dump.

Adam and Mac try to puzzle out conflicting evidence: the body is mummified, indicating low humidity, but the presence of the beetle indicates the humidity was high. The body was placed right in front of the air conditioning, suggesting someone was hoping to mask the smell from it. Mac realizes the power must have gone off at some point, allowing the beetles to enter, and then come back on. The fluctuation in temperature could have thrown Peyton's autopsy findings off. He shares his findings with her, and she reexamines Pauline, this time finding evidence of fatal blows to the jaw and neck, as well as the distinct imprint of a Claddagh ring identical to the one Rayburn wears. The evidence is finally conclusive, and Rayburn is arrested.

<HR ALIGN="CENTER" SIZE="1" WIDTH="45%" COLOR="#007BB5">

To read the full reviews, please click here.<center></center>
 
Wow, you're quick :p

You pretty much nailed exactly what I thought of the episode. This episode was fantastic.

I absolutely loved the whole Holly Golightly idea. It was so creative and it hooked me the second they started playing "I Love NY" by Madonna.

And the dog. Oh man, that was such a cute scene to add into a serious episode. That dog was adorable, and after a little while, you can see a similar resemblance to the dog and Danny. Gotta love how irritated he was getting.

Im still curious as to whose dog it is .. I don't see Danny have a dog like that.

Ending the episode with their hug took away from Lindsay's heroic moment; Danny was an unnecessary element in the scene, as he has been much of the time in her character's development. I would have rather seen Lindsay take down Mosi or free Dana. So much of her character development has been wrapped up in her relationship to Danny, and I would have preferred she have this moment to herself. Still, it was kind of cool to see the guy waiting on the sidelines while the girl goes in to save the day.

I, sort of agree. I think Danny going to find her and see if she was okay, was fine but I do think it lingered on that for too long.

I would've like to have seen them hug for like 10-15 secs and then Lindsey either, go find the girl - becuase that's the reason she was in there in the first place - or walk up to Flack and Stella and they see if she's okay as well. As a memeber of their team, I'd assume they were worried about her as well.

I am loving Det. Angell, already. Im really glad to see her again, cause Im really starting to like her but I also like that she wasn't afraid to mention her uneasiness about finding the corpse, to Mac. Peyton is getting a little more tolerable as well. She just seemed a little more laid back than in the premiere. Her accent calmed down a bit more too, which may have been a factor.

Correct me if Im wrong, but isn't Sid the head ME...? Wouldn't he be able to autopsy the corpse if he wanted to..?

And again, I must curse CTV for not airing promos for next week's episode *shakes fist*
 
Thanks, audrina! :)

allstar12 said:
Wow, you're quick :p

I was trying to make up for the fact that my Miami review still isn't up yet! :eek: It's been a busy week and I have yet to see the episode!

I absolutely loved the whole Holly Golightly idea. It was so creative and it hooked me the second they started playing "I Love NY" by Madonna.

The intro was great--one of my favorite things about the episode! It was really well done--a definite attention grabber.

And the dog. Oh man, that was such a cute scene to add into a serious episode. That dog was adorable, and after a little while, you can see a similar resemblance to the dog and Danny. Gotta love how irritated he was getting.

Im still curious as to whose dog it is .. I don't see Danny have a dog like that.

I think it was supposed to be Danny's dog, but yeah, I was surprised too. I can't see Danny taking care of a fish, let alone a dog. :lol: It was a nice bit of comic relief, though, that also furthered the plot.

I, sort of agree. I think Danny going to find her and see if she was okay, was fine but I do think it lingered on that for too long.

I would've like to have seen them hug for like 10-15 secs and then Lindsey either, go find the girl - becuase that's the reason she was in there in the first place - or walk up to Flack and Stella and they see if she's okay as well. As a memeber of their team, I'd assume they were worried about her as well.

It may have been ending on the hug and the silly freeze frame at the end (I loathe that technique) that bothered me so much. I don't mind that Danny was concerned for her, and the hug was a nice moment, but it made the end all about the bond between Danny and Lindsay and not about what she'd just done, which was pretty brave. I'm not a big Lindsay fan, but I'd like to see more of her independent of Danny. 60-70% of her character development has had to do with Danny, and that's kind of absurd if she's a main character and not a love interest. It's one thing for Peyton to interact mostly with Mac, but Lindsay is in the main credits. They gave her a cool scene and then undercut it by inserting Danny unnecessarily.

I am loving Det. Angell, already. Im really glad to see her again, cause Im really starting to like her but I also like that she wasn't afraid to mention her uneasiness about finding the corpse, to Mac. Peyton is getting a little more tolerable as well. She just seemed a little more laid back than in the premiere. Her accent calmed down a bit more too, which may have been a factor.

I really like them both. I love Angell's straightforwardness, and Peyton's easy confidence.

Correct me if Im wrong, but isn't Sid the head ME...? Wouldn't he be able to autopsy the corpse if he wanted to..?

I'm not sure if he's head ME or not...I've never heard it mentioned...
 
I've always love CSI:NY it had been my fav since it started. But I feel it is hitting it's stride this year. The changes made last year really helped and the cast that has been added this season help as well. I'm a shipper but I think they are pushing this Danny/Lindsay ship a little too fast. Maybe that is what they are bringing up next ep? But I like the relationship of equals in Mac & Payton.
 
^NY is my fav, too, though I do think the first season was superior to the second. I've liked the first two episodes of this season, though.

The Danny/Lindsay thing has been overkill from halfway through second season. I'd love them to put it to rest once and for all next week, but I kind of doubt it will happen that way.

I was surprised by how much I like the Mac/Peyton pairing! At first I was wary of the age gap, but the two have chemistry. It's a nice example of how creating a relationship that's natural and mature really works out quite well.
 
Top41 said:
It may have been ending on the hug and the silly freeze frame at the end (I loathe that technique) that bothered me so much. I don't mind that Danny was concerned for her, and the hug was a nice moment, but it made the end all about the bond between Danny and Lindsay and not about what she'd just done, which was pretty brave.

Oh, most definitely. I didn't like the freeze frame thing at all, I just saw it as .. unnecessary and kinda tacky.

And you're right, the fact that Lindsey did a selfless thing and risked her life was overlooked in the long run. The ending's main focus was D/L, and not Lindsey herself.

I'm not a big Lindsay fan, but I'd like to see more of her independent of Danny. 60-70% of her character development has had to do with Danny, and that's kind of absurd if she's a main character and not a love interest. It's one thing for Peyton to interact mostly with Mac, but Lindsay is in the main credits. They gave her a cool scene and then undercut it by inserting Danny unnecessarily.

Very true. In the first few episodes you can see her true character [from what little we knew about her at that point] but then when TPTB started the flirting and the looks and such, her character did a 180' and changed into someone different. She became less confident and more dependent on other people. They should've waited a while, and developed her character on its own before making her a "love interest".



I'm not sure if he's head ME or not...I've never heard it mentioned...

Im all curious now, I want to know who is :lol:
 
^^allstar, you are my hero. Lindsay's selfless act was completely overlooked in the face of pushing the ship as canon.

Top, like you, I do like the Mac/Peyton pairing. I also had my reservations about the age difference between them, but now that I have seen them together, I am completely sold on the pairing. She seems like a very good match for him, not cowing to him when they disagree on the outcome of the case. I love this.
 
Springmoon said:
^^allstar, you are my hero. Lindsay's selfless act was completely overlooked in the face of pushing the ship as canon.

Aw, shucks.

Since Top put the idea in my head, I think I'll share the glory with her :p
 
I really like the new season so far far
Mac seems a lot more cheerful and I'm likng Mac/Peyton more each episode.
I like Danny/Lindsay but the freeze frame seemed like a bit
too much
I loved Danny's little dog
 
allstar12 said:
Oh, most definitely. I didn't like the freeze frame thing at all, I just saw it as .. unnecessary and kinda tacky.

And you're right, the fact that Lindsey did a selfless thing and risked her life was overlooked in the long run. The ending's main focus was D/L, and not Lindsey herself.

Exactly! That silly freeze frame--an awful technique--took away from what should have been the focus, and that's that Lindsay essentially saved the day. It would have been bad enough if the two were a compelling couple, but the fact that they have no chemistry only compounds it. Still, even if they had overwhelming chemistry, it still would have been a bad move IMO.

Very true. In the first few episodes you can see her true character [from what little we knew about her at that point] but then when TPTB started the flirting and the looks and such, her character did a 180' and changed into someone different. She became less confident and more dependent on other people. They should've waited a while, and developed her character on its own before making her a "love interest".

Ageed, completely. She kind of got fixated on Danny towards the middle/end of the second season, and I don't think that did her character any justice. It's hard to introduce a new character once a show has already begun, and she was a controversial choice. I think they should have left Danny out of it initially, even if the plan down the road was to pair them up. It's been a case of too much too soon with these two.
 
I liked this episode. The beginning was especially well done and the blood diamonds brought a very serious and scary feel to it. Maybe it's because I was sitting in the dark though. Thought Carmine did very well in this episode. He brings all of Danny's insecurities and toughness across very well. You really felt his irritation that everyone was making a fuss over the dog.

Okay... I am unashamedly a D/L shipper, however that said I felt the part at the end with the hostage situation was rushed and also I felt the hug was kinda forced. It just didn't feel quite right. I think Danny is great at flirting and that's where the fun lies. But the caring just seemed forced. I don't know.. maybe the rest of the shippers hyped the hug up a bit so I was expecting more.. Lindsey looked confused to tell the truth.

Just my two cents.. I'm interested to see how TPTB play this out.
 
Loved the first scene, too. Very well played.

As for the last scene, I'm totally neutral about D/L but I agree with what has been said, it shouldn't have freeze-framed at that, uh, what's the word?, rather tacky ending. I thought the hug was sweet but prolonging it? Eyeballs, meet brain. Just not my cup of tea, sorry.

As for Mac/Peyton, well, my OTP is sMacked but I'm such a Macwhore I'd totally support anyone they ship with him (except maybe for Jane). Right now, I'm liking Peyton and I do see their chemistry (Peyton's such a flirt! Heh.) but for some reason...I'm not digging Claire Forlani. Oh well, two more eps to go before I really make up my mind.
 
Back
Top