CSI: New York--'And Here's To You, Mrs. Azrael'

CSI Files

Captain
Synopsis:

Nicole Garner and Heather Rollins, two young women in the prime of their lives, are in a terrible car crash after a night of drinking and partying. Heather is killed, but Nicole survived and comes out of her coma--only to be murdered in her hospital bed. Dr. Hammerback confirms that Nicole was suffocated. Dr. Hawkes talks to his former mentor and boss, Dr. Richards, who is taken aback by the surgeon turned coroner turned CSI's suggest that one of the hospital staff may have committed the murder. He's even more livid when they question Kevin Green, a janitor in the hospital responsible for maintaining the aquarium. Traces of fish food were found on Nicole's lips, but Kevin insists he was just helping her with her juice--not suffocating her. The case dredges up Hawkes' conflicted feelings about leaving the practice of medicine, but Danny reminds him he's still a doctor.

Stella gets a print from a bar of soap in Nicole's room that leads the CSIs to Matt Huxley, Nicole's boyfriend. Matt runs when Flack and Mac come to question him, but the detectives catch up to him. Matt admits he was in Nicole's room despite the fact that her mother had refused to let him see her. He and Nicole had made a pact after a classmate was paralyzed to "do what needed to be done" if the other was ever similarly injured. Matt visited with the intention of killing her, but wasn't able to go through with it. When he returns to the lab, Mac confers with Hawkes about Nicole's EKG, wondering why her heart rate never reached dangerous heights during the attack. Stella determines a blue plastic bag was the murder weapon, and the imprint of a St. Christopher medal leads the CSIs to Nicole's father, Frank Russo. Frank was estranged from Nicole's mother, Ellen, but he denies killing his daughter, even in mercy. He brought her a small teddy bear and is crushed to learn that the bag from his gift was used to kill his daughter.

Hawkes and Lindsay are surprised to discover 4 heart monitor sensors from Nicole's room where there should have only been three. The DNA on them matches to a maternal relative, and the CSIs question Ellen Garner, who had a life insurance policy out on her daughter. The defensive mother insists she did it because of Nicole's wild and dangerous lifestyle, and maintains she didn't kill her daughter. The DNA backs her up--Nicole's isn't a match for Ellen's--or Frank's. The CSIs are shocked to realize there may have been a grave mix-up, and that the two girls who looked so much alike may have been misidentified. They go back to the SUV Nicole and Heather were in and blood evidence reveals Heather was in fact the driver. The DNA on the fourth heart monitor--which the killer used to hook her own readings into the machine and avoid alerting the nurses to the distress of the girl in hospital bed--reveals that Julie Rollins, Heather's mother was the killer. She makes no bones about it when the CSIs tell her--she wanted revenge on Nicole for taking her daughter from her. Her righteousness turns to agony when they tell her that instead of killing Nicole, she actually killed her own daughter, Heather. The case closed, Hawkes leaves for the day only to come across a man who has been hit by a car. The doctor's quick intervention saves the man's life.

Analysis:

And here's to you, <font color=yellow>Peter M. Lenkov</font> for a truly excellent episode. From its clever title to its powerful conclusion, "And Here's to You, Mrs. Azrael" is a winner, that rare episode that melds a compelling case with terrific character backstory. It's about time we finally found out about Hawkes' career prior to his stint in the morgue. His character bio early in the series teased that two tragic deaths in surgery drove him into the morgue, but we saw him leave the morgue behind and head into the field with nary a mention of this. I'm happy to see some of Hawkes' feelings about his previous career finally revealed.

<HR ALIGN="CENTER" SIZE="1" WIDTH="45\%" COLOR="#007BB5">

To read the full reviews, please click here.<center></center>
 
I think CSI did a really good job of telling a ripped-from-the-headlines story but adding their own little twist to it.

While I pegged Julie as the murderer from the beginning (as Im sure many others did), finding out her (ultimately wrong) motive was pretty sad.

The scene where Mac said, "maybe Nicole isn't really Nicole," I immediately rememebered the story of the two girls from Indiana. It's such a gut wrenching and heartbreaking thing for both families to have gone through.

I liked the ending, where Hawkes got to show off his awesomeness and help out the cyclist. Im curious about that though, since he left the hospital and ME's office, is he still a doctor..? Or is he just not a general practitioner..?

Also, note to everyone: don't piss off Hawkes. He was kinda scary in this episode. He was so fierce and abrupt with the Chief of Staff (which is warranted and understandable). Kind of a side we've never really seen before; I loved it :D

I have give a nod to Lenkov for delivering exactly what the fans want: shirtless Danny
Amen! :lol:
 
^I figured Julie for the killer right away, too, but what I didn't see was the twist with the mix-up between the two girls, and that's what made the episode great. I recalled the case in Indiana, too, when they first suspected the mix-up. That made for one hell of a finale.

Hawkes is still a doctor, and I assume is still licensed? :confused: Not sure how all of that works, but it certainly seems he's kept up with his training.

I liked seeing Hawkes pissed off, too. There's an intensity there that was fun to see. I hope Hill gets more of that in future eps, because he was awesome.
 
You neglected to mention the wonderful scene with Sid inviting Mac to Thanksgiving dinner with his family. This was the first time I've seen the usually creepy but funny coroner show off his fatherly side toward Mac of all people. I also loved how Mac also teased Sid about eating a little more and then mentioning but not revealing that he had plans with Peyton.
 
^You're right, I did forget to mention that. I wouldn't quite call Sid's behavior fatherly--he and Mac are probably about the same age. But it did indicate there's a friendship there between the two. Robert Joy is just excellent as Sid--I really love him. :D
 
Back
Top