Ann Donahue: 'We Don't Think Actors Are Replaceable'

CSI Files

Captain
<font color=yellow>Ann Donahue</font> recently attended the Talent Managers Association's An Evening With CBS, where she took the opportunity to praise the actors of CSI.

The show was faced last year with criticism following the firings of <font color=yellow>George Eads</font> (Nick Stokes) and <font color=yellow>Jorja Fox</font> (Sara Sidle), but the Miami producer reassured the audience that every CSI actor is important. "I am very proud of the CSI franchise in that we don't think actors are replaceable, like some other franchises do," Donahue said. "We don't think they're interchangeable -- they're unique."

Donahue may have referred to the Law and Order franchise, where actors join and leave the show on a regular basis. Another source of instable work is the 11-year-old ER. Last year, the producers of the show did not renew <font color=yellow>Alex Kingston's</font> contract because they felt her character had, "run its course." The decision came as a surprise even to the actress, and had fans wondering if the letters ER stood for, "everyone's replaceable."

On CSI, however, the actors' contributions extend beyond the portrayal of their characters, which the producers feel makes them valuable assets to the development of the show. When <font color=yellow>William Petersen</font> found Gil Grissom to be too perfect, he remedied that by going straight to the top. "We were writing him as a hero," Donahue said of Grissom. "[Petersen] brought all the writers in a room [together], and he said, 'Can I be wrong?' And we're like, 'No, you're a star.' And he said, 'No, no--I mean in the script, can I be wrong?'"

Making Grissom imperfect worked better in the long run, and years later the producer doesn't hesitate in giving Petersen the credit. "It really opened up a lot for us that Billy was confident enough to know that there's more power and there's more drama in not always being right," Donahue added. "That speaks to the power that an actor has -- actors are usually the smartest ones in the room."

To read the rest of the article, which includes quotes from other CBS casting directors, visit Backstage.com.<center></center>
 
^^^^I love that show(Damage Control) (sorry my bad)

Anywho, I don't think that I would watch the show anymore if any of the orginal charators were replaced.
 
Right........ Two words: DAMAGE CONTROL.

In all fairness, Ann Donahue, or any other CSI producer, had very little say in those firings last year. The command came on down from the Network executives, who, interestingly enough, did not see the need in damage control of any kind, not to mention, damage itself.

Jane
 
Well that's nice to know..but hard to believe. The firings may not have been the writer's fault, but Anthony Zuiker's reaction to Fox's and Ead's firings was a shrug.."That's showbiz"..gee thanks buddy.

No wonder Petersen said that he would like to see the head of CBS - Less Moonves play a body on the autopsy table.

And she's on CSI Miami--who by the way killed off one of the characters because the actor had asked for more money.
 
Les Moonves is the the primary culprit for all of the tension last year with the firings of George and Jorja. Unfortunately, I think his ego will only get worse with the Viacom split and him getting the CBS portion.

As for Ann, she may now be showrunning CSI: Miami but she is one of the key reasons for CSI's success. I miss her writing for the show sooo much. Even though Anthony created the show, I think he's caught between pleasing Les and standing up for his original show. It's very unsual for a newbie to remain involved with the show they created so he may feel he has to toe the company line. Unfair but that's Hollywood. :(

--------------
LADY HEATHER: Don't take this the wrong way, but I think you've got everything
it takes to make a great Dominatrix.
 
CATHERINE: I take that as a compliment.
 
I don't think I could watch anymore if they replaced the actors. They play the characters a certain way, and I just don't see, for example, Grissom as anyone but Billy Peterson. It just wouldn't be right.
 
Back
Top