Search results

Re: CSI: NY Season 5 Spoiler Dicussion - Back in the Big Apple This Flack storyline sounds like it could be a good one. I hope the writers play it out over more than one episode, though, so they can give it some depth. Reading through that casting sheet makes me wonder if one of the IAB...

Yes, these ratings still look good despite the week-to-week drop. IIRC, Criminal Minds was also down, probably due to baseball as well. That's the positive thing -- CSI:NY seems to be tracking well with Criminal Minds, holding on to almost all the audience, and I didn't think that was the...

Thanks very much for the pictures and video! They all look good. :thumbsup: I especially like Melina K's dress and AJ Buckley's tie with the vest -- dressy but still unique. I don't know what the dress code for something like this would be, but when in doubt... I'd look for cues in...

I gave this episode a C+. There were a lot of moving pieces, much like last week, but this one didn't seem to fit together or flow as well. Some of the pieces just seemed like "extra" stuff that took up time but didn't enhance the case much. The premise of the case (identity switching)...

Re: CSI: NY Season 5 Spoiler Dicussion - Back in the Big Apple I think you are right -- that was my take as well on the reporting relationships. I really hope they aren't getting rid of Sinclair. I was starting to like his dynamic with Mac and looking forward to seeing more of the...

Grade = B+ From a writing perspective, I thought this episode was well-constructed and balanced. Using the doll plot to bring in some humor and also expose clues in the main case was cleverly done. And considering the number of characters involved, the writers still managed to give all the...

Re: Your Thoughts on the upcoming Danny/Lindsay development (SPOILERS! As someone who is rather indifferent to this couple, I admit I don't spend much time analyzing the deeper meanings or nuances to their interactions. That said, I don't really see Lindsay as consciously manipulative of...

I thought it was odd that Flack was there, too. If there were only three people in the room with Sid, I would've expected it to be Hawkes, Mac, and Stella based on the relationships previously shown. But I guess they wanted a male bonding scene and perhaps it was an indication that Flack is a...

I guess I'm in the minority on this one. Veritas was just an average type of episode to me, especially for a season premiere, so I gave it a "C." I think I expected a broader, more far-reaching case with more complex motivations, etc., but this just seemed like a bank robbery gone bad. And I...

I normally just lurk in this thread :o but had to de-lurk for a moment to comment on a couple of things.... I wholeheartedly agree and really wish Well, I gotta admit I was not a fan of Mac/Peyton. The timing felt wrong and it seemed like Mac and the audience were cheated out of...

I voted rarely. I usually don't take the time to watch summer reruns because of other priorities. And also with the DVD's coming out this Fall, I don't feel the urgency to see these episodes right away. I have watched a few scenes through On Demand, and I even have a few episodes on my...

Agree. I think it would really benefit Lindsay as a character if the writers would build some type of connections -- whether friendship, partnership, or even rivalry -- with others on the team. Maybe Stella would be a good choice -- it'd be nice if there were at least one strong female to female...

Glad to hear that Angell will be back.:) Thanks very much for the Veritas photos. Mac looks good. Guess that head injury's not too serious. Stella looks lovely -- especially the sunglasses and hair. And since I've complained about her shirts in the past, I'll admit that I like the white...

I had a difficult time deciding between options, but in the end, I went with the Minhaus incident, too (including the issue of defying Mac). As you indicated, that could've had serious ramifications for Danny's career and freedom. And even if he ended up being cleared, he had to know that...

Yay! Another storyline for Stella. I wonder if she'll learn more about her background and/or family. Looking forward to this one. That's a good way to describe it. I think the challenge for the writers with this type of pairing (where there may or may not be an eventual romance) is to keep...

It's possible...but I prefer the scenario where Rikki comes back because of some legal issues with Ruben's death or the theft of Danny's gun. I don't consider myself a SMACKed shipper either, but I do think Mac and Stella have nice chemistry and some part of me would enjoy seeing their...

Thanks for the spoilers! Interesting. It does seem the characters' personal relationships will be more outward-focused in S5. I just hope the relationship stuff stays mainly in the background relative to cases and that there are still meaningful interactions planned between the core...

Yes, miscasting could be an issue, but I've also wondered whether the producers had a good idea of what they wanted to do with the character early on. Did they intend from the start to have Lindsay as a romantic interest for Danny? If so, seems they would've spent significant time testing them...

Just my two cents on Lindsay.... I don't hate the character but have never really warmed up to her and am rather indifferent at this point. My impression (and I don't know if it's correct) is that LIndsay, as initially conceived, was supposed to provide a more youthful, girlish, small town...

I have to put an asterisk with my answer because there are still a few season 4 episodes I haven't seen yet, which may be contenders. Of the ones I've seen, though, I have to go with "Time's Up." This one just didn't make sense to me. Even with the explanation about the professor's enhanced...