CSI: New York--'The Ride In'

CSI Files

Captain
Synopsis:

After consoling Stella Bonasera, who is anxiously awaiting the result of an HIV test after cutting herself at a crime scene with bloody glass, Mac heads off to a house in Rockaway Beach, where Noah Hubler has been found dead in a pile of money, the victim of a fatal gunshot wound. The real surprise is in Noah's backyard, where an ark full of both animals and people sits, awaiting the big flood, which according to the faithful is due in on the upcoming Sunday. Dr. Hammerback is surprised to discover a pair of surgical scissors in Noah's body, the remnants of a shoddy gastric bypass procedure. Flack questions Jackie DeMartino, who left several angry messages on Noah's machine, but she claims he conned her out of ten thousand dollars. Sure enough, Flack does some digging around and learns "Noah" is actually Patrick Dent, wanted in several cities on fraud charges. He escaped custody several months prior to his death with the help of a woman dressed in disguise as a police officer. Danny questions another woman Patrick Dent conned, Melodee Costanza, whose boot prints were found at Noah's house. Melodee admits to going to try to get her money back, but Noah claimed to have spent all the money from his cons on the ark and when Melodee spotted the giant boat, she realized he was telling the truth and left in disgust.

Stella and Dr. Hawkes are on the case of a man wearing a cigarette costume found dead, his costume charred from fire, in front of a cigarette company, National Spirit Tobacco. The man was apparently protesting smoking, and the CSIs track down a hookah bar manager he had an altercation with, but the man denies doing anything other than pushing their victim. When Stella goes to the morgue to talk to Sid, she finds him passed out from anaphylactic shock and not breathing and gives him mouth in order to revive him. Stella and Hawkes turn to National Spirit when a cigarette found near their dead man turns out to be a prototype of Spirit Green, a new cigarette with less nicotine not yet on the market. The CSIs question the CEO and are shocked to learn the Jason Williams was actually a National Spirit employee spearheading a unique marketing campaign. A gym bag found at the scene leads the CSIs to Heidi Pesco, a young woman who works at a pretzel stand--in costume. Heidi was attacked two nights ago, and she shows the CSIs bite marks on her neck to prove it. The marks lead Stella and Hawkes to a man dressed in a vampire costume who was trying to get costume greeters to unionize. He got violent with those that didn't support his plan, attacking Heidi Pesco and setting fire to the unfortunate Jason Williams. Stella goes to Hammerback to tell him about her possible HIV status and his potential risk for infection, but he cuts her off and reminds her she saved his life.

When the CSIs learn the money Patrick was found in was counterfeit, they track down the counterfeiter, Jim Eisberg Easman, currently doing time in jail. He tells them he stashed the bills in his car after getting caught, and that the car was sold in a police auction--apparently to one of Patrick's followers. Mac tells Danny that the surgical tool in Patrick's body had given him a rampant infection, causing him to be delusional. The ark wasn't just another scene; Patrick really believed in it. Flack is able to ID Patrick's partner, the bogus detective who helped him escape custody in New Orleans, as none other than Jackie DeMartino. Jackie and Patrick had been partners prior to Patrick's surgery, but after he began to spout scripture, they parted ways. Jackie demanded her cut of their profits, but when she learned the bills were counterfeit she confronted Patrick and shot him. She thought he was lying when he said he didn't know about the bills being fake, but Mac tells her he wasn't.

Analysis:

There's a good deal of sly humor in "The Ride In," which is what makes it easy to overlook some of the improbabilities in the cases, such as why anyone would attack people for not joining his union, or how a guy building an ark could go unnoticed by the media. Or how a pair of surgical scissors could end up in a man without him knowing. (A tiny piece of metal, sure. But an actual pair of scissors?) But "The Ride In" is so tongue-in-cheek, so wry, that it seems almost ill-humored not to sit back an enjoy the ride.

<HR ALIGN="CENTER" SIZE="1" WIDTH="45\%" COLOR="#007BB5">

To read the full reviews, please click here.<center></center>
 
Excellent review as always. :) There were definitely some great character moments, but I need to rewatch it to understand all of the details of the cases themselves. :lol:

A tiny nitpick plus a question, though. ;) (You love me, I know it, so you won't mind. :p)

How likely is it that the lead female character in a CSI show will end up being HIV positive.
Unless I'm reading it wrong, shouldn't that have a question mark instead of a period? :)

That's the only thing I saw that might be a 'mistake,' but of course I could miss something. ;)

Also, here's my question:

Usually it's the "case cracking evidence," but for this episode, it was actually the killer.
Do they have different questions in different places? I usually see 'who was the killer' for the case, complete with pictures, but I belive this week it was 'what was the motive' instead. This is interesting... :lol:
 
Hi! Just wanted to comment on your excellent review. I completely agree with your assessment of the always wonderful Melina, and love that you recognize the greatness that is Robert Joy. Usually the kooky ME with wince-inducing sexual tales that make us chuckle, he was incredible in the scene with Stella. I'm so delighted that the writers seem to recognize the gem they have in Robert Joy, and possibly the impressive fan response to his character (at least the sites I frequent).

As for the cases. They kind of made my eyes roll as well, and only the snark made it ok for me ... "good ship looney tunes" anyone? Gotta love Flack.

On the scissors - Sadly, it's possible. I used to work in the medical field and you wouldn't believe some of the stuff I heard about.

Great job as always.
 
Great analysis of the show! I chalked this one down as a "fun" episode as well. Each week the flow of the show with the current cast gets better and better(sorry Lindsay!). I love the one liners they give to the character of Flack (and lately more and more to the character of Danny as well). The humour on this show is witty without being sarcastic. I think they have fantastic writers on this show. Out of all three CSI show's, this one is my favourite. I think the writing is great.
 
The other day they had a segment on the news (maybe it was the local news around here?) about leaving surgical instruments/surgical sponges/etc inside of patients. It definitely makes you paranoid about going under the knife. :eek:
 
Having worked on a surgical floor, my advice is to ALWAYS take a permanent marker and put 'yes' on the correct side/body part. While we never made that mistake (because we required all our patients be marked this way), you would be surprised how many people have it happen. We also required out surgery nurses to so an instrument count before and after surgery, to make sure nothing got left in patients. Also something that happens on a frighteningly often basis.
 
Thanks guys! :D And now I'm thinking if I ever need surgery, I'll just go without. :lol: ;) Seriously, scissors? Those things looked massive! Wow.

Fay, good catch--will correct tonight! Not bad for a long one, but this one was written during daytime hours, which may have helped. ;)

And yeah, we must have gotten totally different CSI Q questions! I've never gotten one with the killer before. What the hell? Not a fan. My roommate and I always laugh at it, but this time it seemed pretty bad.

audrina said:
Hi! Just wanted to comment on your excellent review. I completely agree with your assessment of the always wonderful Melina, and love that you recognize the greatness that is Robert Joy. Usually the kooky ME with wince-inducing sexual tales that make us chuckle, he was incredible in the scene with Stella. I'm so delighted that the writers seem to recognize the gem they have in Robert Joy, and possibly the impressive fan response to his character (at least the sites I frequent).

Robert Joy is seriously great. He can play the deadpan humor so well, but also brings a lot of heart and gravitas to the show. I love how he interacted with Stella in that scene. He said all the right things, and the lines were delivered perfectly.

As for the cases. They kind of made my eyes roll as well, and only the snark made it ok for me ... "good ship looney tunes" anyone? Gotta love Flack.

I know I mention it in pretty much every review, but Flack's humor kills me. The lines are fantastic and Eddie's delivery is so, so on the money. The writers must have so much fun coming up with those lines for him, and he really comes through with them.
 
And yeah, we must have gotten totally different CSI Q questions! I've never gotten one with the killer before. What the hell? Not a fan. My roommate and I always laugh at it, but this time it seemed pretty bad.
I'm pretty sure this is the first time that ours wasn't 'who is the killer?' :rolleyes: It's especially annoying when they show someone you haven't even seen on the show yet and you're like 'well, that'll be him.' Or when they don't show someone and then you know they can't be the killer even if they look guilty as sin. Like in "Obsession," I believe it was--that woman who was 'kidnapped' looked so guilty, but because she wasn't one of the choices, I knew she couldn't have done it.

That game must die. Srsly.
 
Faylinn said:
I'm pretty sure this is the first time that ours wasn't 'who is the killer?' :rolleyes: It's especially annoying when they show someone you haven't even seen on the show yet and you're like 'well, that'll be him.' Or when they don't show someone and then you know they can't be the killer even if they look guilty as sin. Like in "Obsession," I believe it was--that woman who was 'kidnapped' looked so guilty, but because she wasn't one of the choices, I knew she couldn't have done it.

That game must die. Srsly.

Oh, ugh. That would have pissed me off big time. The killer one last night was the first one we got.

Blame the network--I'm sure this one has nothing to do with the creative team behind the show.
 
Maybe NY should consider making Robert Joy a main cast member and quit having Angell and Adam taking away Hawkes' and Flack's (and Belknap's when she's there) screentime.
 
chemgeek said:
Maybe NY should consider making Robert Joy a main cast member and quit having Angell and Adam taking away Hawkes' and Flack's (and Belknap's when she's there) screentime.

Making Robert Joy a main cast member is a great idea. I don't think Angell and Adam's few moments on screen take away from Hawkes and Flack's screentime--they just make a big splash when they are on screen, which might make it seem like they're on more than they actually are.

Dumping Belknap, though, would do wonders for the show. The cast has been amazingly cohesive without her, and the show much stronger for her absence.
 
Back
Top