Search results

  1. P

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    I don't know how old she is supposed to be, but her real age is 35 or 36 and personally I think she looks at least that old and with the new hairstyle I actually thinks she looks older. If she was brought in to be young and hip then I am guessing she is supposed to be late 20's, but I think she...
  2. P

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    I would tend to agree with this and I think it is a huge problem in terms of her ability to interest me at all in her character. If they were going for warm and approachable and I think that was and is the intention, they fell far short of the mark with their casting choice. Now perhaps Anna is...
  3. P

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    I have to second this. I read in other threads and I think someone has probably said it in this thread that Lindsay/Anna is warm and brings a softness to the show, but I really don't see it. I think Melina/Stella brings much more warmth and compassion and a softness when it is called for than...
  4. P

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    I completely agree that there is no chemistry between Danny and Lindsay and that it has always seemed forced. I do wonder if they had just left her the way she was in Season 2 and not tried to give her a lot of drama (e.g. the deep dark secret and a rocky relationship), if I would be as annoyed...
  5. P

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    I don't think they would go the romantic route with Mac and Lindsay either --- as others have said that would just be ridiculous. However, I could see TPTB trying to return what little credibility the character had back to Lindsay after the debacle of this season by having her play off of Gary...
  6. P

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    Would everyone please stop trying to force Lindsay onto Mac! :scream: :lol: I've read a number of times on the boards over time that the only one people see that Lindsay has chemistry with is Mac. Frankly, I don't see it. And I really don't want Mac to be the new Lindsay prop. I love the...
  7. P

    CSI:NY Season 5 Spoilers Discussion - Start Spreadin' The News!

    That is too funny! I love it. I would really hate if they put Lindsay and Hawkes in a relationship so I am glad Hill said it wouldn't be with Lindsay. I had a hard time buying that Danny would be interested in someone like Lindsay, but to try to swallow that two men at her workplace think she is...
  8. P

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    Also miscast because, in reality, from what I have read here anyway, Anaa is only 5 years younger than Melina. If the hope was for her to be a young fun character to contrast with Stella (who I think comes across as more fun than Lindsay :)), they should have gone that route by having someone...
  9. P

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    I completely agree with this. Also there has been some mention of how she has a bachelor's and a master's in acting with the implication being that she must be good. But, how many of us went to school with people who got their degrees by the skin of their teeth. They still have those degrees...
  10. P

    Season 5 Wishlist

    Couldn't agree more. I agree with the others who have said that they like it if the show made a move back to its Season 1 roots when the cases were a bit grittier and more realistic because they tended to deal with people who were more real and from different walks of life and because the...
  11. P

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    I agree that she is a very weak character and I don't understand why she still has a job either. The writers don't seem to know what they want to do with her (possibly because she can't handle anything but the lightest scenes and even those she doesn't do that well) and the actress doesn't...
  12. P

    Grade 'Hostage'

    This is going to be a completely shallow post so my apologies. I thought it, too. Also, at the beginning of the episode when Flack was telling the released hostage to come to him, was anyone else thinking "I'll come to you Flack!" Brett was the guy from Homeland Security that told Stella...
  13. P

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    I agree with this completely. I am sad that I dislike a character in this show so much. Most times she comes on screen she takes me out of the show and it is annoying. I really don't understand her appeal as a character to so many people. There are other characters in shows that I don't like...
  14. P

    CSI: NY Season 4 Spoilers! Discussion in the Big Apple

    That might be a very interesting story line -- if it were done well without it being overly dramatized and if didn't overtake the show. Because, while I do like the character involvement on this show and not following protocol or orders should have consequences, ultimately I want good cases and...
  15. P

    Flack/Stella #2 - "When You Drive, We Don't Eat."

    Re: Flack/Stella #2 - "When You Drive, We Don't Eat." I thought Stella and Flack were great working together in the last episode. They have a good chemistry when working. It would be nice to see them working together one-on-one more often. They should definitely do more interrogations together.
  16. P

    Ooops, What a mistake!

    That bugged me about Stella's foster mother as well. And Anna definitely looks at least 35. They really play with the ages on this show. They also did this with Mac's character. He and Drew Bedford weren't supposed to be that far apart in age if I remember correctly. Yeah, right :rolleyes:
  17. P

    Was Lindsay's Anger Justified?

    I don't think Lindsay was justified in her anger for many of the same reasons as others have posted, so I won't reiterate. But in my mind, she has now actually added to his hurting. She is making him feel bad for not turning to her. Why would you add that kind of burden to someone you love who...
  18. P

    CSI: New York--'Personal Foul'

    It was arguably an opportunity for Danny and Lindsay to get closer and I understand her disappointment, but saying that he "should" have talked to Lindsay so that they would get closer is, in my opinion, wrong. There are no should haves in this situation. It is natural for Danny to talk with the...
  19. P

    Unhappy Lindsay Fans over Kristine Huntley reviews harsh words.

    Everything you said here with the exception of the fact that, iirc, it is cannon that Mac hired her because she is supposedly very thorough, is opinion and as such is debatable and everyone is entitled to an opinion. I think the writers write the character to be smart as they wrote all of the...
  20. P

    Unhappy Lindsay Fans over Kristine Huntley reviews harsh words.

    She is a reviewer and reviews are necessarily from one person's perspective -- the reviewer's. So, if she doesn't think Anna is a good actress and doesn't like the character of Lindsay, why do you think you have a right to demand that she say nice things? And, it isn't rudeness to state your...
Back
Top