Search results

  1. S

    Switch of scenes in episode 4x19

    Switched scenes or not, what we got for canon is what we got. Whatever the original intent was, the writers and/or TPTB decided that a switch needed to be made, and I agree with their choice. From a storytelling and character perspective it was the better choice. The ending was far more...
  2. S

    Dear Writers... (Have something you want to say?)

    Fay, we may not agree on much, but that was hilarious!:guffaw: Dear Writers, Please do not continue to use Flack as the 'stupid cop' who knows nothing, cannot come up with a decent suspect, and who must have everything explained to him like he is a moron. He couldn't have made detective if he...
  3. S

    Switch of scenes in episode 4x19

    Honestly I hadn't thought about the switching scenes, but to me it doesn't make a difference at all. Either order of the scenes makes absolute sense, although the choice they made for canon makes better sense to me. Scenario One: The Canon Scenario Danny's depression when he's talking to...
  4. S

    Grade 'Taxi'

    I only rated the episode a B, and I think I'm being generous. I was not overly impressed with Angell saving Flack because I find it hard to believe that Angell would have enough muscle to shove Flack's 6'2" frame up and over a car and be carried with it. Also, I want to know why Flack has...
  5. S

    Do you think there's any chance Lindsay knows about Rikki?

    I can't imagine that Lindsay wouldn't know about it, and obviously Flack isn't that protective of Danny if he told Angell about it. There's no way they could have kept that a secret anyway. Mac and Stella probably know about it as well.
  6. S

    Grade 'Personal Foul'

    Top41 wrote: One of the things you've pointed out numerous times is how Danny doesn't seem to feel the same way as Lindsay does about him, right? I think based on how he's been treating her she may have realized this as well. So the question really becomes why would --or more, why should--...
  7. S

    Do you think there's any chance Lindsay knows about Rikki?

    I don't think Lindsay has any idea about Rikki. I do think she knows something is still off with Danny and that's one of the reasons why she's pushing him away at the moment.
  8. S

    Grade 'Personal Foul'

    I have to agree with JellyBelly's assessment of Lindsay's feelings about Danny. I suspect strongly that Lindsay knows something is still not quite right with Danny. I think I can explain the alone part of her conversation, too. Danny basically shut himself off from her. From what we've seen...
  9. S

    GLBT - Four letters not found in CSI:NY

    If I thought the storyline would be handled appropriately, I wouldn't have any objections to it. The problem is, as much as I love the writers, they just suck at romance. I haven't been inspired by any of the romances they've presented us with thus far, and the only relationship they've managed...
  10. S

    GLBT - Four letters not found in CSI:NY

    I don't really have a problem with there not being more homosexual issues/characters on television. It's not that I don't care about the issues or that I dislike one type of sexuality or another, I just don't care if it's in a fictional show or not. Especially a show like CSI, where I am far...
  11. S

    Character flaws, foibles, annoyances and aggravations

    Well, MacsLady, I suppose since your name lays claim to him I should give you first dibs. But I definitely want him when your done, right? So no hogging him. It really was an impressive explosion. And fun since I don't know how he managed to walk away from another explosion with very few...
  12. S

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    Faylinn You can answer this in the Danny thread, but what changed your opinion on Danny's character if he annoyed you in the first season? I'm not asking to argue; I'm asking because I too did not like Danny in Season One. Question for everyone: Are we saying then that physical attraction has...
  13. S

    Character flaws, foibles, annoyances and aggravations

    It kind of started with Hawkes bashing and went on from there. :p We decided to see how nasty we could be about Lindsay then, and we moved on to Danny and Flack and then Mac and Stella. I said that we had to be fair, so so Adam had to be abused in some fashion, and then Sid. I digress again...
  14. S

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    Look, I don't want to be disrespectful, but that's NOT what I was saying. I own up to what I say. If I wanted to suggest that people dislike Lindsay only because she's dating Danny, I would say it. If you want me to be totally honest, I will. I think that there is probably at least one person...
  15. S

    Mac/Flack Slash**Squeeze My Hand**

    This is my favorite slash pairing. How can it not be? Two sexy, hot-tempered men in a relationship with each other? :drool: And it can so easily be made into canon. It's all in the subtext, right? So what is everyone's favorite Flack/Mac moment? I'm still pondering my own. Cein, are you...
  16. S

    Character flaws, foibles, annoyances and aggravations

    I'm not sure what mixed signals she sent him. She was pretty consistent in showing him that she didn't want to get too close to him. Towards the end of season three she began to relax more and more around him, almost kisses him, and then finally they end up on his pool table. In Season Four...
  17. S

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    I really wasn't trying to be insulting. There are studies out there that demonstrate how physical appearance does indeed have bearing on how people are judged. --Taken from here: http://www.cnn.com/2005/US/Careers/07/08/looks/ And a link to a discussion on the doctor's Physical...
  18. S

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    Canon according to who? Your version of canon doesn't fit my version of canon, and my canon doesn't fit my best friend's version of canon. Even with it being on screen, we all see things differently. For example, let's take a recent example. In "All in the Family", I found Lindsay to be very...
  19. S

    Why Lindsay Must Go (Part 3)

    I would agree with you, except that I do recall a thread that was started where people talked about why Lindsay should stay, and the gauntlet was tossed down. "Prove it", someone demanded. Use canon arguments to prove why Lindsay should stay. And you couldn't say Lindsay was pretty or had nice...
  20. S

    Anna/Lindsay thread #4 - "You've got friends, kiddo!"

    Re: Anna/Lindsay thread #4 - "You've got friends, kiddo!" Or maybe it's more of a height issue. :lol: Lindsay is the shortest member of the cast. Flack is like two feet (ok, not quite that much) taller than she is. Maybe it's an issue of trying to get them both in the screen at the same time. Of...
Back
Top