RSS iconTwitter iconFacebook icon

Talk CSI title image

Talk CSI STATISTICS

Threads: 17,481
Posts: 1,203,636
Members: 11,306
Currently online: 63
Newest member: terpsichore


Welcome! Talk CSI is the number one place to chat about all the CSI shows with like-minded fans. Please login to see our full range of forums as well as the ability to send and receive private messages, track your favourite topics and of course join in the discussions.

If you are a new visitor, join us for free. If you are an existing member please login below. Note: for members who joined under our old messageboard system, please login with your display name not your login name.


Go Back   Talk CSI > Grissom's Office > CSI Files News Items

CSI Files News Items Discussion of news articles from CSI Files.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old February 5 2009, 03:05 AM   #1
CSI Files
CSI Level Three
 
CSI: Miami--'Smoke Gets In Your CSIs'

Synopsis:

Calleigh and Ryan follow up on a call at a foreclosed house where a neighbor has smelled a foul odor. The pair discovers the body of a man in the attic, but before they can remove him, someone starts firing through the floor at them! The shots stop, only to be followed by an explosion below, which starts a fire. Ryan rushes out and moves to pull Calleigh to safety, but she refuses to leave without the body. The two pull the body out of the fire, coughing as they rush to safety. After the fire is put out, Horatio and Delko examine the scene. The body has no ID, and there are no witnesses to his death. Delko suspects the killer came back and set the fire to destroy the evidence of his crime. Delko finds a business card in the debris for a man named Jeff Peralta, who claims he was simply contemplating buying the house. He tells Horatio he doesn't recognize the victim. In the morgue, Dr. Price determines the victim was killed by a gunshot wound to the head the night before. She recovers some skin scrapings from under his fingernails, which DNA analysis proves belong to a man named Colin Astor. Astor claims he played basketball with the victim, but his questioning is cut short when Calleigh falls victim to a coughing fit. She collapses and is rushed to a hospital in an ambulance, Delko at her side. When they arrive, Alexx Woods, now working as a doctor at Dade General, meets them at the entrance. She is forced to put a tube in Calleigh's throat to help her breathe, and tells Horatio that Calleigh's respiratory problems are serious.

Lab tech Kevin Landau goes over the bullets recovered from the victim's body. The fatal shot came from a 9 millimeter gun and has no matches in IBIS, but the ones from the shooter who fired at Calleigh and Ryan are .45s, a match to a gun used in a robbery four months ago that was tied to a man named Ricky Gannon. Horatio, Ryan and several officers catch Gannon after an intense chase. Gannon admits he was squatting in the foreclosed house--and dealing heroin. Fearing the cops were there for him, he tried to shoot at them and then cause a fire by heating aluminum in the microwave. He denies killing the dead man, referring to him as "Doc" and noting that Doc was his best client. When they learn "Doc" paid for his heroin with prescriptions from Dade General, Ryan calls Delko and asks him to take a trip to the hospital's pharmacy. Delko reluctantly leaves Calleigh's bedside after putting his watch on her wrist to talk to the pharmacist, Teresa Vance. She identifies the dead doctor as Don Phelps and admits that they were sleeping together and that he had access to the pharmacy. She turns over Phelps' address, and Ryan and Horatio find it to be a large warehouse-like space. When they go in, they find what appears to be an underground operating room, complete with instruments and a table. Natalia and Ryan spray luminol over the plastic curtains, the table and the instruments and find large amounts of blood. Though it's clear the area has been cleaned with bleach, Ryan manages to find several blood smudges under the operating table.

Horatio talks to Wendy Kramer, the woman whose blood was under the table, and she tells him she needed a kidney and was on a long waiting list. Dr. Phelps offered her a quicker option--and saved her life. At Dade General, Delko asks Alexx for the kidney transporter. She refuses to turn over the box, noting that it could cost a life if it's not there when a kidney comes in, but she allows him to print it. He uses some materials in the hospital to get a print, which leads the team back to Colin Astor. Astor admits to being Phelps' assistant and tracking down people willing to sell kidneys for Phelps' procedures. He says Phelps' heroin habit cost the life of a patient, and tells the CSIs where they can find the body of the man who died during the transplant. After the body is recovered, the man is identified as Mauricio Colero. Dr. Price removes several staples from the incision Phelps' made, and Ryan recalls cutting himself in the attic on a similar staple. Tissue from the donor kidney leads the team back to Jeff Peralta. Horatio confronts the man, who is clearly in severe pain, and notes the incision in his belly. He admits to selling his kidney to Phelps, but he tells Horatio that after the operation, he was in agony. He followed Phelps to the foreclosed home and went to confront him, but the doctor refused to help him. Enraged, Peralta forced Phelps into the attic and shot him. Back at the hospital, Calleigh wakes up, able to breathe on her own. A relieved Delko returns to her side and promises to stay. Horatio asks Alexx how she's doing, and the former ME invites him over for dinner with her family.

Analysis:

When I first saw the title "Smoke Gets in Your CSIs," I laughed. I still can't decide whether it's the best episode title so far this season or the goofiest. Like "Won't Get Fueled Again" or last season's "CSI: My Nanny", it's a clever little wink at the fans. Sure, they're a bit on the irreverent side, but I do enjoy the wordplay and the fact that the show doesn't take itself too seriously. There tend to be fewer joking interplay moments between the characters in Miami than in the other two CSI shows, so the humorous titles allow the writers to have a bit of fun without taking any tension away from the story itself. Though the title "Smoke Gets in Your CSIs" is a pretty funny one, the episode itself is serious, with the amount of smoke Calleigh got in her lungs in the house endangering her life, and the case tying back into an organ-selling scam.

Calleigh has certainly had a rough time of it these last few seasons. While bringing evidence back in the Hummer, she was forced off the road by a suspect in season five's "Going Under". In season six, she was almost run over and killed in "Stand Your Ground". Several episodes later, she was kidnapped in the two-parter "Ambush" and "All In" and forced by two men to clean up a crime scene. This time around, she chooses to go back for the body rather than to rush to safety as Ryan clearly thinks they need to, and it's a decision that jeopardizes her life. The severity of her reaction to the smoke contrasted with Ryan's also felt off. I realize Calleigh was in the attic longer than Ryan was, but how is it that she's in the hospital fighting for her life while Ryan is literally sprinting after suspects? Because her exposure was longer, I'd expect Calleigh to be worse off than Ryan, but the discrepancy between them seems too great. And after Calleigh was taken to the hospital, wouldn't Ryan have been ordered there as well, if for no other reason than to be checked out so that Horatio could be sure that another member of his team wouldn't collapse during an interrogation?


To read the full reviews, please click here.

CSI Files is offline   Reply With Quote
Old February 5 2009, 04:26 AM   #2
Faylinn
Adam Fangirl
 
Faylinn's Avatar
 
Re: CSI: Miami--'Smoke Gets In Your CSIs'

Great review, as usual.

The case itself was interesting, although I'm not sure I like seeing JJ's baby daddy as a baddie. (JJ being a character on Criminal Minds, which Josh Stewart guest stars on as, you know, her baby daddy. )

The severity of her reaction to the smoke contrasted with Ryan's also felt off. I realize Calleigh was in the attic longer than Ryan was, but how is it that she's in the hospital fighting for her life while Ryan is literally sprinting after suspects?
Yeah - I get that she might have had it worse, but it's a stretch to try to get me to buy that he's peachy keen. I thought Eric might ask him if he was alright when he called while still a bit out of breath - Calleigh had trouble breathing before she collapsed, so I thought hearing Ryan out of breath might have made Eric wonder why. I don't think Ryan said, 'So, I just chased this guy down' before they talked. But eh, I guess the romantz angle was more important than the realism angle (although I'm talking about a CSI show, so there you go ).

Speaking of Teh Romantz - they need to sh*t or get off the pot. I'm tired of the will they/won't they nonsense. Pick a direction and go with it. Either they get together or they decide not to or whatever - but I'm tired of the back and forth stuff. How long are they going to drag this out? *facepalm*

Anyway, it was a decent episode overall. I did enjoy seeing Alexx back on the show - at least they didn't bring her back to off her, a la Aiden.
__________________
Faylinn is offline   Reply With Quote
Old February 5 2009, 08:51 PM   #3
Finch
Funnier in Enochian
 
Finch's Avatar
 
Location: Retro Motel Room
Re: CSI: Miami--'Smoke Gets In Your CSIs'

Originally Posted by Faylinn
The case itself was interesting, although I'm not sure I like seeing JJ's baby daddy as a baddie. (JJ being a character on Criminal Minds, which Josh Stewart guest stars on as, you know, her baby daddy. )
That's where I've seen him! Thanks. That was bugging me during the entire episode.

Speaking of Teh Romantz - they need to sh*t or get off the pot. I'm tired of the will they/won't they nonsense. Pick a direction and go with it. Either they get together or they decide not to or whatever - but I'm tired of the back and forth stuff. How long are they going to drag this out? *facepalm*
Agreed. I don't mind the E/C romance either way but the 'will they/won't they' stuff is starting to annoy. And usually Miami is so great for 'rush rush rush through everything' type storylines. But I suppose some might like that they're taking this much time to develop it.

Originally Posted by Review
When I first saw the title "Smoke Gets in Your CSIs," I laughed. I still can't decide whether it's the best episode title so far this season or the goofiest. Like "Won't Get Fueled Again" or last season's "CSI: My Nanny" it's a clever little wink at the fans. Sure, they're a bit on the irreverent side, but I do enjoy the wordplay and the fact that the show doesn't take itself too seriously. There tend to be fewer joking interplay moments between the characters in Miami than in the other two CSI shows, so the humorous titles allow the writers to have a bit of fun without taking any tension away from the story itself
I'm glad you brought up the play on words with the various titles this year. They've been getting pretty creative and these titles will probably be memorable to many fans. A lot of the time, I remember an episode just because of the title names so it's great that we've been getting these silly ones lately. And like you said above, it shows they don't take themselves too seriously.

Although I have to admit, 'CSI:My Nanny' took the cake for me.

Excellent review.

Last edited by Leviathan; February 5 2009 at 08:58 PM.
Finch is offline   Reply With Quote
Old February 6 2009, 01:01 AM   #4
koshi700
Dead on Arrival
 
Re: CSI: Miami--'Smoke Gets In Your CSIs'

Yeah, the episode was okay, it wasn't nearly as exciting as I thought it was going to be though. I had figured the ep was going to tie into the previous ep and instead it was about some druggie doctor working the organ black market. It fell a little flat for me. And was it just me or did the episode feel a bit disjointed? I was able to follow it for the most part but it felt unorganized.

I have to agree about the absurdness of Ryan being able to literally chase down a supspect while Calleigh was laying close to death in the hospital. It was very unrealistic to me. I was wondering why neither Ryan or Calleigh were checked out to begin with, it should never have been able to progress that far. And I'm sorry but if I was in charge of two people who had been in a fire and one of them collapses due to breathing issues, I'm sure as heck going to have the other one checked out too. For someone who is supposed to care deeply for his team Horatio seems rather disconnected from them at times.

I love Ryan, he is my favorite character on the show, of all of them I think he's the most interesting. But I wanted to smack him because after he cut his hand on the staple he sucks on it! I was like, you moron! You are surround by blood and you have just scratched your hand so you suck on it? *rolls eys*

And I love Calleigh too and I know she was just trying to save the evidence, but I'm sorry, you don't put your own life plus the life of your partner at risk to pull an already dead body out of a rapidly burning building. That was not her brightest move.

Anyways, I was disappointed in the episode, I felt they could have done so much more with it. *sigh*
koshi700 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old February 6 2009, 08:20 PM   #5
BlueDiamondStar
Coroner
 
BlueDiamondStar's Avatar
 
Location: under the carpet
View BlueDiamondStar's Twitter Profile Send a message via ICQ to BlueDiamondStar Send a message via AIM to BlueDiamondStar Send a message via MSN to BlueDiamondStar Send a message via Yahoo to BlueDiamondStar
Re: CSI: Miami--'Smoke Gets In Your CSIs'

i haven't seen this episode but i aggree that if the pair goes in this situation and one later collapses the other should be checked too.
and i also thought that Horatio should take more responsibility about his team if he cares what happens to them.
but i'm not blaming writers about this little mistake
BlueDiamondStar is offline   Reply With Quote
Old August 25 2009, 06:22 PM   #6
RoscoeTrek
Rookie
 
RoscoeTrek's Avatar
 
Location: Roscoe Street
View RoscoeTrek's Twitter Profile
Re: CSI: Miami--'Smoke Gets In Your CSIs'

SOMEONE BRING ALEXX BACK!!!

I loved the wordplay with the title, and i agree that CSI: My Nanny was the best title so far.

It was scary to see Calleigh gasp for air when she collapsed into Delko's arms. Liked the way Delko showed his resourcefulness in taking the prints and cracking the case.

Though the episode wasn't as exciting as I wished it would be, it was a nice glimpse into the personal world of our beloved CSIs!
RoscoeTrek is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump



All times are GMT. The time now is 05:11 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.